User: hhsting, Location: Glen bunie, md, us
Asked on: Tuesday, October 1, 2024 at 2:30 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:14 am EST
Question: See attached sketch. I. have onsite generator which feeds fire pump. However the conductor from generator to enclosed circuit breaker 200A have no overcurrent protection and they run several hundred feet. When they enter the building a 200A enclosed circuit breaker is provided.Should not the conductors require overcurrent protection?
Yes, your concern is valid. The conductors from the generator to the 200A breaker inside the building definitely need overcurrent protection. Here's a breakdown of why and what needs to be considered
Why Overcurrent Protection is Required
Protection of the Conductors
The primary reason for overcurrent protection is to protect the conductors themselves. Overcurrent (short circuit or overload) can cause conductors to overheat, melt insulation, and potentially cause a fire. The conductors must be protected at their ampacity.
NEC Requirements
The National Electrical Code (NEC) is very clear on conductor protection. Specifically, NEC 240.21(C) addresses feeder taps and allows for certain exceptions where overcurrent protection can be omitted at the source of the conductors. However, these exceptions are very specific and generally require the conductors to be relatively short, mechanically protected, and properly sized with respect to the downstream overcurrent device.
Long Runs and Potential Damage
A long run of unprotected conductors like you describe is problematic. A fault along any point of those hundreds of feet of unprotected wire could cause a significant amount of damage before the 200A breaker inside the building trips (assuming it eventually does). Think about mechanical damage (digging, vehicles), insulation breakdown, or accidental short circuits.
Why the 200A Breaker Inside the Building Doesn't Provide Adequate Protection (Typically)
While the 200A breaker will eventually trip on a significant overcurrent event, it won't protect the conductors adequately from smaller overloads that could damage the insulation over time. The conductors might be rated for, say, 150A, and a sustained 175A load could overheat them long before the 200A breaker trips.
What Needs to Be Done1. Overcurrent Protection at the Generator
The most straightforward solution is to install an overcurrent device (circuit breaker or fuses)
at the generator output, sized no larger than the ampacity of the conductors. This will provide immediate protection at the source.2. Feeder Tap Rules (Review Carefully)
Check NEC 240.21(C) very carefully. A common rule is that the tap conductors must have an ampacity that is not less than 1/3 of the overcurrent device protecting the feeder conductors.
3.
Conductor Sizing
Verify that the conductors are sized appropriately for the fire pump motor and the generator output.4.
Coordination Study
A coordination study should be performed to ensure that the overcurrent protective devices in the system are properly coordinated to minimize outages and maximize safety.
Specific Considerations for Fire Pumps NEC 695
Fire pump circuits have special requirements in NEC Article 695. This article allows for some exceptions regarding overcurrent protection, but these exceptions are very specific and are intended to ensure the fire pump runs in emergency situations. They are not a blanket exemption from all overcurrent protection.
Selective Coordination
Fire pump circuits are required to be selectively coordinated to ensure that a fault on the load side of the pump breaker does not trip the upstream breakers.
Supervisory Signals
Fire pump installations often require supervisory signals to indicate the status of the system.
Recommendation
You should consult with a qualified electrical engineer or a licensed electrician familiar with fire pump installations and NEC requirements. They can properly evaluate your situation, perform the necessary calculations, and design a system that is both safe and compliant. Do not proceed without professional advice.
In summary, the long run of unprotected conductors is a code violation and a safety hazard. It needs to be corrected by adding overcurrent protection at the generator or confirming the installation meets the strict requirements for an exception under the NEC's tap rules. Flag for review