User: Mehdi, Location: United States
Asked on: Wednesday, September 25, 2024 at 1:50 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 2:56 am EST
Question: I am working on a project where I have 3 enclosures (MCC 380V, 24V DC PLC Control Panel and 24 VDC Operator Control Panel). We never done this before. All enclosures are NEMA 12/ IP52. I have few questions, and your answers will help me to understand and learn in deep.1. Where I can rea code for C1, D2, G C&D?2. Does all of them require purge enclosure? Or we can say 24VDC doesn't require.3. As all of these are in hazardous location but different rooms and control one machine, how should I control purge system, individually or one main will cut power for all other enclosures.I hope you will understand my questions. Thank you.
Okay, this is a multifaceted problem related to electrical enclosures in hazardous locations. Let's break down each of your questions, and I'll provide information to guide you. However, I have to preface this with a very important disclaimer
Disclaimer: I am an AI chatbot. I cannot provide definitive engineering advice. Working with electrical systems in hazardous locations requires in-depth knowledge of applicable codes and standards and should only be done by qualified and certified professionals. My responses are for informational purposes only and should not be considered a substitute for professional engineering advice.
With that out of the way, let's get into your questions
1. Where can I read the code for C1, D2, G C&D?
You're referring to Class 1, Division 2, Group C & D hazardous locations. These classifications are defined in the National Electrical Code (NEC) (NFPA 70) in the United States and Canadian Electrical Code (CEC) Part I in Canada. The relevant sections are: NEC (NFPA 70), Article 500-505: This is the core of hazardous location requirements. Pay close attention to: Article 500: General requirements for hazardous locations. Article 501: Class I Locations. This is your primary focus as you're dealing with potentially flammable gases or vapors. Article 505: Zone classification (if applicable to your installation). Although you mentioned Division, understanding Zone classification is helpful for context.In particular, look at: 500.5 Classification of Locations 501.10 Wiring Methods 501.15 Equipment Permitted CEC Part I (Canada), Section 18: Similar to the NEC, this section provides the rules and regulations for electrical installations in hazardous locations in Canada. ISA (International Society of Automation) Standards
ISA provides numerous standards related to instrumentation and control in hazardous locations, including:
ISA-12.12.01: Nonincendive Electrical Equipment for Use in Class I and II, Division 2 and Class III, Divisions 1 and 2 Hazardous (Classified) Locations
ISA-RP12.06.01: Wiring Practices for Hazardous (Classified) Locations Instrumentation Part 1: Intrinsic Safety ISA-60079-2: Explosive Atmospheres - Part 2: Equipment protection by pressurized enclosure "p"While ISA standards aren't law, they offer highly regarded best practices.
To find these documents
NEC (NFPA 70)
Can be purchased from the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) website. You may also find access at technical libraries or through professional organizations.
CEC Part I
Purchased from the Canadian Standards Association (CSA) website.
ISA Standards
Purchased from the ISA website.
Understanding Class I, Division 2, Group C & D
Class I
Locations where flammable gases or vapors are or may be present in the air in quantities sufficient to produce explosive or ignitable mixtures.
Division 2
Locations where flammable gases or vapors are present under abnormal conditions (e.g., accidental rupture or breakdown of a container). This is less stringent than Division 1, where the hazard is present under normal operating conditions.
Group C
Atmospheres containing ethyl-ether, ethylene, or cyclopropane.
Group D
Atmospheres containing acetone, alcohol, ammonia, benzene, benzol, butane, gasoline, hexane, lacquer solvent vapors, naphtha, natural gas, propane, or similar flammable liquids, vapors, or gases.
2. Does all of them require a purge enclosure? Or can we say 24VDC doesn't require?
Not necessarily. Whether you need purging depends on several factors: The equipment's design and ratings
You have several options for protection methods:
Explosion-proof enclosures (NEC 501.15(A))
Designed to contain an internal explosion without igniting the surrounding atmosphere. These are robust but heavy and often expensive. They are often used for motors or high voltage components.
Purged and Pressurized Enclosures (NEC 501.15(B))
Use positive pressure to keep the hazardous atmosphere out of the enclosure. Requires a reliable source of clean, dry air or inert gas. The NEC 500.8(B) section is also useful in these enclosures.
Intrinsically Safe (IS) Circuits and Equipment (NEC 501.15(E))
Limits the energy in the circuit to a level that cannot cause ignition, even under fault conditions. Very common in instrumentation circuits and often used in 24VDC control systems. If your PLC and Operator panels use Intrinsically Safe designs, then purging isn't required.
Non-incendive circuits or equipment (NEC 501.15(F))
Equipment designed such that, under normal operating conditions, it is not capable of causing ignition of a specified flammable gas or vapor in air.
Type 'n' Enclosures (NEC 501.15(B)(3))
These are sealed enclosures designed to prevent arcs, sparks, or hot surfaces from igniting the hazardous atmosphere.
The nature of the equipment inside
High-voltage equipment or equipment that generates arcs or sparks is more likely to require robust protection methods like explosion-proof enclosures or purging. Low-voltage DC equipment may be suitable for other protection methods.
The specific approvals and certifications
Equipment must be listed and labeled for use in the specific hazardous location (Class, Division, Group). This listing will dictate the allowable protection methods.
The 24 VDC Question
Low Voltage Advantage
24 VDC control circuits can be good candidates for intrinsically safe (IS) designs. If your PLC, power supplies, and other 24 VDC components are certified as intrinsically safe for Class I, Division 2, Group C & D, you do not need purging. This is a very common and cost-effective approach for control panels.
Careful Design Required
To use intrinsically safe circuits, you must follow strict wiring practices (e.g., using shielded cables, proper grounding, and separation of IS and non-IS wiring). All devices in the IS loop must be certified as intrinsically safe and compatible with each other.
Alternatives
If intrinsic safety isn't practical for the entire 24 VDC system, other options like non-incendive designs or Type 'n' enclosures might be suitable, depending on the equipment and certifications.
Therefore, you cannot automatically assume the 24VDC panels don't need purging. You need to evaluate the equipment inside and explore alternative protection methods like intrinsic safety or Type 'n' enclosures before deciding on purging.3. As all of these are in hazardous locations but different rooms and control one machine, how should I control the purge system, individually or one main will cut power for all other enclosures?
This depends on your risk assessment and operational requirements. Here's a breakdown: Individual Purge Systems
Pros
More granular control. If one enclosure loses purge pressure, it only shuts down that part of the system, allowing other parts to potentially continue operating (if safe to do so). Potentially lower overall cost if some enclosures don't require purging based on their contents.
Cons
More complex to install and maintain. Requires more independent sensors and control logic.
Single Master Purge System
Pros
Simpler to install and maintain. Ensures that all enclosures are de-energized if any purge system fails, providing a higher level of safety.
Cons
Less flexible. A single purge failure shuts down the entire system. May be overkill if some enclosures don't actually require purging.
Key Considerations
Safety
What is the consequence of an ignition in any of the enclosures? If an ignition in any enclosure could lead to a catastrophic event, a single master purge system that shuts down everything might be the safest approach, even if it means more downtime.
Operational Impact
How critical is it that the machine continues to operate if one part of the system fails? If downtime is extremely costly, individual purge systems with redundancy might be preferable.
Interlocks
Regardless of whether you choose individual or a master purge system, you must have properly designed safety interlocks that: Monitor purge pressure continuously. De-energize the equipment inside the enclosure if purge pressure is lost. Prevent the equipment from being energized if purge pressure is not established.
Sequence of Operations
Consider the startup and shutdown sequence. Purge systems need time to properly purge enclosures before* power is applied.
Recommendation
Given that you're new to this type of installation, I would
strongly recommend consulting with a qualified hazardous location expert (electrical engineer, safety consultant) to perform a formal hazard assessment. This assessment should consider the specific chemicals present, the equipment used, the operating conditions, and the potential consequences of an ignition. The hazard assessment will help you determine the most appropriate and safest approach for your purge system and overall hazardous location design.
In summary, consider the following
Consult the NEC (NFPA 70) and/or CEC Part I, and ISA standards.2. Determine the exact classification of the hazardous location (Class, Division/Zone, Group).3. Evaluate the equipment inside each enclosure to determine the appropriate protection methods.4. Prioritize intrinsic safety for 24 VDC control circuits where possible.5. Develop a well-defined purge system strategy (individual vs. master) based on a thorough risk assessment.6. Implement robust safety interlocks to de-energize equipment upon loss of purge pressure.7. Most importantly, involve qualified professionals experienced in hazardous location design and installation.
This is a complex topic, and the information I've provided is only a starting point. Good luck with your project, and please stay safe! Flag for review