Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Pancake Boxes

User: Jimmy7, Location: Boston, MA

Asked on: Sunday, September 29, 2024 at 11:35 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:08 am EST

Question: One of my guys has been installing pancake boxes on exterior lights. The problem is that there are two 14-2 cables in some of these. I just found out about this recently, and some of these jobs are done. Would you move on, or try to go back and fix it? Everything has been inspected.

This is a tricky situation that requires careful consideration. Here's a breakdown of the factors to consider and a recommendation

Understanding the Issue
Pancake Boxes and Fill Capacity

Pancake boxes are notoriously shallow. They often struggle to meet the National Electrical Code (NEC) fill requirements, especially with two 14-2 cables.


NEC Concerns



Box Fill (314.16)

The NEC has strict rules about how many conductors, devices, and internal cable clamps can be within an electrical box. Overfilling a box can lead to overheating, wire damage, and potential fire hazards. This is
especially true in exterior applications.

Conductor Bending Radius (314.25)

Overcrowding can force conductors to bend at too sharp an angle, damaging the insulation and potentially causing shorts.

Mechanical Integrity

Overfilling can also compromise the mechanical integrity of the connections, potentially leading to loose wires.


Exterior Considerations

Exterior boxes are subject to moisture, temperature fluctuations, and physical stress, all of which exacerbate problems caused by overcrowding.

Why This is a Problem (Even if Inspected)
Inspections Aren't Perfect

While passing inspection is good, it doesn't guarantee long-term safety or compliance. Inspectors can miss things, and issues can develop over time.


Long-Term Reliability

Even if the connections seem okay now, an overfilled box is more likely to experience problems down the road. Vibration, temperature changes, and normal wear and tear will put extra stress on the wires and connections.

Liability

If a fire or other electrical problem occurs and is traced back to the incorrectly installed boxes, you and your company could be held liable, even if it previously passed inspection.


Reputation

Customer satisfaction and trust are invaluable. A problem arising from a known issue can damage your reputation.

Arguments for Moving On (and Why They're Weak)
"It Passed Inspection"

As mentioned above, this isn't a guarantee.


"It's Too Much Trouble to Fix"

While re-work is never fun, the potential consequences of not fixing it are far worse.

"We Haven't Had Any Problems Yet"

This is short-sighted. Electrical problems often manifest over time.

Arguments for Fixing It (and Why They're Strong)
Safety

This is the most important reason. Overfilled boxes are a safety hazard.

Compliance

You know the installations are likely non-compliant with the NEC.


Professional Responsibility

As a professional electrician, you have a responsibility to ensure that your work is safe and code-compliant.

Peace of Mind

Knowing that you've done the right thing will give you peace of mind.


Long-Term Cost Savings

Fixing the problem now is likely cheaper than dealing with a fire, lawsuit, or damaged reputation later.

Recommendation
You should absolutely go back and fix the installations.

Here's a suggested plan of action:1. Assess the Situation



Document

Take pictures of the existing installations, noting the number of wires, cable clamps, and the type of box.


Verify Fill Calculations

Use NEC 314.16 to calculate the fill capacity of the pancake boxes. Determine if they are indeed overfilled. They almost certainly are with two 14-2 cables.
2.


Determine the Corrective Action



Replace with Deeper Boxes

The ideal solution is to replace the pancake boxes with deeper boxes that provide adequate fill capacity. This will likely require some modification to the mounting surface.


Consider Remote Wiring

In very limited circumstances, and only if allowed by code and approved by the inspector, you might be able to relocate some of the connections to a larger junction box nearby. This is usually not a practical solution.

Use Smaller Wire (Highly Unlikely)

This is
highly unlikely to be a viable solution, as you're probably using the correct wire size for the circuit.3.

Contact the Inspector (Optional but Recommended)

It's often a good idea to inform the inspector that you've identified a potential issue and are taking steps to correct it. They may have specific recommendations or concerns.4.

Implement the Corrective Action

Carefully and safely replace the boxes, ensuring that all connections are secure and that the new boxes meet the fill requirements.5.

Document the Correction

Take pictures of the corrected installations and keep records of the materials used and the work performed.

Important Considerations



Communicate with the Customer

Explain to the customer that you've identified a potential issue with the original installation and are taking steps to correct it to ensure their safety. Most customers will appreciate your honesty and professionalism. Frame it as a proactive measure.*

Train Your Employees

Make sure your employees understand the NEC fill requirements and the importance of using the correct boxes for each application.

In summary, while it might be tempting to ignore the problem, the potential consequences of doing so are far too great. Taking the time to fix the installations now will ensure the safety of your customers, protect your company's reputation, and give you peace of mind.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question