User: Coachmike, Location: Morris County, NJ
Asked on: Thursday, September 26, 2024 at 12:10 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 2:59 am EST
Question: We have a 2000-amp service on an assisted living facility. We are installing a 500KW genset and 2000-amp ATS on the outside of the facility. The existing service is fed by 4- 4" parallel PVC UG conduits with 4- 750 MCM CU conductors. There is an existing spare/ empty 4" conduit that we would like to run our new EGC in. The AHJ is requiring a full size EGC- 250 CU in each of the 4 existing feeders. We would like to pull one full 250 CU in the spare, empty, parallel conduit or at the very least decrease the size of the ground wire for parallel circuits. Is this acceptable?
Okay, let's break down the NEC requirements and discuss possible solutions for your grounding situation.
Understanding the NEC Requirements (Simplified)
250.4(A)(5): Effective Ground-Fault Current Path
The grounding path must be permanent, continuous, electrically conductive, and capable of safely carrying the maximum fault current likely to be imposed on it.
250.24(C)(1): Grounding Electrode Conductor for AC Systems
This section discusses sizing the grounding electrode conductor (GEC), which connects your service equipment to the grounding electrode system (ground rods, water pipe, etc.). This is separate from the equipment grounding conductors (EGCs).
250.122(B): Increased in Size
if the ungrounded conductors are increased in size from the conductors described in Table 310.16, the equipment grounding conductor is increased in size proportionally according to circular mil area of the ungrounded conductors.
250.122(C): Conductors in Parallel
When conductors are run in parallel in multiple raceways or cables, as permitted in 310.10(H), the equipment grounding conductor is installed in each raceway or cable. Each EGC shall be sized based on the overcurrent protective device protecting the circuit conductors in the raceway or cable in accordance with Table 250.
122.
310.10(H): Conductors in Parallel
This allows parallel conductors under specific conditions: Each phase/neutral/grounding conductor must be the same length, conductor type, and termination method. All conductors must have the same insulation type. Conductors must be sized 1/0 AWG or larger. Parallel conductors must have the same ampacity rating.
Analysis of Your Situation1. You have a 2000-amp service
You have a parallel conductor arrangement feeding the service.2.
You have 4 x 750 MCM CU conductors per phase
This is your existing setup.3.
AHJ Requirement: 250 CU in EACH of the 4 existing feeders
This is where the issue arises. The AHJ is interpreting the code as requiring a full-sized EGC in each raceway. This is a common interpretation.4.
Your Proposal: One 250 CU in a Spare Conduit
You want to run a single, larger EGC in the spare conduit, rather than individual smaller EGCs in each feeder conduit.
Why the AHJ Might Be Insisting on EGCs in Each Raceway
The primary reason is to ensure a low-impedance fault current path within each parallel run. If a fault occurs in one of the raceways, having a dedicated EGC in that raceway provides the lowest possible impedance path back to the source, facilitating a faster and more reliable trip of the overcurrent protective device (the main breaker). This is crucial for safety and minimizing damage.
Addressing the AHJ's Concerns and Finding Possible Solutions
Argument Against the One Large EGC
The AHJ will likely reject the idea of a single 250 CU EGC because it doesn't guarantee a low-impedance path in each individual raceway. The fault current would have to travel outside of the faulted raceway to reach the EGC, increasing impedance and potentially slowing down fault clearing.
Code Compliance
NEC 250.122(F) and the informational note within the 2020 NEC hand book states that each EGC must be in close proximity to the parallel ungrounded conductors.
Reducing the EGC Size
If the AHJ continues to require one 250 CU EGC in each conduit, then the next step would be to calculate the minimum size based on NEC table 250.122. Looking at the 2000 amp OCPD, the correct size would be 3/0 CU.
Important Considerations
AHJ Ruling is Final
The AHJ has the final say in code interpretation. You need to work with them to find an acceptable solution.
Documentation
Keep thorough documentation of all calculations, discussions with the AHJ, and any changes made to the design.
Recommendation
Meet with the AHJ
Schedule a meeting with the AHJ to discuss your concerns and explore options. Present your calculations and reasoning.2.
Comply with EGC Sizing Requirements
You will need to have 3/0 CU EGC in each of the 4 conduits.3.
Documentation
Keep records of all changes made to the project in case of future inspections or concerns.
Disclaimer: This information is for general guidance only. Always consult with a qualified and licensed electrical engineer and your local AHJ for specific code interpretations and design requirements for your project. Flag for review