Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Replacing a 480v RTU

User: Sparky202, Location: Washington DC

Asked on: Saturday, September 28, 2024 at 12:20 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:06 am EST

Question: We currently have a 480V 3-Phase RTU with a 132amp MCA and 150amp MOP that needs to be replaced. The new RTU has a higher amperage, with a 147amp MCA and 175amp MOP. The question is whether we can continue to use the existing (3) 1/0 THHN feeder on a 150amp breaker for the new RTU. The feeder is 92ft long. The building engineer is confident that the existing feeder and breaker will suffice, but the building inspector advises against it. Any guidance on this matter would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.

This is a classic electrical sizing problem with conflicting advice, and the inspector is likely correct. Here's a breakdown of the issues and why replacing the feeder is likely the safest and most code-compliant solution

Arguments Against Keeping the Existing Feeder and Breaker:
Code Violation (Likely)

The most compelling reason is the NEC (National Electrical Code) requirement to protect equipment. The MOP (Maximum Overcurrent Protection) of 175A

exceeds
the rating of your existing 150A breaker. NEC 440.22 (and potentially other sections depending on the specific equipment) dictates how to size the overcurrent protection based on the MOP. Ignoring the MOP rating violates the code and potentially voids the equipment warranty.
NEC 440.22

This section specifically addresses air-conditioning and refrigeration equipment. It requires you to size the overcurrent protection device (breaker) according to the MOP listed on the equipment nameplate. If the MOP is 175A, you must have an overcurrent device that size or less, but no less than the sum of the branch circuit overcurrent protection for the compressors, fan motors, and other loads, plus 125% of the full load current rating of the largest motor or compressor. This means you cannot use the existing 150A breaker.

Breaker Nuisance Tripping

While the RTU
might operate without tripping the 150A breaker, the higher MOP suggests that the unit is designed to potentially draw more than 150A under certain conditions (e.g., starting current, high ambient temperatures, etc.). This means the 150A breaker could nuisance trip, causing disruptions and potentially damaging the RTU.

Marginal Conductor Ampacity

1/0 THHN is typically rated for 170 amps at 75°C. However, to be safe, we need to verify derating factors due to ambient temperature, number of conductors in a conduit, and voltage drop. The existing configuration is cutting it close to its maximum, and if any derating is required, the 1/0 might not be sufficient.

Arguments For Keeping the Existing Feeder and Breaker (and why they're often insufficient)



The Engineer's Confidence

The engineer might be thinking the RTU will
typically draw less than 150A under normal operation. This could be true, but the MOP is not about "typical" operation; it's about the maximum potential current draw under all possible operating conditions.

Voltage Drop

Voltage drop is a valid concern, but it doesn't justify an undersized breaker. The existing 92-foot run of 1/0 THHN should be adequate for voltage drop at 480V if the conductor is adequately sized for the current demand. Use a voltage drop calculator to verify. If voltage drop is a concern, increasing the conductor size is the solution, not keeping an undersized breaker.

Cost Savings

While understandable, saving money by using undersized components is a dangerous and code-violating shortcut.

Recommendation



Replace the Feeder and Breaker

This is the safest, most code-compliant, and ultimately the best long-term solution.

Breaker

Install a breaker sized according to the MOP rating on the new RTU (175A). Standard breaker sizes are available at 175A.


Conductor

Choose a conductor size with an ampacity sufficient for 125% of the MCA, and that also is sufficient for the breaker size you will use. Using the MCA of 147A, 125% = 184A. In this case, we'd probably move up to a #2/0 THHN, which can handle 195 amps at 75 degrees.

Voltage Drop Calculation

Recalculate voltage drop with the new conductor size.


Consult the NEC

Review NEC Article 440 (Air-Conditioning and Refrigeration Equipment) to ensure full compliance.

Do Not Rely on the Engineer's Assurance Alone

While their experience is valuable, the code and the MOP rating on the equipment are paramount.

Important Considerations



Local Codes and Amendments

Be sure to check with your local authority having jurisdiction (AHJ) for any local amendments to the NEC. They have the final say.

Equipment Warranty

Using an undersized breaker could void the RTU's warranty.


Safety

Ultimately, the safety of the installation is the most important consideration. A correctly sized feeder and breaker will protect against overloads and short circuits, preventing fires and equipment damage.

In summary, the inspector is most likely correct. The increased amperage requirements of the new RTU necessitate upgrading the feeder and breaker to comply with the NEC and ensure safe and reliable operation. The minimal cost savings of reusing the existing conductors are not worth the risks of code violations, nuisance tripping, and potential equipment damage.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question