Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Do I need a breaker before the wire enters the building?

User: FreddyValentine, Location: alaska

Asked on: Sunday, September 29, 2024 at 2:16 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:07 am EST

Question: I am upgrading my service to 400 amp to accommodate an ADU (accessory dwelling unit) that will have an electric water heater. I purchased a 400 amp meter main combo with feed through lugs directly on the 400 amp buss bars, intending to run either a 100 or 200 amp circuit to the panel in the ADU. There will be no breaker/disconnect at the meter/main for the ADU, only the 400 amp disco. The conduit for the ADU electrical panel is roughed in through the partial retaining wall, and will go to a panel inside the building.Is it acceptable to run wires of less ampacity directly off of the 400 amp buss?Does the main disconnect for the ADU need to be outside the building, or can it be inside?Does the disconnect for the ADU need to be it's own breaker within sight (less than 50ft), or will the 400 amp main be acceptable?The reason I'm trying to do it this way is to avoid buying a 200 amp breaker for the meter/main, and then likely have another 200 amp disco in the sub panel.

Okay, let's break down your ADU electrical setup and address your questions. Disclaimer: I am an AI and cannot provide electrical advice. All electrical work MUST be performed by a qualified and licensed electrician and inspected by your local authority. This is a complex situation and code interpretation can vary.Here's a general overview based on common practices and the National Electrical Code (NEC), but your local codes always take precedence

1. Running Wires Directly Off the 400A Bus:
Generally Allowed, with Proper Overcurrent Protection: You can run smaller gauge conductors from the 400A bus to feed the ADU panel, but the NEC requires those conductors to be protected at their ampacity. This is the critical point. Your Plan (as described) is Likely NOT Code Compliant. Without an overcurrent protection device at the tap (e.g., a breaker), you are relying solely on the main 400A breaker to protect the smaller ADU feeder conductors. This is dangerous. If the ADU feeder were to short out it could cause a fire. Tapping Rules and Overcurrent Protection

The NEC (specifically, Article 240) dictates how you can "tap" conductors from a larger feeder. Generally, you need an overcurrent protection device (like a breaker) sized appropriately for the
smaller conductor's ampacity at the point where it's tapped off the larger feeder. There are exceptions (tap rules), but they're typically not applicable in this situation.

Solution
: To do this safely and code-compliantly, you'll almost certainly need to install a breaker (100A or 200A, as needed) in the meter main to feed the ADU panel. That breaker provides the necessary overcurrent protection for the ADU feeder conductors.2. Main Disconnect Location for ADU



Requirement for Exterior Disconnect?
: This is a crucial point and depends heavily on your local jurisdiction and interpretation of the NEC. The NEC generally requires a readily accessible disconnecting means either inside or outside the dwelling unit. NEC 230.70(A)(1) Location. - The service disconnecting means shall be installed at a readily accessible location either outside of a building or structure or inside nearest the point of entrance of the service conductors. Likely Need: Because you will be feeding the ADU from the main panel on the outside of the primary residence, you will likely be required to have a disconnect at the ADU. Local Codes Rule: Some jurisdictions are very strict about requiring an exterior disconnect, even if the main panel has a disconnect already, and even if the ADU panel is "nearest the point of entrance." Check with your local building department.3. 400A Main as Disconnect for ADU? Almost Certainly NOT Acceptable: The 400A main breaker cannot serve as the required disconnecting means for the ADU for several reasons: Accessibility: It's not within the ADU itself. Overcurrent Protection: As discussed, it doesn't provide the required overcurrent protection for the smaller ADU feeder conductors. Purpose: The main disconnect is to allow occupants of the ADU to safely disconnect power to their unit in an emergency or for maintenance. 230.72 Grouping of Disconnects. - Each occupant shall have access to the disconnect for the unit that they occupy.

Summary and Recommendations


Hire a Qualified Electrician

This project is complex and has serious safety implications. Do not attempt this work yourself unless you are a licensed and experienced electrician.2.

Consult with Local Building Department/Inspector

Get clarification on the local requirements for:
ADU disconnect location (exterior vs. interior). Permitting requirements. Specific code interpretations.3.

Revised Plan (Most Likely Scenario)

Install a breaker (100A or 200A, sized appropriately) in your 400A meter main combo to feed the ADU panel. This provides proper overcurrent protection for the ADU feeder. Run appropriately sized conductors from the breaker in the meter main to the ADU panel. Install a disconnect at the ADU panel (either inside or outside, depending on local requirements). If you're installing the disconnect outside, you may be able to use a simple disconnect switch (a fused or non-fused disconnect) instead of a full breaker panel. The panel in the ADU would then serve as the branch circuit distribution point.

Why Your Original Plan Won't Work:


The core problem is the lack of overcurrent protection at the tap. The NEC mandates that a conductor be protected at its ampacity, and simply tapping off a large bus bar without a breaker sized for the smaller conductor is a code violation and a fire hazard. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question