Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Klein ET450 tracing giving me false reading need a little help if possible

User: dfphoto, Location: los angeles

Asked on: Friday, September 27, 2024 at 1:25 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:02 am EST

Question: Dear group, I'm an appliance tech apologies if not being an electrician is not allowed. I own a condo and have an open Line wire from a light switch to an outlet in a bedroom. My Klein ET450 has not been as great so far.1. Tested continuity with a wire to wire connection using a DMM black no continuity, red and white have continuity.2. With 120v no voltage on the Black, White, or ground wires. I'm assuming an Open in a junction box, we have had about 4 smaller earthquakes lately.3. I have an ET450 and the ethernet VDV500 tone generator as well. Both showed a potential issue in the drywall near a corner. Opening the wall resulted in a solid wire false reading.4. I tried the unit following the directions with ground using a water line pipe and the in box ground with the same results.5. I tried different sensitivity settings from 5-6-7(8 is max) currently showing me two potential areas on a different wall 1 above the light switch and another about 6 feet away above an outlet that is fed by a different circuit.The condo has 3/4 drywall thickness and I am not trusting my meters since the above, wondering if I might be doing something you don't agree with. I let the meter have 5-10 sec to send the beam out before moving a few inches, and I have tried letting the meter go to 0 before getting a reading. a I can normally get some reading. 10-20 and a few areas I see changes in the 30-50% range but that's exactly what happened on hole #1.On setting 5 with no power I get about 55 on the drywall as a solid reading on 6 I can get to 99(max) the manual said to use the middle scale where possible. On level 7 I was not placing the (hand wand) on the drywall at all and to get some readings on areas where I was seeing 0 or close to 0 (4-13). Thank you if you can help me out.From the manual:TRACING WIRES1. Connect the Transmitter to the circuit to be traced and power onthe Transmitter.NOTE: The direct ground and remote ground connection methodscan be used on both energized and de-energized circuits, but anenergized circuit produces a higher signal strength.2. Power on the Receiver, and use the Increase Sensitivity button 4,to set the Sensitivity Level to 8 (highest level).3. Starting a few feet from the Transmitter, slowly move the Receiveraround to locate the direction of the strongest signal. The wires maybe located behind the wall, in the ceiling, or underneath the floor.NOTE: If the signal strength displays "99", the signal is saturated.Use the Decrease Sensitivity button 5 to reduce the sensitivity level.NOTE: If the signal strength is too weak, use the Remote Groundconnection method (if not done already) to strengthen the signal.4. Continue to follow the location of the highest signal strength untilthe destination is reached.NOTE: If the circuit is de-energized, the Transmitter can beconnected to the neutral and ground wires, which will create astronger closed loop signal, as neutral and ground are bondedtogether at the panel.

Okay, let's break down this issue and address your troubleshooting steps. It sounds like you're methodical, which is good, but wire tracers can be tricky. Here's a structured approach, combined with tips and things to consider

Understanding the Problem
Open Line Wire

This means the hot (black) wire is broken somewhere between the light switch and the outlet. No power is reaching the outlet.


Earthquakes & Loose Connections

Earthquakes could definitely have loosened a wire nut or connection in a junction box.

False Readings

Drywall, especially if slightly damp or containing metal components (like corner beads), can create false readings for wire tracers.

Critical Safety Considerations
Turn off the breaker

ALWAYS de-energize the circuit you're working on. Verify with your meter that there is NO voltage before touching any wires. Even when you think it's off, double-check.

Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)

Wear safety glasses and insulated gloves.


Working with Electricity

If you're uncomfortable or unsure about any of these steps, it's best to call a qualified electrician. Electrical work can be dangerous.

Troubleshooting Steps & Best Practices
1. Confirm No Power (Again)

Turn off the breaker. Use your DMM to verify no voltage between the black wire and neutral, black wire and ground, and neutral and ground at both the light switch and the outlet.2.

Visual Inspection of Accessible Junction Boxes



Light Switch Box

Start by carefully inspecting the light switch box. Look for:
Loose wire nuts. Wires that have come completely disconnected. Burn marks or signs of arcing (indicating a bad connection). Wires that are cracked or brittle.

Outlet Box

Inspect the outlet box for the same issues.

Other Accessible Boxes

Are there any other easily accessible junction boxes along the likely path of the wiring between the switch and outlet? Check those, too. (Attic, basement, accessible crawl space?)3.

Continuity Testing (with NO POWER)



Isolate the Circuit

Disconnect the black wire at both the light switch and the outlet. This is crucial to avoid getting false readings from other connected circuits.

Test

Now, use your DMM in continuity mode.
Touch one probe to the black wire at the light switch box. Touch the other probe to the black wire at the outlet box. If you get no continuity, you have a break somewhere in between.4.

Advanced Wire Tracing (With Cautions)



Isolate the Circuit

Again, make sure the circuit is de-energized and the black wire is disconnected at both ends.


Grounding

Good ground is key for wire tracers to work well.

Remote Ground is Best

The instructions say if the signal strength is too weak, use the remote ground connection method to strengthen the signal.


Connecting

Connect the Transmitter to the black wire and the remote ground.

Start at the Source

Begin tracing from the light switch box.


Sensitivity

Start high (level 8) and adjust downwards until you get a clear signal.

Slow and Steady

Move the receiver
very slowly and deliberately. A few inches at a time.

Mark Potential Spots

When you get a strong signal, mark that spot on the wall.

Trace the Path

Carefully trace the
likely path of the wiring. Remember, wires usually run horizontally or vertically, not diagonally, inside walls.

Consider Conduit

Is the wiring in conduit (metal or plastic tubing)? If so, tracing becomes much more difficult.5.

Interpreting Tracer Results



Don't Trust It Blindly

Wire tracers are not perfect. False positives are common.


Look for Patterns

Look for areas where the signal consistently gets stronger or weaker.

"Cold Spots"

Pay attention to areas where the signal suddenly disappears. This could indicate the break.6.

Dealing with False Readings



Metal

Be aware of metal objects in the wall (pipes, studs, corner beads). These can interfere with the signal.

Moisture

Moisture in the drywall can also create false readings.


Move Objects

Try removing any metal objects near the wall to see if it affects the readings.7.

When to Call an Electrician

If you've tried these steps and still can't find the break. If you're uncomfortable or unsure about any part of the process. If you find any signs of damage or overheating (burn marks, melted insulation). If the wiring is complex or difficult to access.

Specific Comments on Your Actions



Opening the Wall

Avoid opening the wall unless you have very strong evidence that the break is in that location. Opening walls unnecessarily is time-consuming and messy.


Different Circuits

The fact that you're getting readings on a different circuit suggests interference or that you're not properly isolating the circuit you're trying to trace.

Using Tone Generator VDV500

if your running a new line, this is a great tool to make sure that the right line has been run. I wouldn't use it for this project.

In summary



Safety First.
Isolate the circuit for accurate testing. Start with visual inspections of accessible connections. Use the wire tracer methodically, but don't rely on it exclusively. Consider calling a professional if you get stuck.

Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question