User: marcosgue, Location: Tampa
Asked on: Thursday, September 26, 2024 at 5:59 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 2:58 am EST
Question: Hi everyone, I usually run individual gec from the main groun bar to each dry type transformer SDS inside the premises, but 1. Can I run a common gec for several SDS and how to size this according to 250.66?2. Is there some advantage to use individual gec or common gec for various SDS transformers?Thank you and I appreciate some comments in this particular questions
Okay, let's break down the grounding electrode conductor (GEC) questions for separately derived systems (SDS) from dry-type transformers, referencing NEC 250.66.1. Can I run a common GEC for several SDS and how to size this according to 250.66?
Yes, you can use a common GEC for multiple SDS transformers, but with significant caveats and considerations. It's not as straightforward as just connecting everything to a single wire. The NEC doesn't explicitly prohibit it, but it's crucial to do it correctly. Here's the process and the "how to size" part: NEC Rationale
The general principle behind grounding and bonding is to provide a low-impedance path for fault current back to the source. A common GEC can achieve this if done properly, but there are failure modes if not sized and connected carefully.
Key Requirements & Considerations
Parallel Conductors
The critical point here is that each individual SDS must have a properly sized system bonding jumper (SBJ) that connects the neutral (X0) to the transformer's case/enclosure (the location where you would connect the GEC). Think of these SBJs as individual "paths" to the common GEC. These SBJs must be sized according to 250.28, based on the secondary conductors of each transformer. Each transformer's SBJ MUST be connected to the transformer neutral terminal that is bonded to the transformer enclosure. Each transformer SBJ must be independently routed, with no series connections between them.
Caution
This configuration is only suitable for multi-building (outdoors) installations with the use of a common grounding electrode (grounding ring). It's essential to confirm that the building steel is effectively grounded and that all transformers are mounted to the same steel structure. Verify local AHJ requirements for multi-building installations.
Sizing the Common GEC
This is the tricky part and requires some careful calculation. The common GEC must be sized based on the largest secondary conductor size of any of the SDS transformers served. Here's the breakdown from 250.66:1.
Determine the Largest Secondary Phase Conductor
Identify the SDS transformer with the largest phase conductors on its secondary side.2.
Consult Table 250.66
Look up the required GEC size based on the size of the largest secondary conductor.
Important
If the electrodes are concrete-encased or ground ring, you can stop at 4/0 CU or 250 kcmil AL (250.66(A) and (B)). If you connect to the building steel, the GEC can never be smaller than 6 AWG copper or 4 AWG aluminum.
Continuous Length
The common GEC must be continuous from the grounding electrode(s) to the point where the SBJs from each transformer connect to it. There can't be splices along the GEC itself. You can use irreversible compression type connectors or exothermic welding connections to connect the SBJs to the GEC.
Accessibility
Ensure that the connections of the SBJs to the common GEC are accessible for inspection and testing. This often means a dedicated enclosure or junction box.
Example
Transformer #1: 480V to 208Y/120V, Secondary conductors: 500 kcmil Cu Transformer #2: 480V to 208Y/120V, Secondary conductors: 3/0 AWG Cu The largest secondary conductor is 500 kcmil Cu. According to Table 250.66, the common GEC must be at least 1/0 AWG Cu (assuming connection to earth/rod).
How to Connect
The best practice is often a grounding busbar or terminal block located centrally. The common GEC connects to this busbar, and then the individual SBJs from each transformer connect to the same busbar. This creates a central grounding point.
2. Is there some advantage to use individual gec or common gec for various SDS transformers?Here's a comparison of the advantages and disadvantages of individual vs. common GECs:
Individual GECs
Advantages
Simplicity and Clarity
Easier to understand and troubleshoot. Each transformer has its dedicated grounding path.
Fault Isolation
A fault on one transformer's grounding system is less likely to impact the grounding of other transformers.
Redundancy
If one GEC fails, the other transformers remain properly grounded.
Less Engineering Calculation
Sizing is straightforward based on each transformer's secondary conductors.
Disadvantages
Higher Material Cost
More copper/aluminum wire is required.
More Labor
More connections to make, more conduit to run.
More Crowding
Can result in a more crowded grounding electrode system, especially if space is limited.
Common GEC
Advantages
Potentially Lower Material Cost
Can reduce the total amount of GEC conductor needed, especially for a cluster of transformers.
Potentially Less Labor
Fewer overall connections to the grounding electrode system.
May be the only viable approach
For multi-building (outdoor) installations where a common grounding electrode system is in place.
Disadvantages
More Complex Design and Calculation
Requires careful sizing of the common GEC and the individual SBJs.
Potential for Ground Loops
If not properly implemented, can create ground loops, leading to unwanted circulating currents and potential noise.
Single Point of Failure
A failure in the common GEC compromises the grounding of all transformers.
Difficult to Troubleshoot
Identifying the source of a grounding problem can be more challenging.
Increased Current on GEC
The common GEC will carry the combined fault current of all the connected transformers, potentially leading to a larger conductor size requirement.
Easier to Make Mistakes
More opportunities for errors in sizing and connections.
Greater Risk of Overheating
If the SDS neutrals are not balanced, the common GEC can carry a significant amount of continuous neutral current, potentially leading to overheating.
Recommendation
In most typical indoor installations,
individual GECs are generally the preferred approach. They offer simplicity, clarity, redundancy, and are easier to troubleshoot. The added cost and labor are often justified by the increased reliability and safety.A common GEC is most likely to be applicable in multi-building applications.Verify local AHJ requirements for multi-building installations.Important Considerations & Best Practices
Always consult with a qualified electrical engineer
Grounding and bonding systems are critical for safety. An engineer can perform the necessary calculations and ensure that the design meets all applicable codes and standards.
Thorough Documentation
Keep detailed records of all grounding and bonding connections, conductor sizes, and materials used.
Regular Inspection and Testing
Periodically inspect the grounding and bonding system to ensure that all connections are tight and conductors are in good condition. Perform ground resistance testing to verify the effectiveness of the grounding electrode system.
Coordination with the AHJ
Discuss your grounding and bonding design with the local Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) to ensure that it meets their requirements.
Grounding Electrode System
Ensure that the grounding electrode system itself (ground rods, building steel, etc.) is properly installed and sized according to the NEC. The GEC is only as effective as the grounding electrodes it connects to.
System Bonding Jumper
The SBJ is the critical link. Ensure it's properly sized and installed per 250.28.
Ground Fault Protection
Consider using ground fault protection (GFP) on the secondary side of the transformers to minimize the duration and magnitude of ground faults.
In summary: While a common GEC is possible under the NEC, it requires careful engineering and meticulous installation. For most typical installations, individual GECs are generally the simpler and more reliable solution. Always consult with a qualified electrical engineer to ensure that your grounding and bonding system is safe and code-compliant. Flag for review