Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Emergency generator question

User: hhsting, Location: Glen bunie, md, us

Asked on: Thursday, September 26, 2024 at 10:33 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 2:59 am EST

Question: I have one feeder shown sketch below that feeds emergency ATS #2 and legally required ATS #1. The feeders get tapped one feeds ATS#1 and another tap feeds ATS#2. The question that I have is do I need two separate generator main breakers one feeding ATS#1 and another feeding ATS#2 or just one main breaker feeding both ARS with tap as shown would comply with NEC 2017 Article 700.3(F)?

Okay, let's break down the NEC 2017 requirements, specifically Article 700.3(F) and how it applies to your situation with two Automatic Transfer Switches (ATSs) connected to a single generator.

Understanding NEC 2017 Article 700.3(F) (Accessibility)

Article 700.3(F) states:"Emergency system equipment shall be suitable for the location and shall be protected against physical damage. Equipment shall be located in spaces that are accessible only to qualified persons.Author's comments: The code recognizes that only trained personnel are qualified to perform the work associated with emergency systems. The point is to limit access to those who understand the function of the equipment and can properly maintain and operate it. This minimizes the risk of unauthorized or unintentional interference that could compromise the system's reliability. Enclosure doors and panels, if any, shall be kept locked or otherwise secured to prevent ready access by unqualified persons.Analysis of Your Scenario

You have:
One Generator

Supplying power to both ATSs.

Two ATSs

ATS #1: Serves Legally Required Loads ATS #2: Serves Emergency Loads

Single Feeder

From the generator, with taps to each ATS.The core question is whether one main generator breaker ahead of the taps complies with NEC 2017 (specifically considering 700.3(F) and general emergency system design principles).

The Answer: One Main Breaker CAN be acceptable, but with conditions and careful consideration.


Here's the reasoning:1. NEC Doesn't Explicitly Mandate Separate Breakers for Each ATS in This Configuration

The code doesn't state you must have a breaker for each ATS feed. The focus is on reliable and protected power.2.

Overcurrent Protection Coordination is Key

The crucial aspect is proper overcurrent protection coordination. You MUST ensure the following:

Main Generator Breaker Sizing

The main breaker must be sized to carry the
total connected load of both ATS #1 and ATS #2. You'll need a load calculation for all loads served by both ATSs to determine this.

Tap Conductor Protection

The tap conductors feeding each ATS must be protected against overcurrent according to NEC 240.21 (Tap Rules). This usually means using fuses or breakers at the tap point or very close to the ATS. Consider the 10' tap rule or 25' tap rule if appropriate for your design. These tap protective devices are critical for the protection of the feeder conductors feeding each ATS.

Selective Coordination

This is
vital for emergency systems. The overcurrent protective devices must be selectively coordinated. Meaning, if a fault occurs on a circuit fed by ATS #1, only the overcurrent device protecting that circuit should trip. The main generator breaker (and any breakers upstream) must not trip. This ensures the remaining emergency and legally required loads continue to be powered. Selective coordination is often achieved through the use of fuses with appropriate time-current characteristics or circuit breakers with adjustable trip settings. NEC 700.28 requires selective coordination.
3.


Accessibility and Maintenance

Given 700.3(F), the location and access to the generator and its associated breakers and ATSs need careful consideration:


Restricted Access

Ensure the generator room (or enclosure) is accessible only to qualified personnel. Lock the door, have a sign, and enforce the restriction.

Clear Labeling

Label
everything clearly. Label the generator, the main breaker, the ATSs, and the loads they serve. This is essential for troubleshooting and maintenance. Labeling helps qualified personnel quickly identify and isolate problems.4.

Redundancy and Reliability (Considerations)

While a single main breaker
can be compliant, consider these points regarding system reliability:

Single Point of Failure

With one main breaker, a trip of that breaker kills power to both ATSs. Having two main breakers provides a degree of redundancy. If one breaker trips (due to a fault, etc.), the other ATS can still function.

Easier Isolation for Maintenance

With two breakers, you can more easily isolate one ATS for maintenance without disrupting the other.

In summary, here's how to comply


Load Calculation

Accurately calculate the total load served by both ATSs.2.

Main Breaker Sizing

Size the main generator breaker to handle the
total calculated load.3.

Tap Conductor Protection

Properly protect the tap conductors feeding each ATS with fuses or breakers at the tap point.4.

Selective Coordination

Ensure
selective coordination of all overcurrent protective devices from the branch circuits up to the main generator breaker.5.

Restricted Access

Secure the generator room/enclosure.6.

Clear Labeling

Label all components.

Recommendations



Consult with a Qualified Electrical Engineer

Given the criticality of emergency systems and the complexity of selective coordination, I highly recommend consulting with a qualified electrical engineer experienced in emergency power system design. They can perform detailed calculations, select appropriate overcurrent protective devices, and ensure your system meets all applicable codes and standards.

Consider Two Breakers for Enhanced Reliability

While not strictly required by the NEC if done correctly, consider the redundancy benefits of using two separate main breakers. It may be a worthwhile investment for the added reliability, especially if the emergency and legally required loads are critical. This decision involves a trade-off between cost and the desired level of system resilience.


AHJ Approval:
It's always best practice to discuss your design with your local Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) before installation to ensure they agree with your interpretation of the code and your proposed solution.By carefully addressing these points, you can design a compliant and reliable emergency power system. Remember to always prioritize safety and compliance with all applicable codes and standards. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question