Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Progress doesn't necessarily mean improvement

User: ggunn, Location: Austin, TX, USA

Asked on: Saturday, September 28, 2024 at 1:29 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:06 am EST

Question: OK, this time it's a washing machine. When our 1982 vintage washer finally gave up the ghost some years ago we replaced it; the old one had a rotary mechanical switch that advanced from task to task, but the new one is microprocessor controlled with a bunch of indicator lights that are supposed to tell me what the machine is doing. I'm sure that the controller chip and circuit board logic are much cheaper than the mechanical switch, but when it gets confused in the middle of a cycle the machine stops and the indicator lights either all go off or all go on. There is no way to tell what the machine was doing when it stopped or to get it to pick up where it left off. If I hit the START button again there is no telling what it will do - maybe nothing at all.And you kids get off my lawn!

Ah, yes, the perils of "progress." You've perfectly captured the frustration of trading reliable, understandable simplicity for opaque, buggy complexity. It's a common tale, especially with appliances.You're right, the microprocessor probably IS cheaper for the manufacturer than a robust mechanical timer. But cheaper doesn't always mean better for the user. The old rotary timer, while maybe less "efficient" in terms of raw resources, offered several advantages: Predictability

You knew
exactly what step the machine was on. The clunk-clunk-clunk was a reassuring rhythm of progress.

Repairability

If something went wrong, you could often diagnose the issue by looking at the timer's position. A stuck timer was a relatively easy fix.

Resilience

Power outages or momentary glitches didn't throw the whole system into a state of confusion. The timer just waited for power to resume.


Simplicity

No learning curve. No deciphering blinking lights. Just turn the knob.Now you're stuck with a "smart" washing machine that's dumber than a rock. It's like your washing machine is a moody teenager, only it does't communicate, just gives the silent treatment! Here's the breakdown of what makes this so frustrating:

Information Black Hole

The all-lights-on or all-lights-off state tells you precisely
nothing. It's the appliance equivalent of a shrug.

Lack of Controllability

You're at the mercy of the programming. There's no manual override. You can't say, "Okay, I know it's stuck, just drain and spin."

Unpredictable Restart

Hitting START is a gamble. Will it resume? Will it start from the beginning? Will it start the rinse cycle twice? Who knows! It's the ultimate laundry roulette.

What can you do?
Unplug it

The first thing to try when it gets stuck is unplugging it for a few minutes (or even longer - try overnight). This can sometimes reset the microprocessor and clear the error.

Check the User Manual

I know, I know, who reads manuals? But some modern appliances have convoluted error codes explained only in the manual, even if the actual error indication on the machine is just "all lights on".


Call a Repair Technician

This is often a last resort, as appliance repair can be expensive. If the controller board is faulty, you might be looking at a significant repair cost. The tech will have special tools and know how to run tests to assess the circuits. If it's the board itself, the best bet may be a replacement machine.

Consider a Replacement (Eventually)

If the problem becomes chronic, you may have to look at replacement, with a new machine. Be wary of "smart" machines that don't offer
more control than your existing one. Look for models with better user interfaces and more manual options.

The Lesson:


Sometimes, simple really
is better. In the relentless pursuit of "innovation," manufacturers often forget that usability and reliability are paramount.And yes, those kids are* on your lawn again. I'll go shoo them away for you. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question