User: Sparro, Location: Colorado
Asked on: Monday, September 30, 2024 at 4:38 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:12 am EST
Question: I do mostly service work and have found the need to put a switch and outlet for a garbage disposal in some very challenging locations. It got me thinking about Pico switches and how handy it would be to have the ability to put a switch powering the disposal somewhere convenient and then placing the pico above the disposal when other solutions like an air switch won't work. I know pico switches aren't motor rated but does anyone have something similar they've used successfully?
You've identified a common challenge and a smart potential solution! Using a Pico-style wireless switch for a garbage disposal is tempting for its flexibility. However, you're right to be concerned about motor ratings. Here's a breakdown of considerations and some alternative approaches
Why Pico Switches (and Similar) Aren't Ideal Directly:
Motor Load
Garbage disposals are inductive loads. When they start, they draw a surge of current (inrush current) significantly higher than their running current. Standard switches, especially those designed for lighting, are often not built to handle this inrush. Repeated inrush current can damage the switch contacts, leading to failure or even fire hazards.
Amperage Ratings
Even if the running current is below the switch's stated amperage, the inrush can far exceed it.
Solutions & Approaches (with varying levels of complexity)
Pico (or Similar) as a Remote Control for a Contactor
The Best (Safest & Most Reliable) Approach
This is the recommended solution, even though it's slightly more involved.
How it Works
You install a motor-rated contactor (a heavy-duty relay) in a readily accessible location. This contactor is rated for the horsepower and voltage of your garbage disposal. You wire the Pico switch to the coil of the contactor. The coil draws very little current, so the Pico switch is within its safe operating range. The contactor's heavy-duty contacts switch the power to the garbage disposal.
Benefits
Complete isolation of the Pico switch from the motor load. Increased safety and reliability. Extends the life of the disposal.
Wiring
Pico
Line voltage to Pico, Pico output wired to the coil input of the contactor. Neutral wired to the coil of the contactor.
Contactor
Line voltage wired through the contactor's normally open (NO) contacts. Contactor output to disposal.2.
Wireless Smart Plug with a Motor Rating
Finding One is the Key
You'd need to carefully research and verify that the smart plug is specifically rated for motor loads.
Check Specifications
Horsepower (HP) Rating
The smart plug must have an HP rating equal to or greater than your disposal's HP.
Locked Rotor Amperage (LRA)
This is the inrush current. The plug's specs should list the maximum LRA it can handle.
UL or ETL Listing
Look for safety certifications.
Caveats
Smart plugs can be less reliable than wired solutions.
Example (Potential)
Leviton makes some smart outlets and plugs with higher amperage ratings. Search for one that also specifies motor load capabilities.
Installation
Plug the disposal into the smart plug, and then plug the smart plug into the existing outlet (or have one installed).3.
In-Line Motor Starter with a Remote Switch
Similar to the contactor approach, but using a pre-packaged motor starter unit. These often include overload protection. You'd still use a Pico-like switch to trigger the starter coil.4.
Air Switch (If Possible)
You mentioned this wasn't always feasible, but if the situation allows, an air switch is still the simplest and safest method.
Important Considerations
Local Electrical Codes
All work must be done in compliance with your local electrical codes. If you're not comfortable with this type of wiring, hire a qualified electrician.
Horsepower Rating
The key is the horsepower (HP) rating of the disposal motor. This is usually listed on the disposal's nameplate. Match the components (contactor, smart plug, etc.) to the HP rating.
Overload Protection
Consider adding overload protection (e.g., a thermal overload relay) to protect the disposal motor from damage if it gets jammed. Some motor starters include this.
Testing
After installation, thoroughly test the setup to ensure it works correctly and safely.
Example Product Searches (to give you ideas, not endorsements - verify compatibility and ratings before purchasing)
"Motor rated contactor" "Garbage disposal air switch kit" "Motor starter" "Smart plug motor rated" "Wireless remote control switch with relay"
Recommendation
For the safest, most reliable, and code-compliant solution, the
contactor approach is the best bet. While it requires a bit more wiring, it isolates the Pico switch from the heavy motor load, ensuring long-term reliability and preventing potential electrical hazards.Remember to consult with a qualified electrician for any electrical work you're unsure about. They can assess the specific situation and recommend the best solution for your needs. Flag for review