Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: HVAC shutdown with F/A system and Chlorine Detection system

User: Futboldt9, Location: Vancouver, BC

Asked on: Wednesday, September 25, 2024 at 6:27 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 2:56 am EST

Question: Hi guys,We're doing an install which involves the small standalone building to be air neutral (shutdown of BCU's, HP's, HRV, ceiling fans, etc...) in the case of Chlorine detection and/or Fire alarm.There is a Chlorine Detection panel as well as an addressable Fire Alarm panel (Notifier). The sequence of events shows each panel having the capability of shutting down all HVAC equipment to make building air neutral however I've been beating my head on how we wire this as I've never done a system with both F/A and Chlorine Detection. This is a no brainer for me if it was just F/A and we were shutting HVAC down in only a fire alarm state as we would use the relay modules. But what is the best way to go about this with the F/A system and Chlorine system as well? Chlorine detection system has four internal SPDT dry contact relaysrated 5A @ 240VWould love to hear your input.Thanks!

Okay, let's break down how to achieve this. The goal is to reliably shut down all HVAC equipment upon activation of either the fire alarm or the chlorine detection system. The key is to use the dry contacts from each system to control a single, common control circuit for the HVAC shutdown.Here's a recommended approach, focusing on simplicity, reliability, and safety

Core Concept: Series Circuit for Logic OR Function

We'll use a series circuit to create an "OR" logic function. If either the fire alarm OR the chlorine detection system activates, the series circuit will open, causing the HVAC equipment to shut down.

Wiring Diagram & Explanation1. Power Supply

You'll need a reliable 24VDC or 24VAC (depending on your HVAC contactors/relays) power supply that can handle the load of the relay(s) that will control the HVAC equipment. This should be a dedicated power supply, separate from either the fire alarm or chlorine detection system power. Using a separate power supply isolates the shutdown circuit and prevents issues if one system's power supply fails.2.

Relay for HVAC Shutdown (Common Control Relay)

Choose a relay (or multiple relays, depending on the number of HVAC devices and their individual load requirements) with a coil voltage matching your chosen power supply (24VDC or 24VAC). This relay will have its contacts wired to interrupt the control circuits of ALL the HVAC equipment (BCUs, HPs, HRVs, ceiling fans, etc.). This is the most critical component.

Carefully check the voltage and current requirements of the HVAC equipment's control circuits before selecting this relay(s).
A good practice is to use a relay rated for significantly more current than you expect it to switch, providing a safety margin. Let's call this relay the "HVAC Shutdown Relay" or "Common Control Relay".3. Wiring



Power Supply (+) ---> Chlorine Detector Relay (Normally Closed Contact) ---> Fire Alarm Relay (Normally Closed Contact) ---> HVAC Shutdown Relay Coil (+) ---> Power Supply (-)
Power Supply (-) Directly connected to HVAC shutdown Relay Coil (-) Chlorine Detector Relay

Use a

normally closed (NC)
contact from one of the Chlorine Detector's SPDT relays. When the chlorine detector is in a normal (no chlorine detected) state, this contact will be CLOSED, allowing current to flow through the circuit. Fire Alarm Relay

Use a

normally closed (NC)
contact from a relay module connected to the fire alarm panel. Configure the relay module in the fire alarm panel to be normally energized and de-energize on alarm. When the fire alarm is in a normal (no alarm) state, this contact will be CLOSED, allowing current to flow through the circuit. You will need to program the Notifier panel to activate this relay upon any fire alarm condition.
HVAC Shutdown Relay

The coil of this relay is in series with the NC contacts of the Chlorine Detector Relay and the Fire Alarm Relay. As long as BOTH the chlorine detector and fire alarm are in a normal state, the series circuit is complete, energizing the HVAC Shutdown Relay.

HVAC Equipment Control Circuits

The

normally open (NO)
contacts of the HVAC Shutdown Relay are wired in series with the control power circuits of all the HVAC equipment. When the HVAC Shutdown Relay is energized (normal state), the NO contacts are closed, allowing power to flow to the HVAC equipment's control circuits, and they operate normally. When the HVAC Shutdown Relay is de-energized (alarm state), the NO contacts open, interrupting the control circuits and shutting down the HVAC equipment.

How it Works



Normal State

Both the chlorine detector and fire alarm are in a normal state. Their respective NC contacts are closed, completing the series circuit. The HVAC Shutdown Relay coil is energized, closing its NO contacts, and allowing the HVAC equipment to operate normally.

Chlorine Detection

The chlorine detector goes into alarm. Its NC contact opens, breaking the series circuit. The HVAC Shutdown Relay coil de-energizes, opening its NO contacts, and shutting down the HVAC equipment.


Fire Alarm

The fire alarm goes into alarm. Its NC contact opens, breaking the series circuit. The HVAC Shutdown Relay coil de-energizes, opening its NO contacts, and shutting down the HVAC equipment.

Both Systems in Alarm

The series circuit is broken, the HVAC Shutdown Relay coil de-energizes, opening its NO contacts, and shutting down the HVAC equipment.

Important Considerations and Best Practices



Wiring Methods

Use appropriate wiring methods (conduit, wiring type) per local codes and the device manufacturer's requirements.

Supervision

Consider supervising the wiring between the chlorine detector, fire alarm, and HVAC Shutdown Relay. This will alert you to any broken or disconnected wires, ensuring the system's integrity.


Relay Selection

Carefully choose relays that are rated for the voltage and current they will be switching. Over-rating is better than under-rating. Industrial-grade relays are generally more reliable than consumer-grade.

Power Supply Size

Size the power supply appropriately for the load of the HVAC Shutdown Relay(s), with some headroom.


Documentation

Document EVERYTHING! Create a detailed wiring diagram and clearly label all components. This will be invaluable for troubleshooting and maintenance.

Testing

Thoroughly test the entire system after installation. Simulate a chlorine alarm and a fire alarm and verify that the HVAC equipment shuts down as expected.


Local Codes and Regulations

Adhere to all applicable local codes and regulations. This type of system is often subject to specific requirements.

AHJ Approval

Before installation, have your plan reviewed and approved by the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ). This is crucial to ensure compliance and avoid issues during inspection.


Fail-Safe Design

This design is "fail-safe" in that if any wire breaks in the control circuit, the HVAC system will shut down.

Notifier Programming

You will need to program the Notifier panel to activate the relay module's contact upon ANY fire alarm condition (smoke detection, heat detection, manual pull station activation, etc.). Refer to the Notifier panel's programming manual for specific instructions. Ensure that the relay module is configured for normally energized operation so that the NC contact opens when the relay is de-energized on alarm.

Advantages of this Approach



Simplicity

Relatively simple to design, wire, and troubleshoot.

Reliability

Uses well-understood components and a straightforward design.


Fail-Safe

A broken wire in the control circuit will result in HVAC shutdown.

Common Control

Allows for a single point of control for all HVAC equipment.


Meets Requirements

Satisfies the requirement of shutting down HVAC on either fire alarm or chlorine detection.

Alternatives (Less Recommended in this Case)



Using an AND Gate

While you could use an AND gate IC, it's generally overkill for this application. The series circuit provides the same logic function with fewer components. AND gates require power and can be more complex to integrate.


Using a PLC

Using a Programmable Logic Controller (PLC) is also an option, but it's typically not necessary for this relatively simple application. PLCs are better suited for more complex control systems.*

Parallel Wiring:
Avoid wiring the relays in parallel. If one relay fails closed, the system will not operate correctly.Let me know if you have any more questions. Good luck with the installation! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question