Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Loading a generator, KVA vs KW

User: mark32, Location: Currently in NJ

Asked on: Thursday, September 26, 2024 at 9:59 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 2:59 am EST

Question: Hey guys,I know someone will shed light on this in short order, but here goes. I am tasked to perform a monthly load test on a standby generator. The specs are as follows: 850 KVA, 680 KW, 480 VAC, PF .8During the test, the readout on the Generator's screen shows the load varying between 240 and 250 amps. On a subsequent screen, it shows the load being supplied is approximately 30% of the gen's capacity, which is good because my employer wants the gen loaded to a min of 30%. However, when I fill out the paperwork for the test, it states a load of 307 amps is 30% of the gen's capacity, hmm. So it appears the person who wrote up the test sheet is using KVA to derive the 307a figure (850kva/480/1.732 = 1022 amps*.3 = 307 amps), but the generator is using KW to derive it's % figure (680kw/480/1.732 = 818 amps*.3 = 245.4 amps) So, which formula would you say is the correct one to be used here?

Okay, let's break this down. You've identified the core of the issue: whether to use KVA or KW to determine the proper amperage for the load test.

The Correct Approach: Use KW (Kilowatts)

Here's why: Generator Rating

Generators are primarily rated in KW for real power output. The KVA rating includes both real power (KW) and reactive power (KVAR).


Load Banks

Load banks, which are typically used for generator testing, primarily provide a resistive load, which primarily draws KW (real power).

Percentage of Capacity

When you're aiming for a percentage of the generator's capacity, you're generally targeting a percentage of its KW output.

Calculations to support the KW approach


Full Load Amps (Based on KW)

`Amps = KW / (Volts 1.732 Power Factor)` `Amps = 680 KW / (480 V 1.732 0.8)` `Amps = 680,000 W / (480 V 1.732 0.8)` `Amps = 1022 A` (Full Load)2.

30% of Full Load Amps (Based on KW)

`30% Load Amps = 1022 0.3 = 306.6 Amps`

Explanation and Resolution


The figure shown on your gen's readout (240-250A) is significantly less than the 306.6A calculated above, so this points to one of two scenarios.
1. Your generator's screen is likely displaying the
average* amperage across the three phases. With a balanced load bank, each phase should be drawing a similar current. If you were to check the amperage on each phase individually, you would likely see that each phase is operating at or near the expected load. The average would be in the 240-250 range.2. Your load bank is underperforming and not truly delivering the expected KW load.

Recommendation1. Verify Amperage per Phase Use a clamp meter to measure the current on each phase of the generator output.2. Calculate Total KW Load Calculate the total KW load from the amperage measurements taken from each phase to ensure that they align with the expected values.3. Adjust the Load Bank Adjust the load on the load bank, and then re-measure the individual phases to make sure they conform to the 30% KW requirement.4. Update Test Sheet

In future monthly tests, make sure the amps are derived from the KW spec on the generator's info plate.5.

Consult Generator Manual/Manufacturer:
If you're still unsure, consult the generator's manual or contact the manufacturer for clarification on how they calculate the percentage of capacity displayed on the screen.By following these steps, you can ensure that you are accurately assessing your generator's performance during your monthly load tests and that the data you're collecting aligns with the manufacturer's specifications. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question