User: Aistobasbistoc9, Location: Texas
Asked on: Thursday, September 26, 2024 at 3:31 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:01 am EST
Question: There is a 1600A main switchboard that was once rated at 1600A with main at 1600A as well. At some point, services split and they reused the 1600A main switchboard, but rerouted 800A feeders with 800A disconnect over to the switchboard (disconnect before switchboard). Is this allowable per NEC if they kept the 1600A main in the switchboard? As long as what is on the switchboard does not exceed 800A, will the 800A disconnect before the switchboard suffice? If not, could the 1600A main that was in the switchboard simply be updated to an 800A main and then we could call it good?Please let me know what NEC references would allow or disallow either scenario.Thank you!
This is a complex scenario requiring careful consideration of the National Electrical Code (NEC). Here's a breakdown of the issues and applicable NEC sections
Understanding the Setup
Original
1600A Switchboard with 1600A Main.
Current
1600A Switchboard, fed by 800A Feeders and protected by 800A Disconnects before the switchboard. The original 1600A main breaker inside the switchboard is still present.
Scenario 1: Keeping the 1600A Main Breaker in the Switchboard Issue
The key problem is the 1600A main breaker in the switchboard is not protecting the 800A feeders coming into the switchboard. The 800A disconnects provide that protection, but the 1600A breaker inside the switchboard is now essentially a downstream breaker, and its rating is higher than the feeder size.
NEC Implications
NEC 240.21(B)(3) Feeder Taps
This section might seem applicable at first glance. It allows for feeder taps under specific conditions. However, a switchboard is generally not considered a simple "tap" because it's a distribution point with multiple overcurrent devices. This section would not apply.
NEC 240.21(B)(1) and (B)(2)
These sections cover transformer secondary conductors and over 10' feeder taps (over 25' feeder taps). These would likely not apply since we are not talking about a transformer secondary or a tap in the traditional sense.
NEC 240.4 Overcurrent Protection. This is a key section. It requires conductors to be protected against overcurrent according to their ampacity. The 800A feeders need to be protected at their ampacity (or next standard size up, under certain circumstances, per 240.4(B)). The 800A disconnects handle this. However, this does not address the 1600A main breaker issue. Is it ALLOWABLE? Potentially problematic, but depends on specific interpretation and AHJ approval. The 800A disconnect adequately protects the 800A feeders. However, the 1600A main breaker is not providing any upstream overcurrent protection. It is simply allowing the 800A that it receives to pass downstream, and would only trip if it was in excess of 1600A. This could lead to confusion in an emergency, or the assumption that the system could handle 1600A. As long as what is on the switchboard does not exceed 800A, will the 800A disconnect before the switchboard suffice? Yes, the 800A disconnect before the switchboard provides the necessary protection for the feeders coming into the switchboard.
Scenario 2: Replacing the 1600A Main Breaker with an 800A Main Breaker Issue
This would now provide overcurrent protection at the switchboard as the main breaker will now trip at 800A. The 800A disconnect before the switchboard is still providing feeder protection.
NEC Implications
NEC 240.21(B)(3) Feeder Taps
This section still not be applicable as switchboards are not generally considered a tap.
NEC 240.21(B)(1) and (B)(2)
These sections would likely not apply since we are not talking about a transformer secondary or a tap in the traditional sense.
NEC 240.4 Overcurrent Protection
The conductors are still being protected adequately against overcurrent according to their ampacity (800A).
Is it ALLOWABLE? Yes, this is a much better and more compliant solution. Replacing the 1600A main breaker with an 800A main breaker ensures that the switchboard itself is protected at the appropriate level. It aligns with good engineering practice and addresses the potential hazards of the oversized breaker. Could the 1600A main that was in the switchboard simply be updated to an 800A main and then we could call it good? Yes, replacing the 1600A main with an 800A main is the recommended solution. This is because the main breaker in the switchboard is no longer protecting any upstream equipment and provides no protection to the feeder conductors.
Additional Considerations and NEC Sections
NEC 110.3(B) Installation and Use
Requires equipment to be installed and used according to listing and labeling instructions. The switchboard may have labeling related to its maximum overcurrent protection.
NEC 110.3(A) Examination, Identification, Installation, and Use of Equipment. You have to use the correct equipment for the installation. Using a 1600 amp main where you only are receiving 800 amp is not ideal. NEC 408 Switchboards, Switchgear, and Panelboards
This article covers the installation requirements for switchboards, including overcurrent protection and conductor sizing.
NEC 408.36 Overcurrent Protection
Each feeder and branch circuit shall be protected by an overcurrent device rated or set at not more than the ampacity of the conductors. (This reinforces the need for the 800A protection.)
NEC 408.30 Interior Wiring
"Only those conductors used for circuit wiring, control, signaling, and communications shall be located in switchboards and panelboards." This is less relevant to your specific question but highlights the importance of proper wiring practices.
NEC 408.36 Overcurrent Protection. This is relevant to the breaker inside the switchboard.
Recommendation
The best and most compliant solution is to replace the 1600A main breaker in the switchboard with an 800A main breaker. This ensures proper coordination and protection of the entire system. It prevents potential overloading of the 800A feeders and simplifies future troubleshooting.
Important Notes
Local AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction)
Always consult with your local electrical inspector or AHJ. They have the final say in what is acceptable in your specific location and may have additional requirements or interpretations.
Engineering Judgment
A qualified electrical engineer should review the entire system to ensure proper coordination, selective tripping, and compliance with all applicable codes and standards.*
Documentation: Keep detailed records of all changes made to the electrical system, including drawings, calculations, and equipment specifications.This information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute professional engineering advice. You must consult with qualified professionals before making any changes to electrical systems. Flag for review