User: ManicTulip76, Location: TN
Asked on: Saturday, September 28, 2024 at 11:02 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:05 am EST
Question: Just looking for something that would work for this install. Tankless water heaters are tricky and in this townhouse subdivision Im almost sure there wouldnt be allowance for a 400A panel upgrade.Last time I did one the owner told me to install the one he asked for even though I told him it was too much draw for a 200A panel (It was, it kept tripping other breakers and we ended up downsizing)Anyway, now we are in a new townhouse and we are gonna do it again....thoughts and recommendations please
Okay, I understand the situation. You're looking for a tankless water heater that will work reliably in a townhouse with a likely 200A electrical service, and you want to avoid overloading the panel. You also want to avoid a repeat of the situation where you installed a unit that was too powerful and caused problems.Here's a breakdown of things to consider and recommendations, keeping in mind I can't give definitive advice without seeing the specific electrical setup
Key Considerations for Tankless in a Townhouse with 200A Service:
Existing Load
This is the most critical factor. What's the existing electrical load in the townhouse? Consider the following:
Heating/Cooling
Electric furnace, central AC, window units, etc. These are big power users.
Appliances
Electric stove, oven, dryer, microwave, dishwasher, refrigerator(s), washer, etc.
Other
Electric car charger (Level 1 or 2), hot tub, well pump, electric baseboard heaters in certain rooms.
General Lighting & Outlets
While individual lights and outlets don't draw much, collectively they can add up.
Voltage Drop
Long wire runs (especially from the panel to the water heater location) can cause voltage drop, which reduces the unit's efficiency and lifespan. Proper wire gauge is essential.
Coldest Incoming Water Temperature
The colder the incoming water, the more energy the tankless heater needs to use to raise the water temperature to the desired setting. This affects the required BTU output.
Number of Simultaneous Hot Water Demands
How many showers, faucets, or appliances (e.g., dishwasher) might be running at the same time? This determines the required flow rate (GPM).
Gas vs. Electric
Gas tankless water heaters are generally more energy-efficient and can provide higher flow rates than electric tankless heaters, but they require a gas line. If you don't have a gas line, electric is your only option.
Code Requirements
Local electrical codes may have specific requirements for tankless water heater installations, including dedicated circuits, overcurrent protection, and grounding.
Manufacturer's Specifications
Carefully review the manufacturer's specifications for each tankless water heater model, including the voltage, amperage, BTU input, and required wire gauge.
Recommendations
Load Calculation (Crucial)
Perform a proper electrical load calculation according to the National Electrical Code (NEC) and local codes. This is essential to determine the available capacity of the 200A panel. You need to account for all existing loads before even considering a tankless heater. An electrician experienced in load calculations is highly recommended. Many tankless manufacturers also have tools to help you approximate the load.2. Consider a "Point-of-Use" Tankless Heater
If your load calculation indicates limited capacity, consider multiple point-of-use tankless heaters. These are smaller, lower-powered units installed directly at the point of use (e.g., a bathroom sink, a kitchen sink). They require less power than a whole-house unit.
Advantages
Lower electrical demand, easier to install, potentially lower cost overall.
Disadvantages
Requires multiple units, hot water only available at the specific point of use.3.
Electric Tankless Heater Options (Assuming You Can't Get Gas)
Lower BTU/kW Models
Look for electric tankless heaters with lower BTU/kW ratings. These will have lower amperage draws. However, they may not be able to provide sufficient hot water for multiple simultaneous uses.
Modulating Tankless Heaters
Some electric tankless heaters are "modulating," meaning they adjust their power output based on the demand for hot water. This can help reduce the overall electrical load.
Consider these brands/models (but CHECK SPECS & CALCULATE LOAD)
Rheem
Rheem is a reputable brand with a range of electric tankless water heaters. Check their specs carefully.
Ecosmart
They make smaller, whole-house electric units (13-27 kW models) and point-of-use units. Good if you need smaller sizes.
Stiebel Eltron
High-quality German-engineered units. They offer both whole-house and point-of-use models.
Note
All these brands have different power requirements. Don't just buy based on brand; check the specs.4.
Gas Tankless Heater Options (If Applicable)
Navien
Known for high efficiency and reliability. Check model-specific venting requirements.
Rinnai
Another leading brand with a wide range of models.
Noritz
Solid reputation.
Important
You'll still need to run a small electrical circuit (usually 120V) to the gas tankless heater for the controls and ignition.5.
Important Installation Practices
Dedicated Circuit
Tankless water heaters must have a dedicated circuit from the electrical panel.
Proper Wire Gauge
Use the correct wire gauge specified by the manufacturer. Oversizing the wire is always better than undersizing.
Overcurrent Protection
Install the correct size circuit breaker or fuse as specified by the manufacturer.
Professional Installation
Tankless water heater installations are complex and should be performed by a qualified electrician and/or plumber.6.
Communication is Key Be upfront and honest with the homeowner from the start. Explain the limitations of the 200A panel and the importance of a proper load calculation. Clearly explain the different options (whole-house vs. point-of-use) and the pros and cons of each. Get the homeowner's approval on the selected tankless water heater model before you start the installation. Provide a written estimate that includes all costs (materials, labor, permits, etc.).
Example Scenario (Illustrative)
Let's say after a load calculation, you determine that you have 60 amps available on the 200 amp panel after accounting for all the other appliances and devices. You might consider an electric tankless water heater that draws no more than 50 amps. This gives you a bit of headroom to avoid overloading the panel. However, a 50-amp unit might not be able to provide enough hot water for multiple simultaneous uses, so you might need to consider a point-of-use unit instead.
To give you a more specific recommendation, I need more information. Tell me
What is the existing electrical load in the townhouse? (Be as specific as possible.) What is the coldest incoming water temperature? How many simultaneous hot water demands are likely? Do you have a gas line available?* What is the distance from the electrical panel to the water heater location?Disclaimer: I am an AI chatbot and cannot provide professional electrical or plumbing advice. This information is for general guidance only. Always consult with a qualified electrician and plumber before installing a tankless water heater. Flag for review