User: Dylankjsutice, Location: Tulsa, OK
Asked on: Monday, September 30, 2024 at 8:38 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:09 am EST
Question: I am working on a project where the customer wants to add generator backup power to an existing building that currently has 31 apartments. Additionally, they are planning an expansion that will include 10 more apartments. The existing 31 apartments are fed from two separate meter banks. Meter Bank 1 has 15 meters, while Meter Bank 2 has 16 meters, and both are equipped with a 1200A main breaker.The new addition will have two more meter banks (referred to as Meter Banks 3 and 4), each with 5 meters. Based on load calculations, each of these new meter banks will require a main breaker rated at 400A.The utility company, however, will not allow an ATS (Automatic Transfer Switch) to be installed between their transformer and the four meter banks. Instead, they will be installing a single meter to serve all 41 apartments.The challenge I am facing is determining how to connect all four meter banks to a single service-rated ATS. The primary issue is that the ATS manufacturer does not recommend using the eight conductors per phase needed to feed all four meter banks due to "space" limitations inside the ATS enclosure.I considered the option of tapping the conductors for the existing and new meter banks, but this is not possible since tap conductors are not allowed for overcurrent devices rated 800A or less. Below is a breakdown of the feeds I have identified for this setup.Primary Line Side:Utility to ATS – (4) Parallel Sets – (2) 500 MCM AL (1) 350 MCM AL N (1) 250 MCM GSecondary Line Side:Gen to ATS – (4) Parallel Sets - (2) 250 MCM AL (1) 3/0 N, (1) 3/0 GLoad Side:From ATS to Meter Bank 1 - (2) Parallel Sets – (2) 250 MCM AL (1) 3/0 N, (1) #1 AL GFrom ATS to Meter Bank 2 - (2) Parallel Sets – (2) 250 MCM AL (1) 3/0 N, (1) #1 AL GFrom ATS to Meter Bank 3 - (2) Parallel Sets – (2) 500 MCM AL, (1) 250 MCM AL N, (1) 2/0 GFrom ATS to Meter Bank 4 - (2) Parallel Sets – (2) 500 MCM AL, (1) 250 MCM AL N, (1) 2/0 G-----------------------------------------------------------Line Side: (4) 500 MCM AL – *Per LegLoad Side: (4) 250 MCM AL, (4) 500 MCM AL – *Per LegNeutral will have: (4) 350 MCM AL, (9) 250 MCM AL, (8) 3/0 AL, (4) 2/0, (4) #1 (includes bonded grounds)------------------------------------------------------------
Okay, this is a tricky situation with several constraints. Let's break down the problem and explore possible solutions, focusing on code compliance, practical feasibility, and the ATS manufacturer's recommendations.
Understanding the Constraints
Utility Requirement
No ATS between their transformer and the meter banks, forcing a single meter for all 41 apartments.
ATS Limitation
The ATS manufacturer prohibits multiple conductors per phase due to space limitations within the enclosure. This is the core challenge.
Tap Conductor Restriction
You correctly identified the NEC limitation prohibiting tap conductors from overcurrent devices rated 800A or less [NEC 240.21(B)].
Load Calculations
You haven't explicitly stated the total calculated load, but the conductor sizes indicate a significant load requiring a large ATS and service size.
Challenges and Concerns
Multiple Conductors Per Phase
The fundamental problem is getting the required current from the ATS to the four meter banks while avoiding parallel conductors on the load side of the ATS for each leg.2.
Neutral and Grounding Considerations
As your analysis shows, the neutral and grounding conductor requirements add to the crowding inside the ATS enclosure. You also need to consider the feeder and grounding electrode conductor sizes to adhere to code.
Possible Solutions (and their drawbacks)
Larger ATS with a Single Set of Conductors per Load
Concept
Find an ATS large enough to accommodate the total calculated load with single sets of conductors going to each meter bank. Instead of multiple parallel runs to each meter bank, you would run a single, much larger conductor to each.
Pros
Complies with the ATS manufacturer's recommendations and eliminates parallel conductors on the load side within the ATS enclosure.
Cons
This will likely be very expensive. Finding an ATS rated for that much current with the number of poles required might be difficult. The larger conductors can be unwieldy and challenging to work with. The enclosure size will be enormous.
Code Compliance
Verify conductor ampacity based on calculated load and temperature ratings. Ensure adequate working space around the ATS.2.
Using an approved junction box/trough before the Meter Bank (but after ATS)
Concept
You run a larger conduit with parallel conductors from the ATS to a listed and labeled junction box/wiring trough located near the meter banks. Inside the trough you will split up into the required conductor sets to feed each meter bank.
Pros
Keeps the ATS wiring simpler, and is likely the most cost effective option.
Cons
Must follow NEC 314 to properly size the box and comply with conductor fill.
Code Compliance
You must ensure proper conductor fill and bending radius within the junction box/wiring trough [NEC 314.16, 314.28]. All terminations must be properly made with approved connectors.
3.
Series-Rated Overcurrent Protective Devices
(Highly unlikely to be acceptable)
Concept
If each meter bank had a main breaker rated for a lower current, you might be able to tap into the main feeder. This would involve careful coordination between the ATS main breaker and the individual meter bank breakers.
Pros
Potentially could reduce the size of conductors needed from the ATS.
Cons
Extremely complex coordination study required. Utility approval is highly unlikely. Very restrictive on future changes. The savings in conductor size would likely be outweighed by the engineering and equipment costs. The tap rules still might come into play depending on the details.
Code Compliance
NEC Article 240 (Overcurrent Protection) - series rating is typically not allowed for this type of application.
Recommended Approach and Next Steps
Confirm Accurate Load Calculations
Double-check the demand factors applied and ensure that all loads are accounted for, including potential future loads. This is critical for determining the correct ATS size and conductor ampacities.2.
Consult the ATS Manufacturer
Provide the exact load calculations and configuration to the ATS manufacturer. Emphasize the constraints and ask for their specific recommendations. They might have solutions or specific models that better suit the situation. Get their written approval for any proposed configuration that involves multiple conductors on the load side (even if it's feeding a junction box).3.
Explore Option 2 (Junction Box/Wiring Trough)
This is the most likely path to success. Work with the ATS manufacturer and your electrical contractor to design a system with a adequately sized junction box located close to the meter banks that meet the requirements of the ATS and NEC 314.4.
Document Everything
Thoroughly document all calculations, conductor sizing, equipment specifications, and communications with the ATS manufacturer and the local inspection authority (AHJ). This is crucial for a smooth inspection process.
Additional Considerations
Accessibility
Ensure that the ATS and junction box are readily accessible for maintenance and inspection.
Space
Carefully evaluate the available space for the ATS, junction box, and associated conduit runs.*
Cost
Compare the costs of each solution, considering equipment, labor, and potential future modifications.
Important Note: I am an AI and cannot provide code-compliant electrical design services. This information is for general guidance only. A qualified electrical engineer must perform all calculations, design the system, and obtain necessary approvals from the AHJ. Flag for review