Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Motor calculation

User: brianthejabroni2, Location: NE (9.06 miles @5.9 Degrees from Winged Horses)

Asked on: Tuesday, October 1, 2024 at 7:27 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:16 am EST

Question: What size over current protection do I need ? I’m terrible at motor calculations … would I be ok feeding vfd with 800a ?

Okay, let's break down why directly feeding a VFD with an 800A overcurrent device might be a terrible idea (but isn't always). I need more information to give a definitive answer. However, I can explain the principles and help you figure out the correct size.

Understanding the Issue VFDs and Overcurrent Protection

VFDs (Variable Frequency Drives) are used to control the speed of motors. They are electronic devices that can be damaged by excessive current. They also have specific protection requirements.


Motor Overcurrent Protection

Motors draw significantly higher current during starting (inrush current) than during normal operation. Overcurrent protection (circuit breakers or fuses) must be sized to allow the motor to start without tripping but also to protect against sustained overloads and short circuits.

VFD Input Current

The current feeding the VFD is related to the motor's horsepower (HP) and voltage,
but also to the efficiency of the VFD and the load on the motor.

Why 800A Could Be Wrong (Likely)


An 800A overcurrent device is VERY large. It's likely far too large for the typical motor controlled by a VFD. If you used an 800A breaker on a VFD that was controlling, say, a 50 HP motor, the breaker might not trip even if the motor was severely overloaded or had a fault. This could lead to:
Damage to the VFD

The VFD's internal components could be damaged by excessive current before the 800A breaker trips.

Motor Damage

The motor itself could be damaged if it's overloaded for a prolonged period.


Fire Hazard

Overheating conductors or components could create a fire risk.

Information Needed for Proper Sizing


To calculate the correct overcurrent protection, I need the following information:1. VFD Specifications



Manufacturer and Model Number

This is CRUCIAL. The VFD's datasheet will specify the required input current, maximum overcurrent protection size, and recommended fuse/breaker type.


Input Voltage

(e.g., 240V, 480V, 600V, etc.)

Output Horsepower (HP) Rating

This is the maximum motor size the VFD is designed to control.


Input Amperage (FLA)

this is the input amperage of the vfd when controlling the max horsepower motor it is rated for.2.

Motor Specifications



Horsepower (HP)



Voltage



Full-Load Amps (FLA)

This is the current the motor draws under normal full-load conditions, as listed on the motor's nameplate.


Service Factor (SF)

This is also on the motor nameplate.3.

Wiring Information



Wire Gauge and Type

(e.g., #6 AWG THHN)


Conduit Type and Installation Method

(e.g., in conduit, open air)

Ambient Temperature

The surrounding temperature affects wire ampacity.

General Steps for Sizing Overcurrent Protection (Without Specific VFD Data)
NEC (National Electrical Code)

The NEC provides guidelines for motor circuit protection. You must follow the NEC for safe and code-compliant installations.

VFD Manufacturer's Instructions First

Always follow the VFD manufacturer's recommendations first. They may be more restrictive than the NEC.

Calculate Motor FLA

If you don't have the motor's FLA from the nameplate, you can look it up in NEC tables (Table 430.248 for single-phase motors, Table 430.250 for three-phase motors).

Size Conductors

The conductors feeding the VFD must be sized to carry at least 125% of the VFD's
input current rating (or the motor FLA, whichever is greater as determined by the VFD manufacturer). See NEC Article 430 and 310.

Overcurrent Protection (General Guidelines)



Inverse Time Circuit Breaker

Typically sized between 150% and 250% of the VFD's input current rating.


Fuses

Can be sized higher than circuit breakers (e.g., up to 300% for some fuse types). Again, follow the VFD manufacturer's recommendations.

Short-Circuit Protection

VFDs also require short-circuit protection, typically provided by fuses or a high-interrupting-capacity circuit breaker. The VFD manual will specify the required interrupting rating.

Example (Illustrative - DO NOT USE WITHOUT VERIFYING!)


Let's say you have:
A VFD rated for 480V, 50 HP motors. The VFD datasheet specifies a maximum input current of 65 Amps at full load. The VFD manufacturer recommends using a time-delay fuse sized at 175% of the VFD's input current.Calculation: 175% of 65 Amps = 1.75 65 = 113.75 AmpsIn this hypothetical case, you would likely use a 125 Amp time-delay fuse (the next standard size up). You would also need to ensure the conductors feeding the VFD are sized for at least 125% of the VFD's input current (65A 1.25 = 81.25A), which would likely require at least #4 AWG copper conductors (check ampacity tables in the NEC).

Important Considerations



Harmonic Distortion

VFDs generate harmonic distortion, which can affect the power quality in your electrical system. Consider using line reactors or harmonic filters if necessary.

Grounding

Proper grounding is critical for VFD installations to prevent noise and ensure safety.


Qualified Electrician

VFD installations should always be performed by a qualified electrician who is familiar with VFDs and the NEC.

Documentation

Keep all VFD manuals, wiring diagrams, and calculations readily available.

Next Steps


Gather all the information
I requested above (VFD and motor specifications).2. Consult the VFD manual. This is the most important* step. The manual will provide specific instructions for overcurrent protection.3. Consult the NEC. Ensure your installation complies with the NEC.4. Contact a qualified electrician. Have a qualified electrician review your calculations and perform the installation.

Do not proceed with an 800A breaker until you have confirmed it is appropriate based on the VFD and motor specifications. It is highly unlikely to be the correct size. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question