User: arc_flashed, Location: FL, United States
Asked on: Friday, September 27, 2024 at 12:10 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:04 am EST
Question: Hoping someone can help clear up a bit of confusion.I have a motor/vfd panel that has (2) 125HP VFDs and a small AC load. Per NEC 430.24 I've calculated my feeder conductor ampacity as 354 amps.Does this value require that my upstream feeder breaker be sized at a minimum of 354 amps? I know the cable must be at least capable of carrying this ampacity but I am having a hard time finding the section that would determine if I need to have a 400amp breaker or if a 350amp would be acceptable by code.
Okay, let's break down the NEC requirements and address your question about the feeder breaker size.
Understanding NEC 430.24
NEC 430.24 (Conductor Size for Several Motors or Motor(s) and Other Load(s)) is indeed the correct article for determining the minimum ampacity of your feeder conductors. Your calculation of 354 amps, assuming it's based on the correct application of 430.24, establishes the floor for your conductor ampacity.
The Key: Overcurrent Protection and NEC 430.62 & 430.63
The breaker (or fuses) that protect your feeder are governed by a different set of rules than the conductor sizing. You're looking at NEC 430.62 and NEC 430.63 which are related to overload protection of the conductors. 430.62 Feeder Overcurrent Protection
This section addresses the maximum rating of the overcurrent protective device (OCPD) protecting the feeder. It's essentially designed to prevent the feeder conductors from being overloaded and damaged.
430.63 Feeder Overcurrent Protection — Motor and Other Loads
This section provides guidance when you have a combination of motor loads and other loads connected to the feeder, as in your case.
How to Apply the Rules
Here's the general process to determine the maximum allowable feeder breaker size, based on NEC, and incorporating your calculated 354-amp conductor ampacity.1. Calculate the Maximum Feeder Overcurrent Protection based on VFDs VFD as a Motor
For the purpose of NEC 430, treat each VFD as a single motor.
NEC 430.52 and Table 430.52
You can use the values on this table to size the breaker on the LOAD SIDE of the VFD. This would be the short circuit or overload protection on the vfd itself.
VFD Input Current vs. Motor FLA
It's CRITICAL to use the input current rating of the VFD, not the equivalent full-load amps (FLA) of the motor it's driving. This information should be on the VFD's nameplate. Sometimes you can get away with using the motor nameplate, but this is less common as it generally needs to be derived from the kVA/HP ratio.
Using 430.62
The feeder breaker is not directly related to the values in table 430.52.
430.22
This article describes how to size conductors. 125% of the largest motor (VFD) rating, plus the sum of all the other loads.
430.24
You then take your number from 430.22 to get your feeder wire size.
2.
Calculate the Overcurrent Protection for the "Other Load(s)" Determine the total ampacity of your other loads (AC load). This is likely straightforward and based on their nameplate ratings.3. NEC 430.63 Calculation
Here's where NEC 430.63 comes in.First add the two largest motor/VFDs' ratings that you calculated in step 1. After these are added, you add all the other loads. The total is equal to the highest amount of OCPD your panel can be protected with.
Important Considerations and Cautions
VFD Manufacturer Recommendations
Always consult the VFD manufacturer's installation manual. They may have specific requirements for upstream overcurrent protection, conductor sizing, and grounding that supersede the general NEC requirements. Adhering to the manufacturer's recommendations is crucial for warranty compliance and proper operation.
Selective Coordination
If you have a multi-level distribution system, consider selective coordination. This means ensuring that a fault downstream is cleared by the closest upstream protective device, minimizing the impact on the overall system. NEC Article 700.27 covers this specifically for emergency systems.
Engineering Judgement
NEC is a minimum standard. An engineer might choose to upsize conductors or overcurrent devices based on specific application needs, future load growth, or other factors.
Submit drawings to AHJ The authority having jurisdiction has final say on what they will approve.
Back to Your Specific Question
Given your 354-amp calculated conductor ampacity, it does not necessarily mean you must have a 400-amp breaker. You can use a 350 amp breaker if the calculations using NEC 430.63 show that it's sufficient to protect the feeder and all loads connected to it, and if it falls within the constraints of any VFD manufacturer requirements.
In summary you should perform 430.22, 430.24, and 430.63, as well as verifying the manufacturers specifications of all equipment involved. If you do not feel comfortable doing this, contact a certified PE in your area.
Disclaimer: This information is for educational purposes only and should not be considered as a substitute for professional electrical engineering advice. Always consult with a qualified electrical engineer or licensed electrician for the design and installation of electrical systems. They can properly assess your specific needs, perform the necessary calculations, and ensure compliance with all applicable codes and regulations. Flag for review