Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Old Post HR's

User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ

Asked on: Thursday, September 26, 2024 at 3:53 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:01 am EST

Question: Came across this old thread. So if you had EMT with circuit out of a panel to a box right outside the closet then switched over to MC cables out to a hr box in the field would you consider the MC cable "homeruns"? Thanks."'Homerun'" definitionHello all, New to the forum. I'm also new to being an estimator. Working on a bigger project so I need to make sure I'm taking this off correctly. Engineer is allowing MC cable for branch circuits, but not for Homeruns. 'Homerun' isn't defined in the specs, and I know the NEC doesn't define it...

Okay, let's break down the scenario and the definition of "homerun" in this context, considering the original thread and your question.

Understanding the Scenario EMT Conduit from Panel

You start with EMT (Electrical Metallic Tubing) coming directly from the electrical panel.


Junction Box Outside Closet

The EMT terminates into a junction box located just outside of a closet.

MC Cable to Field

From that junction box, you switch to MC (Metal-Clad) cable, and that MC cable runs out to a "HR box" (likely meaning a "device box" or "handy box" for outlets, switches, or fixtures) in the field (meaning the area where the devices being powered are located).

Is the MC Cable a "Homrun" in this scenario?
It depends on the spec. Since the spec in the original question does not include a definition of "Homrun" we can not know for sure. Likely, Yes, the MC cable is considered a "homerun". Here's why, considering common industry understanding: "Homerun" Meaning

In electrical work, a "homerun" typically refers to the entire circuit run from the electrical panel to the first device box (outlet, switch, light fixture, etc.) on that circuit. It's the direct and uninterrupted feed.

Circuit Starts at Panel

The circuit originates at the panel. The entire path, regardless of the wiring method used in different sections, is
part of the same circuit. The MC Cable is carrying the power from the point in which it splits from the circuit at the junction box.

Engineer's Intent

The engineer is trying to limit the use of MC Cable, and this is a typical specification.

Important Considerations
1. Clarify the Definition

The most crucial thing is to get a clear definition of "homerun" from the engineer. The absence of a definition in the specifications or NEC leaves room for interpretation, which can lead to change orders and cost overruns. Contacting the design engineer is always recommended when ambiguity exists. Ask: "What constitutes a 'homerun' in these specifications?" "Is the entire circuit run from the panel considered the homerun, or only a specific portion?" "What are the specific limitations for MC cable usage?"2.

Engineer's Rationale

Knowing
why the engineer is restricting MC cable on homeruns can help with interpretation. Common reasons include:

Fire Resistance

In some applications (especially high-rise or commercial), EMT might be preferred for its fire resistance.

Durability/Protection

EMT provides better physical protection in certain environments.


Cost

EMT may be cheaper than MC.

Flexibility and Labor

MC cable is often used as a flexible means to reach devices. The engineer may want to limit the flexibility.3.

AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction)

If the engineer doesn't provide a clear definition, consult with your local electrical inspector. They might have a standard interpretation of "homerun" in your area.4.

Alternative Interpretation (Less Likely, But Possible)

It's
possible (though less likely) that the engineer intends "homerun" to mean only the wiring inside the closet or a specific length from the panel. This is less common because it creates a somewhat arbitrary distinction. But, always clarify.

In conclusion

Based on general electrical industry understanding, the MC cable in your scenario
would likely* be considered part of the "homerun," and therefore subject to the specification limiting MC cable for homeruns. But, you MUST get a definitive answer from the engineer to avoid issues.

Your Next Steps


Contact the Engineer

This is the most important step. Get a clear and unambiguous definition of "homerun."2.

Document Everything

Keep a record of your communication with the engineer and any clarifications you receive.3.

Adjust Your Estimate:
Once you have a clear understanding of the requirements, adjust your estimate accordingly to reflect the correct wiring methods. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question