User: Isaiah, Location: Baton Rouge
Asked on: Thursday, September 26, 2024 at 3:25 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:00 am EST
Question: Construction wants to tap a 3 phase feeder from a 480V SWGR CB at three locations all within about 10 feet of each other: first a 400A fused disconnect; second a 150A fused disconnect and third, a MLO panelboard with a max rating of 800A and has seven branch circuits ranging from 30A to 100A.I’m primarily concerned about the MLO panelboardIs this Code compliant?
Okay, let's break down the situation and address the Code compliance, focusing primarily on the MLO panelboard.
The Situation Summary Source
480V Switchgear (SWGR)
Taps
Three taps within 10 feet of each other from the same feeder. 400A Fused Disconnect 150A Fused Disconnect 800A MLO (Main Lug Only) Panelboard with various branch circuits (30A-100A)
Key Code Considerations and Potential Issues1. Tap Rules (NEC Article 240.21): This is the most critical area. Taps can be made from feeders, but they must comply with specific rules. Since the length of the tap conductors is not provided, I will address the most restrictive, "10-Foot Tap Rule." 10-Foot Tap Rule (240.21(B)(1))
This rule allows a tap up to 10 feet long without overcurrent protection at the tap point, if the following conditions are met:
Conductor Ampacity
The tap conductor's ampacity must be not less than the sum of the calculated loads on the circuits supplied by the tap conductors, and not less than the rating of the overcurrent protective device at the termination of the tap conductors. This is crucial!
Protected from Physical Damage
The tap conductors must be enclosed in a raceway or otherwise protected from physical damage.
Termination Overcurrent Protection
The tap cannot be longer than 10 feet, and the tap conductors must terminate in a circuit breaker or fuses (overcurrent device) rated to protect the tap conductors' ampacity.2.
Panelboard Rating (NEC 408.36)
The panelboard's rating (800A in this case) must be sufficient for the calculated load.3.
Short-Circuit Current Rating (SCCR) of the Panelboard (NEC 110.10, 408.6)
This is a very important safety consideration. The panelboard, including its components (breakers, etc.), must have a SCCR that is equal to or greater than the available fault current at its terminals. This helps prevent catastrophic failures during a short circuit.4.
Available Fault Current
Tapping at the switchgear likely means a high available fault current. A short circuit study is typically required to determine this value.5.
Feeder Size
The feeder from the switchgear must be sized to handle the total load of all three taps (400A + 150A + MLO Panel Load), plus any existing load on the feeder. It must also be protected by an overcurrent device at the source (the switchgear breaker) that is sized appropriately for the feeder ampacity.6.
Load Calculation for the MLO Panel
You need to perform a thorough load calculation for the MLO panelboard based on the connected branch circuits. This calculation must include demand factors as permitted by the NEC (Article 220). The calculated load is a key factor in sizing the tap conductors.
Analysis & Recommendations MLO Panelboard Tap
This is the most concerning area.
Tap Conductor Size
The tap conductors feeding the 800A MLO panelboard must be sized based on the calculated load of the panel, not the 800A rating of the panel. Let's assume, for the sake of discussion, that after your load calculation, the total calculated load on the panel is, say, 350A. In this case, you could potentially use conductors with an ampacity of 350A, provided you meet the 10-foot tap rule and the other conditions.
Termination Overcurrent Protection
Since it's an MLO panel, there's no main breaker in the panel itself to protect the tap conductors. This is a major issue! The 10-foot tap rule requires that the tap conductors terminate in an overcurrent device that protects the tap conductors.
10-Foot Rule Issues (For All Taps)
Even if all tap conductors were sized equal to or greater than the rating of the OC device at the termination of the tap conductors the fact that all three taps are within 10 feet of each other could be a violation. I say could, because it is possible for all three to be within 10 feet of each other and the sum of the length from the feeder to each disconnect and/or panel is over 10 feet, then the taps are legal. However it appears that the intent is to use a single "Main" tap which could then be tapped into three locations. This would violate the "Single Tap" requirement.
SCCR
Do not underestimate the importance of SCCR. With a tap directly from the switchgear, the available fault current could be very high. You must verify that the panelboard's SCCR, as well as the SCCR of the disconnects, is adequate. If not, you may need to use series-rated combinations or current-limiting fuses to achieve an acceptable SCCR.
Recommendations1. Load Calculation
Perform a precise load calculation for the MLO panelboard according to NEC Article 220.2.
Available Fault Current Study
Engage a qualified electrical engineer to conduct a short-circuit study to determine the available fault current at the tap locations.3.
Overcurrent Protection
Most Likely Solution
Install a suitably sized circuit breaker or fused disconnect immediately adjacent to the switchgear for each tap. This provides the required overcurrent protection at the origin of each tap, and removes the reliance on the 10-foot tap rule. Size the overcurrent protection and tap conductors based on the calculated load of each tap.
Series-Rated Combination (If Necessary)
If the available fault current is high and the panelboard's/disconnects' SCCR is too low, investigate the use of series-rated combinations of overcurrent devices (e.g., a current-limiting fuse upstream of the panelboard breaker) to increase the effective SCCR. Consult with the equipment manufacturers for their listed series ratings.4.
Feeder Sizing and Protection
Verify that the existing feeder from the switchgear is adequately sized for the total load of all three taps, and that the switchgear breaker is sized correctly to protect the feeder.5.
Consider an Alternative
Depending on the long-term needs, it may be better to consider installing a new distribution panel closer to the loads, fed by a dedicated feeder from the switchgear. This could provide more flexibility and better protection for the downstream circuits.6.
Consult a Qualified Electrical Engineer
Given the complexity and safety implications, it is highly recommended that you consult with a licensed professional electrical engineer to review your design, perform the necessary calculations, and ensure Code compliance.
In summary, it is UNLIKELY that the proposed setup with the MLO panelboard directly tapped from the switchgear feeder is Code compliant, due to the lack of overcurrent protection at the origin of the tap conductors and the potential violation of the 10-foot tap rule without proper OCPD. You need to provide overcurrent protection at the origin of the tap and verify the SCCR. Flag for review