User: jimbo172005, Location: Reno, Nevada
Asked on: Monday, September 30, 2024 at 12:15 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:10 am EST
Question: 1st Floor 400 amp rated panel feeding into the 2nd floor 400 amp panel is this right? Or do i need to upsize my 1st floor panel to 800,also the Circuit breaker on 1st floor panel is not rated for two wires…..in each phase terminal lug.
Okay, let's break down the scenario and address the issues you've raised.
Understanding the Basic Problem
You have a 400 amp panel on the 1st floor feeding a 400 amp panel on the 2nd floor. You're concerned if the 1st floor panel needs to be larger (800 amps) and you've also discovered the breakers in the 1st floor panel are not rated for double-lugging (two wires in one terminal).
Analysis and Solutions1. Panel Size - 400A vs. 800A on the 1st Floor
The Fundamental Question: What is the actual load on each panel? This is the most critical factor. You cannot determine if you need to upsize based solely on the fact that you're feeding another panel. You need to perform a load calculation for both the 1st and 2nd floor panels. Load Calculation
This involves calculating the total anticipated power draw of all the circuits connected to each panel. This includes:
Lighting
Wattage of all lights (consider LED fixtures, which use less power).
Receptacles (Outlets)
For general use receptacles, a standard assumption (e.g., 180 VA per receptacle in residential) is often used. For specific receptacles dedicated to appliances, use the appliance's nameplate rating.
Appliances
Ovens, stoves, refrigerators, dishwashers, washing machines, dryers, HVAC systems (heating, ventilation, and air conditioning), water heaters, etc. Use the nameplate ratings.
Motors
Motors have inrush currents that need to be factored in.
Any other significant loads
Electric vehicle chargers, welders, etc.
Demand Factors
Code (like the National Electrical Code in the US) allows for the use of demand factors in some situations. Demand factors recognize that not everything in a building runs at its maximum load simultaneously. For example, you don't likely have every light on, every appliance running, and the HVAC system at full blast all at the same time. The load calculation method in the NEC (or your local code) will guide you on applying appropriate demand factors.
After the load calculation
1st Floor Panel
The load calculation for the 1st floor must include the entire calculated load of the 2nd floor panel plus any additional loads connected directly to the 1st floor panel. If this total calculated load is greater than 400 amps, then you do need to upsize the 1st floor panel (and likely the service entrance conductors, meter, etc.).
2nd Floor Panel
The load calculation for the 2nd floor tells you if that panel is adequately sized for the loads it serves. If the calculated load is greater than 400 amps, you need to consider upsizing the 2nd floor panel as well.
Example (Simplified)
Let's say the 2nd floor load calculation comes out to 300 amps. The 1st floor has an additional 100 amps of its own loads. The total load that the 1st floor panel has to supply is 300A + 100A = 400A. In this case, the 400 amp 1st floor panel might be sufficient, but you'd want to factor in some safety margin and future growth.2.
Double-Lugging (Two Wires in One Terminal)
This is a code violation and a safety hazard. Breaker terminals are specifically designed and tested for a certain number of conductors and a certain size of conductor. Putting two wires in a terminal that's only rated for one can lead to: Loose connections
The wires might not be properly secured, leading to arcing, overheating, and potential fires.
Reduced ampacity
The terminal may not be able to handle the combined current of two wires of that size.
Damage to the breaker
Overheating can damage the breaker's internal components.
Voiding of the breaker's UL listing
Makes the insurance company liable.
Solutions for Double-Lugging
Pigtailing
The most common and generally accepted solution.1. Take the two wires that are currently double-lugged.
2. Add a third, appropriately sized wire (a "pigtail").3. Use a properly sized wire connector (wire nut or similar) to connect all three wires together.
4. Connect the single pigtail wire to the breaker terminal.
Replacing the Breaker
In some cases, you can find a breaker that is specifically listed and labeled for two conductors. This is less common for standard branch circuit breakers but might be available. Check the breaker manufacturer's specifications.
Adding a Junction Box
If you have enough space, you can install a junction box near the panel. Run the two wires into the junction box, connect them to a terminal block, and then run a single wire from the terminal block to the breaker.
Adding a subpanel
this would entail running a larger feed from the main panel to a subpanel with the appropriate number of breakers.3.
Other Considerations
Service Entrance
If you do need to upsize the 1st floor panel to 800 amps, you absolutely must ensure that your service entrance (the wires coming from the utility company) is also rated for 800 amps. This might involve upgrading the service entrance conductors, the meter, and the service disconnect. This is a job for a qualified electrician and requires coordination with your utility company.
Conduit Size
If you're running new conductors between the panels (especially if upsizing), make sure the conduit (if used) is sized appropriately for the number and size of the conductors.
Overcurrent Protection
Make sure all breakers and fuses are sized correctly to protect the conductors they feed.
Grounding and Bonding
Ensure that the grounding and bonding system is properly installed and up to code.
Steps to Take
Hire a Qualified Electrician
This is not a DIY project. Electrical work is dangerous and must be done to code. A licensed electrician has the training, experience, and tools to perform the load calculations accurately, identify code violations, and make the necessary repairs or upgrades safely.2.
Perform Load Calculations
The electrician will conduct thorough load calculations for both panels.3.
Correct Double-Lugging
The electrician will immediately address the double-lugging issue using one of the acceptable methods described above.4.
Determine Panel Size
Based on the load calculations, the electrician will determine if the 1st floor panel needs to be upsized.5.
Inspect Service Entrance
If upsizing is required, the electrician will inspect the service entrance to ensure it can handle the increased load.6.
Obtain Permits and Inspections
Electrical work typically requires permits and inspections from your local building department. The electrician will handle this process.
In summary: Double-lugging is a serious problem that must be corrected immediately. Whether you need to upsize the 1st floor panel depends entirely on the load calculations. Do not attempt this work yourself; hire a qualified and licensed electrician. Flag for review