User: Chuck0, Location: Northern California
Asked on: Sunday, September 29, 2024 at 11:44 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:09 am EST
Question: Hi, I am new to posting on the forum here, but I have read a lot of good pointers from these very forums .I am a general residential and light commercial repairman for about 40 years.I have been invited many times to troubleshoot issues.Last year I was asked to track down what seemed to be very random residential AFCI tripping, even into sub panels. All the panels are Siemens and all the breakers were Murray. There were 8 different breakers tripping. Sometimes 2 months between and sometimes the next day. Most tripping seemed to happen about an hour after dark.I brought my TinySA spectrum analyzer to the house and found that the gas range and the range vent system both had a huge amount of wide band RF being generated even just sitting in stand-by. I put a couple of Plug in RF snubber modules in series with the plugs and I thought I had it figured out.... Well 5 weeks later another trip. I had looked long and hard at this, so I called Siemens. They suggested that I borrow their Recording Diagnostic Breaker (RDB), which I did.Just by chance, running through the multiple trips in my head, I grabbed what I felt was the most tripped breaker and went to replace it with the RDB. When I pulled it out small burn marks were evident on the shiny relatively new stabs of the Siemens panel. Looking closely at the Murray AFCI I could see heat discoloration at the bus connection point; . So, I cleaned the Stabs well with some fine ceramic scrubbing pad and installed the borrowed RDB. That breaker happened to be the culprit!RDB installed completely stopped all the tripping. Now after going to the bother of requesting and having the RDB sent to me I couldn’t even use it because I couldn’t get a trip.At any rate I bought a new, this time Siemens AFCI, replaced the RDB and solved all the nonsense tripping.Well that was all good until this week, 5 months later, we had another set of trips within 3 second of each other. The vacuum cleaner tripped one circuit, and 3 seconds later the lights go out- both on the same phase. The owner went right out and bought 2 new Siemens AFCI breakers and I installed them this morning... and what did I find ; more burnt stabs , both on the same phase.When I found the first burnt breaker I couldn’t get any response from Siemens concerning this issue.Now the home owner is concerned about the overall safety of his electrical system.I am wondering if anyone has experienced this issue in the past ?Murray is supposed to be compatible with Siemens according to Siemens.I hope this doesn’t become a Zinsco problem, but it will probably be ok since the AFCIs trip before they can weld on .If anyone has experienced this or more importantly found a cause, I would like to know. I am hoping the new Siemens breakers do the jobI’m pretty sure since the arcing was happening on the bus all the breakers were reading the noise on the line that is why such random tripping.If I can figure out how to get pictures uploaded , I will
This is a frustrating and potentially dangerous situation. You've done a thorough job so far, and your intuition about the arcing on the bus bar causing the issues sounds plausible. Let's break down the possible causes and solutions
Possible Causes of Bus Bar Arcing & Subsequent AFCI Trips:
1. Loose Connections/Poor Contact
This is the most likely culprit. Even a slight imperfection in the connection between the breaker and the bus bar creates resistance. This resistance generates heat, which can cause:
Oxidation
The metal surfaces oxidize, increasing resistance further.
Arcing
The heat can cause arcing between the breaker lug and the bus bar, particularly when under load. Arcing generates significant RF noise, which can trigger AFCI breakers.
Burning/Discoloration
Visible evidence of heat damage.2.
Overloading
If the circuit is consistently close to its rated capacity, it can exacerbate a pre-existing loose connection. While AFCI breakers should trip due to overload, the heat generated before tripping can still contribute to the arcing.3.
Aluminum Wiring (If Applicable)
If the home has aluminum wiring (and copper pigtails are used to connect to devices), corrosion can occur at the aluminum-to-copper junction, leading to increased resistance and potential arcing upstream. (Less likely if you're just seeing issues at the bus bar.)4.
Panel Manufacturing Defect
Less likely, but possible. A defect in the panel's bus bar itself (e.g., improper plating, inconsistent thickness) could contribute to poor contact.5.
Improper Breaker Installation
Were the Murray breakers always properly seated and tightened? A sloppy installation, even with seemingly compatible breakers, could cause issues.6.
Harmonic Distortion
Though less likely to cause arcing at the bus bar directly, excessive harmonic distortion in the electrical system can sometimes cause nuisance tripping of AFCI breakers. The gas range could be a contributor to this. However, I feel that this is not the main problem.7.
Environmental Factors
Excessive humidity or corrosive atmospheres can accelerate oxidation at the bus bar connection.
Troubleshooting and Solutions
Thorough Inspection of the Bus Bar
Power OFF! This goes without saying, but ensure the main breaker is OFF and the panel is de-energized before proceeding. Visual Inspection
Look for any signs of corrosion, pitting, burning, or discoloration on the bus bars. Pay particular attention to the stabs where the breakers connect.
Mechanical Check
With the power OFF, gently attempt to wiggle the bus bars. Are they securely attached to the panel?
Cleaning
Use a non-conductive abrasive pad (like the ceramic pad you used before) to thoroughly clean the bus bar stabs, removing any oxidation or residue. Be careful not to remove the plating excessively.
Bus Bar Inspection (Backside)
If possible, carefully inspect the backside of the bus bar for any signs of damage or overheating. This might require temporarily removing the panel's interior, which should only be done by a qualified electrician.2.
Breaker Installation Best Practices
Proper Seating
Ensure the breakers are fully and securely seated onto the bus bar stabs.
Firm Pressure
Apply firm, even pressure when pushing the breaker into place.
Correct Breaker Type
Verify the Siemens AFCI breakers you're using are specifically designed for Siemens panels. There may be minor variations that can affect contact.
Torque Screws
If the breakers have set screws for the wire connections, torque them to the manufacturer's specifications.3.
Load Testing and Circuit Analysis
Load Testing
Use a clamp meter to measure the current draw on the affected circuits under typical load conditions. Are they close to the breaker's rating? If so, consider splitting the circuit or upgrading the breaker and wiring (if the wiring gauge allows).
Identify Shared Neutrals
Are any circuits sharing a neutral? This can cause overloaded neutrals and potentially nuisance tripping.4.
Address Potential Sources of RF Noise
Further Investigate Appliances
Even with the snubbers, monitor the gas range and its vent hood for potential RF emissions. Try turning off the circuit breakers for these appliances to see if the problem stops.
Consider Line Conditioners
If RF noise continues to be a suspect, consider installing a line conditioner at the main panel to filter out noise.5.
Panel Replacement
Serious Damage
If the bus bar is severely damaged (e.g., extensive burning, pitting, or mechanical looseness), replacing the entire panel is the safest and most reliable solution. This is especially true if the panel is old or showing other signs of wear.
Professional Evaluation
Consult with a licensed electrical engineer or master electrician to evaluate the panel's condition and determine if replacement is necessary.6.
Contact Siemens (Again)
Escalate the Issue
Emphasize the severity of the problem (arcing, potential fire hazard) and request a higher level of technical support. Document everything – dates, times, who you spoke with, and the information they provided. The burn marks on the stabs are not good.7.
Homeowner Education
Explain the Risks
Clearly explain to the homeowner the potential dangers of arcing and the importance of addressing the issue promptly.
Appliance Usage
Discuss appliance usage patterns to identify potential overloading situations.
Important Considerations
Safety First
Electrical work is dangerous. If you are not completely comfortable with any of these procedures, hire a qualified electrician.
Documentation
Keep meticulous records of everything you do – inspections, tests, measurements, repairs.
Code Compliance
Ensure all work complies with local electrical codes.
Insurance
Notify the homeowner to inform their insurance company. They may have specific requirements or recommendations.
Regarding Murray Breakers:
While Siemens states Murray breakers are compatible, some electricians prefer to stick with the same brand for both panel and breakers to ensure optimal fit and performance. The initial issue with the Murray breaker having heat discoloration suggests there may* be a compatibility issue, even if slight.Good luck! This is a tough problem, but with a systematic approach, you should be able to get to the bottom of it. Flag for review