User: J.Daniel, Location: Qwerty-1
Asked on: Tuesday, October 1, 2024 at 3:56 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:15 am EST
Question: Hey I a have question about have to ground a service panel in a duplex house at a same spot meter. One the meter main combo panel is existing with to 200 amp and the another one is 100 amp and owner wants me to upgrade the 100 amp panel to 200 amp panel. Can I use the same grounding electric conductor for both of them based on 250.58 and ground the grounded conductor in each service panel.
Okay, let's break down the grounding requirements for your duplex service upgrade. It's a critical safety issue, so we need to be precise.
Understanding the Situation Duplex with a Shared Meter
You have a duplex dwelling served by a single meter. The power company feeds the meter, and from there, the service is split to feed each unit.
Existing Meter Main Combo Panel
You mention a meter main combo panel with two breakers (200A and 100A). This panel likely contains the meter socket and disconnects for each unit.
Upgrade
You're upgrading the 100A panel to a 200A panel within one of the duplex units.
Grounding Requirements - Key Concepts Service Grounding Electrode System (GEC)
This is the connection to the earth (ground rods, water pipe, etc.). Its purpose is to provide a path for fault current to return to the source, tripping the breaker and preventing dangerous voltage on metallic parts.
Grounded Conductor (Neutral)
This is the conductor that is intentionally grounded at the service. It provides a return path for normal load current and acts as a low-impedance path for fault current.
Equipment Grounding Conductor (EGC)
These are the wires or metallic raceways that connect the non-current-carrying metal parts of electrical equipment (enclosures, appliances, etc.) back to the service grounding system.
Answering Your Question: Can You Share the Grounding Electrode Conductor (GEC)? Yes, with Conditions (Based on NEC 250.58)
NEC 250.58 allows you to use a common grounding electrode conductor (GEC) for multiple services supplied by the same service drop or lateral. This is exactly your situation with a duplex sharing a meter.
Important Considerations for 250.58
GEC Sizing
The single common GEC must be sized based on the total combined ampacity of all the service disconnects (in your case, 200A + 200A = 400A). Use NEC Table 250.66 to determine the correct GEC size for 400A service. This is very important. It will likely require a larger GEC than what was previously used for the 100A service.
Continuity
The GEC must be continuous from the grounding electrode(s) to the point where it's connected to the grounded (neutral) conductors in both service disconnects. Avoid splices in the GEC if possible; if splices are unavoidable, they must be made with irreversible compression connectors listed for grounding.
Accessibility
The grounding electrode system (ground rods, water pipe connection, etc.) must remain accessible for inspection and maintenance.
Grounding the Grounded Conductor (Neutral) in Each Service Panel (250.24) Yes, this is REQUIRED
You must bond the grounded (neutral) conductor to the service enclosure (the metal panel box) at each service disconnect (200A panels). This is typically done using a main bonding jumper (MBJ), which is a screw or strap that connects the neutral bus to the metal enclosure. This is the point where the neutral becomes grounded.
Single Point Ground
Each service panel must be grounded only at this first point of disconnect.
No Neutral-Ground Bonds Downstream
Do NOT create any additional neutral-to-ground bonds in subpanels or branch circuits within each unit. These create parallel paths for neutral current, which can cause electrical noise and safety hazards.
Grounding Electrode System (250.50) You must have an effective grounding electrode system. This typically includes: Metal Water Pipe (if properly bonded)
If you have a metallic water pipe that is in direct contact with the earth for at least 10 feet, it must be used as part of the grounding electrode system. It must be supplemented by another electrode (see below).
Ground Rods (Minimum of Two)
If you don't have a suitable metal water pipe, you must install at least two ground rods, spaced at least 6 feet apart. The GEC must be connected to both ground rods.
Concrete-Encased Electrode (Ufer Ground)
If present, this must be used.
Other Electrodes
Other types of electrodes are permitted by the NEC (e.g., ground ring).
Practical Steps for Your Upgrade1. Inspect the Existing Grounding System
Carefully examine the existing grounding electrode system (ground rods, water pipe connection, etc.). Is it adequate? Is it in good condition? Is it accessible?2.
Calculate GEC Size
Calculate the total ampacity of your combined services (200A + 200A = 400A) and use NEC Table 250.66 to determine the required size of the common GEC. You will likely need to upsize the existing GEC.
3.
Run the New GEC (if needed)
Run the new, properly sized GEC from the grounding electrode(s) to the meter main combo panel.4.
Connect the GEC to the Neutral in Each Service Disconnect
Terminate the GEC at the neutral bus in both 200A service disconnects.5.
Install Main Bonding Jumpers
Ensure that each service disconnect has a main bonding jumper (MBJ) connecting the neutral bus to the metal enclosure.6.
Upgrade Service Entrance Conductors (if necessary)
Ensure your service entrance conductors (from the meter to each panel) are appropriately sized for the load. The 100 amp service would need to be replaced.7.
Install the New 200A Panel
Install the new 200A panel, connecting the feeders from the meter main combo panel.8.
Verify Neutral-Ground Isolation Downstream
Ensure there are NO neutral-to-ground bonds in any subpanels or branch circuits within either unit of the duplex. This is crucial.9.
Inspection
Call for an electrical inspection to ensure your work complies with the NEC and local codes.
Important Cautions and Considerations Local Codes
Always check with your local electrical inspector for specific requirements and interpretations of the NEC. Local codes can be stricter.
Aluminum vs. Copper
Be mindful of using the correct connectors when transitioning between aluminum and copper conductors to prevent corrosion.
Professional Help
If you are not completely comfortable with electrical work, especially service upgrades, hire a qualified and licensed electrician. Incorrect grounding can be extremely dangerous.
Load Calculation
Perform a proper load calculation for each unit to ensure that the 200A service is adequate for the anticipated loads.
Coordination with the Utility
Contact your local utility company. They may have specific requirements for service upgrades and may need to disconnect and reconnect power during the work.
Photo Documentation
Take photos of the existing setup before you begin work. This can be helpful if you encounter any issues or need to explain the existing conditions to an inspector.
In summary, you can share the GEC, but you must* size it correctly based on the combined service ratings, ensure it's continuous, and properly bond the neutral in each service disconnect. Safety first! Flag for review