Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Baseboard heater run

User: JC58, Location: NY

Asked on: Wednesday, September 25, 2024 at 3:57 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 2:56 am EST

Question: Looking for some advice. Came upon an old house with 240v baseboard heating. There is one run that consists of a 30 amp breaker on 10/2 that goes to a junction box and splits to 2 separate 12/2 runs that each go to a separate mysa thermostat. One of the thermostats controls 2 heaters totally 2500 watts (10.85 amps) and the other controls a 2000 watt (8.3 amp) heater. Does anyone have a problem with the 10/2 to 12/2 split? I also called the mysa company and they said it should be fine because the thermostats are rated to 3800watts each and 20 amps. Even though each thermostat is handling way less than 20 amps each. They terminate at. 30 amp breaker.

Okay, let's break down the situation with your baseboard heater wiring and address the potential issues.

Here's a summary of what you have



Source

30 amp breaker, 10/2 wire to a junction box.


Split

From the junction box, two 12/2 wires branch out.

Thermostat 1 (Mysa)

Controls 2 x baseboard heaters totaling 2500 watts (10.85 amps).


Thermostat 2 (Mysa)

Controls 1 x baseboard heater totaling 2000 watts (8.3 amps).

Thermostat Rating

Mysa thermostats are rated for 3800 watts (20 amps) each.

Potential Problems & Concerns


Overcurrent Protection and Wire Gauge

This is the biggest concern. You have a 30 amp breaker protecting 12/2 wiring. 12/2 wire is generally rated for a maximum of 20 amps. The purpose of a breaker is to protect the
wiring from overheating and potentially causing a fire.

Scenario: Short Circuit on a 12/2 Run

If a short circuit occurs on either of the 12/2 runs (e.g., a wire comes loose and touches the metal enclosure), the 30 amp breaker might not trip fast enough to protect the 12/2 wire from overheating. It's designed to protect the 10/2 wire. The 12/2 could get dangerously hot before the breaker trips.

Code Violation

In most jurisdictions, this is a code violation. The breaker size must be matched to the
weakest link in the circuit (in this case, the 12/2 wiring).2.

Junction Box Connections

Make sure the connections in the junction box are properly made and secure. Use appropriate wire connectors (wire nuts) and ensure they are twisted on tightly. Loose connections can cause heat and create a fire hazard.3.

Thermostat Rating vs. Breaker Size

While the Mysa thermostats are
capable of handling 20 amps, that doesn't negate the issue of the 12/2 wire being protected by a 30 amp breaker. The thermostat is a load on the circuit, but the breaker is there to protect the wiring feeding that load.

The Problem with the Mysa Rep's Answer

The Mysa representative's advice is technically accurate about the thermostat's capacity, but it's incomplete and potentially dangerous. They are focusing on the
load (the heaters) and the thermostat and not the wiring that carries the current. It's like saying a bridge can hold a 20-ton truck, but the road leading to it can only handle 10 tons.

What You Should Do


Reduce Breaker Size

The simplest and safest solution is to replace the 30 amp breaker with a

20 amp breaker
. This will properly protect the 12/2 wiring. Important Calculation

After switching to a 20 amp breaker, calculate the total load on the circuit: 2500 watts + 2000 watts = 4500 watts. 4500 watts / 240 volts = 18.75 amps. This is below the 20 amp limit of the new breaker and the 12/2 wire, so you're good to go.2.

Re-evaluate with an Electrician

The best approach is to consult with a qualified, licensed electrician. They can assess the entire wiring system, ensure it meets code, and provide the safest and most appropriate solution. There may be other considerations beyond what you've described here.

In summary:
The 30 amp breaker on 12/2 wiring is a safety hazard. Change the breaker to a 20 amp. Consult with an electrician for a professional evaluation. Safety first! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question