Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: I hate these switches

User: Tainted, Location: New York

Asked on: Saturday, September 28, 2024 at 7:52 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:07 am EST

Question: Does anybody know how to properly open these Siemens Vacu-Break type switches without cutting off the power? I know it's possible because I've seen it done before.I think we have to stick a screw driver below the lever, we tried it however the electrician and I were having trouble with this so we gave up and said we would worry about it later...I am now coming back to the building to do the survey for a design... I need to access the compartment to see the fuse type and size...

Okay, let's address opening Siemens Vacu-Break switches safely and properly without cutting off the power. It's crucial to understand that working with energized electrical equipment is inherently dangerous and should only be done by qualified electricians wearing appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE). I will provide the general procedure based on what you've described and my knowledge, but this information is for informational purposes only and should not be considered a substitute for proper training and expertise. If you are not a qualified electrician, DO NOT ATTEMPT THIS. Call a qualified electrician.Safety First! Before Even Thinking About Opening It Energized



Qualified Personnel ONLY

This should be performed only by qualified electricians experienced with Vacu-Break switches and arc flash hazards.


PPE (Personal Protective Equipment)

Arc-rated clothing (suit or appropriate layers), face shield, safety glasses, insulated gloves, and hearing protection are essential. Determine the Arc Flash Hazard category for the equipment and use the correct PPE. Never compromise on PPE.

Proper Tools

Use insulated tools specifically designed for electrical work. This includes the correct type and size of screwdriver.


Clear Communication

Inform others in the area that you will be working on energized equipment and to stay clear.

Lockout/Tagout Considerations

Even though you're trying to avoid a full outage, consider if any downstream equipment
could be affected and needs to be properly identified and safeguarded.

Verification of Absence of Voltage

Before touching anything inside the compartment, use a properly rated voltage meter to confirm that all parts are de-energized after opening the switch. This confirms the switch is operating as expected.

General Procedure (Use with Extreme Caution and Only If Qualified)

Based on your description of using a screwdriver below the lever, you're likely referring to a mechanism designed to bypass the normal tripping action. Here's a more detailed breakdown of how these switches typically operate and the bypass procedure:1.

Understand the Mechanism

Vacu-Break switches have a visible blade that moves between the "ON" and "OFF" positions. They also have an internal mechanism that uses vacuum interrupters to extinguish the arc when the switch is opened under load. The "screwdriver method" you described is a way to manually move the operating lever to disengage a secondary contact, allowing the enclosure door to be opened without causing the switch to trip off.2.

Identify the Bypass Point

Look closely below the operating lever on the switch. There may be a small slot or opening specifically designed for a screwdriver. Sometimes there will be markings indicating the purpose of this area. Refer to the switch's documentation if available.3.

Engage the Bypass (If Applicable)

With insulated gloves and tools, carefully insert the correct size and type of insulated screwdriver into the slot. The goal is to gently lift or depress the lever to disengage the secondary contact.4.

Open the Door

While holding the screwdriver in place, attempt to open the door of the switch compartment. The switch should not trip. If it does, stop immediately. You are either doing something wrong, or the switch is not designed to operate in the manner you are trying.5.

Inspect the Fuses

Once the door is open, you should have access to the fuses. Document the fuse type, size, and any other relevant information.6.

Closing the Door

To close the door, reverse the process: Make sure nothing is obstructing the door's movement. Hold the screwdriver in the bypass position. Close the door carefully. Remove the screwdriver. The switch should remain in the "ON" position.

Important Considerations and Potential Problems



Switch Condition

The success of this procedure depends on the condition of the switch. If the switch is old, corroded, or damaged, the bypass mechanism may not function properly. Forcing it could cause damage or a hazardous situation.


Arc Flash Hazard

Even with the bypass engaged, there is still a risk of arc flash if something goes wrong. Ensure you're wearing appropriate PPE and maintain a safe distance from energized parts.

Documentation

Ideally, you should have the manufacturer's documentation for the specific Vacu-Break switch you are working on. This will provide detailed instructions on how to safely open and close the switch.


Alternative

If there is an upstream isolation switch or breaker, it might be safer to de-energize the entire circuit to access the fuses. Weigh the risks and benefits of each approach.

Age of Equipment

Older Vacu-Break switches may not have the same safety features as newer models. Exercise extreme caution.

Why You Might Be Having Trouble



Incorrect Screwdriver

Using the wrong size or type of screwdriver can damage the bypass mechanism.

Corrosion or Dirt

The mechanism might be seized up due to corrosion or dirt.


Incorrect Procedure

You might be trying the wrong procedure for that particular model of Vacu-Break switch.*

Damaged Switch

The switch may already be damaged, making the bypass impossible or dangerous.

Recommendation

Given your uncertainty and the potential dangers, my strongest recommendation is to

consult a qualified electrician who is experienced with Siemens Vacu-Break switches and arc flash hazards
. They can properly assess the situation, determine the safest approach, and perform the work with the appropriate tools and PPE. Trying to force the bypass mechanism without proper knowledge could result in serious injury or damage to the equipment.Good luck, and please prioritize safety above all else. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question