User: dm9289, Location: Pennsylvania
Asked on: Tuesday, October 1, 2024 at 9:02 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:16 am EST
Question: Could you have a 15kv transformer fed by 2 legs of a 480v wye to a 120/240 single phase secondaryoutput with no secondary protection (200 amp main in panel).Oh sorry primary would have 40amp fusing.I believe from 450 chart for transformer you can do primary only protection.I also believe the main for that panel fed from secondary is necessary and about 85 amp breaker.Is that breaker required in the panel and if so I assume a 200 amp would not be code compliant. I could not find the rule
Okay, let's break down this scenario with the 15kVA transformer, 480V primary, 120/240V secondary, and the panel considerations.
Transformer Setup and Protection 15kVA Transformer, 480V Primary (2 Legs), 120/240V Secondary
This is an unusual but possible configuration. Feeding a single-phase transformer from two legs of a 480V wye system is acceptable.
Primary Overcurrent Protection (40A Fuses)
You are on the right track with 450.3, however this rule has limits.
Calculating Primary Current
15kVA / 0.48kV = 31.25 Amps
450.3(B) Primary Only Protection
Yes, 450.3(B) generally allows primary-only protection.
450.3(B) (1)
"For transformers over 600 volts, the primary overcurrent protection shall be in accordance with Table 450.3(A)."
450.3(B) (2)
"For transformers 600 volts or less, the primary overcurrent protection shall be in accordance with Table 450.3(B)."
Primary Overcurrent Protection Required
Assuming Table 450.3(B) is the appropriate section, the breaker or fuse must be no more than 125% of the transformer rated current. So 31.25 1.25 = 39.06, so 40 amp fusing is compliant.
Secondary Overcurrent Protection
Your initial question assumed no secondary protection but if you are installing a secondary main, that is acceptable if compliant with 450.3.
Secondary Panel and Main Breaker Secondary Current Calculation
15kVA / 0.24kV = 62.5 Amps.
Secondary Overcurrent Protection (Main Breaker in Panel)
Now this is where things get tricky.
Panel Rating vs. Calculated Load
The code requires the panel to be rated high enough to handle the calculated load. A 200A panel is more than capable of handling the 62.5A calculated load from the transformer, and that is fine.
Main Breaker Size
Here's where the requirement you were looking for comes into play. If you use the 125% rule from 450.3, then 62.5 1.25 = 78.125 amps, so you can use up to an 80 amp breaker. If this is the only over current device, you need to follow this limit.
240.5(B)(2)(a)
There is an important exception for this type of transformer in 240.5(B)(2)(a) that allows you to disregard the secondary breaker protection, so long as the primary breaker meets all the conditions of the 240 section.
240.5(B)(2)(a) conditions
10' or Less
The tap conductor is no more than 10 feet in length.
Ampacity
The tap conductor has an ampacity of: (1) Not less than the calculated load, and (2) Not less than the rating of the OCPD at the termination of the tap conductors.
Enclosure
The tap conductors do not extend beyond the equipment they supply.
240.5(B)(2)(b)
This sections details the same exception requirements as above but with the exception of tap conductors of no more than 25ft.
Summary and Recommendations1. Primary Protection
40A fuses on the primary appear to be code-compliant using the 125% rule.2.
Panel
The 200A panel is likely acceptable, as the calculated load is less than the panel's rating. However, NEC Article 408 provides very specific rules about panel board construction and installation which must be followed.3.
Secondary Main Breaker
Required? No, as long as the conditions of 240.5(B)(2)(a)/(b) are met. The secondary overcurrent protection must be compliant if following the 125% rule. 200A Not Compliant
If installing the 200a and not meeting the conditions of 240.5(B)(2)(a)/(b), this would not be compliant.
Important Considerations and Disclaimer Local Amendments
Always check with your local electrical inspector, as jurisdictions may have amendments to the NEC.
Voltage Drop
Pay attention to voltage drop calculations, especially with the longer secondary runs.
Professional Design
This information is for general guidance only. Always consult with a qualified electrical engineer and licensed electrician for the design and installation of electrical systems. They can ensure compliance with all applicable codes and regulations, and properly size conductors and protective devices for your specific application.
Load Calculations
This analysis assumes the transformer is feeding its full-rated load. Accurate load calculations for the downstream panel are crucial to ensure the system is safely designed.
Bonding and Grounding
Ensure proper bonding and grounding of the transformer, panel, and equipment.
Coordination: Proper coordination of overcurrent protective devices is critical for safety and reliability.This analysis provides a starting point. Consulting with a qualified professional is essential to ensure a safe and code-compliant installation. Flag for review