Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: SPD at multimeter services

User: Liquidtrav, Location: San Diego, ca

Asked on: Wednesday, September 25, 2024 at 7:45 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 2:57 am EST

Question: How is everyone going about adding an SPD at a multimeter service? The code states it must be at or adjacent to the service. The exception also allows it to be in each unit sub panel. When replacing existing services, adding it into each units panel is not always possible or practical. Many times the HOA will own the service and only will pay for that to be replaced, individual units are privately owned and will either not be accesible or existing older panels may not be compatible with plug on style SPDs.There are a number of solutions my local supply house has presented… the most expensive being a $4000 spacer style SPD that would go after the main switch and before the meter stacks. The more economical solution I have found is ordering stacks with an additional meter space, using a meter socket bypass jumper and installing a plug in style SPD where normally a unit feeder breaker would go. I can’t find any issue with doing it this way. Any opinions?

You've outlined a common challenge faced when retrofitting SPDs in multi-meter services. Let's break down the considerations and your proposed solutions

Understanding the Code Requirements
NEC 230.8(A)

The general rule is, as you stated, the SPD has to be installed at or adjacent to the service.


NEC 230.8(B) Exception

This is the critical piece. It allows the SPD to be installed at each individual unit's subpanel. This is often the most practical approach for minimizing voltage drop.

NEC Article 285

Important to review the requirements for Surge Protective Devices (SPDs), including the specific type ratings, suitability, and installation requirements based on the system voltage and available fault current.

Challenges You've Identified



HOA Control

HOA only pays for the service replacement, not upgrades within individual units.

Accessibility

Access to individual units can be difficult or impossible.


Panel Compatibility

Existing panels might not easily accommodate plug-on SPDs.

Cost

Retrofitting can be expensive.

Evaluating Your Proposed Solutions



1. $4000 Spacer-Style SPD



Pros

Potentially provides whole-building surge protection. Meets the "at the service" requirement.

Cons

Very expensive. May not be the most effective surge protection strategy compared to SPDs closer to the point of use. May need to be derated.

2. Meter Stack with Additional Meter Space and Meter Socket Bypass



Pros

Economical compared to the spacer style. Potentially simpler installation if you're already replacing the meter stacks.

Cons

This is where we need to be very careful about code compliance and safety. Here's a detailed breakdown of the considerations:


Bypass Jumper Concerns

Extremely important to use a listed and appropriately rated bypass jumper specifically designed for temporary bypass of meter sockets. Using an incorrect or homemade jumper is incredibly dangerous.

NEC Compliance



230.8(A)

Is the SPD really "at or adjacent to the service"? Some interpretations might say no, especially if it's downstream of the main disconnect and the meter. This is something the AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction) will need to weigh in on.

230.9

Overcurrent Protection. The SPD itself typically has internal overcurrent protection (fuses or breakers). However, you need to ensure that the upstream overcurrent protection (likely the main breaker in the meter stack) is appropriate for the SPD's short-circuit current rating (SCCR). The SCCR of the SPD must be equal to or greater than the available fault current at that point in the system.


110.3(B)

Listed and Labeled Equipment. Everything you use (meter stacks, bypass jumpers, SPD, etc.) must be properly listed and labeled for its intended use.

Article 408

Switchboards, Switchgear, and Panelboards. You're essentially using the meter stack as a distribution point. Make sure the meter stack is rated and suitable for this purpose.


Safety

Working on energized meter stacks is extremely hazardous. Proper PPE (personal protective equipment) and lockout/tagout procedures are essential. Qualified personnel only should perform this work.

Utility Company Approval

You
must coordinate this with the utility company. They likely have very specific requirements about working on their equipment and using meter socket bypass jumpers. You may need their approval.

Service Entrance Rated

The SPD must be rated for service entrance use.

Voltage

The SPD must be rated for the voltage of the system.


Wiring

The conductors connecting the SPD must be properly sized and protected.

Other Potential Solutions & Considerations



Negotiate with the HOA

Explore options to incentivize individual unit owners to upgrade their panels and install SPDs within their units. Perhaps the HOA could offer a partial rebate. This is the most comprehensive solution for individual surge protection.


Combination Approach

Install a more basic, cost-effective SPD at the service (even if it's not ideal) and strongly encourage individual unit owners to install additional SPDs at their panels.

Surge Strips & Power Conditioners

Encourage tenants to use surge strips and power conditioners. It is the least effective solution but might be helpful.

Recommendations


Consult with the AHJ

Before proceeding with
any solution, discuss your plans with the local electrical inspector. Get their opinion on the proposed method and ensure it will be compliant with local codes and interpretations.2.

Consult with the Utility Company

Absolutely essential for anything involving the meter stack.3.

Prioritize Safety

Work must be performed by qualified personnel with appropriate PPE and following lockout/tagout procedures.4.

Focus on Individual Unit Protection (Ideal Scenario)

Push for the individual unit SPD approach. It provides the best protection and complies with the exception in 230.8(B).
5.


Consider a Hybrid Approach

A less expensive service-entrance SPD combined with encouraged/incentivized unit-level SPDs.6.

Document Everything

Keep detailed records of your plans, approvals, and installation procedures.

In conclusion, while the meter stack solution
might* be feasible, it carries significant code compliance and safety risks. The "at each unit" approach is generally the best solution when you are dealing with multi meter service but with HOA, affordability and other issues it’s not always practical. Prioritize consulting with the AHJ and utility company before proceeding.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question