User: fastline, Location: midwest usa
Asked on: Tuesday, October 1, 2024 at 10:02 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:16 am EST
Question: Trying to do some remodeling of this shop space and I'd like to be able to run this panel. Obviously every single thing needs evaluated but I am wondering about a complete panel work up plus new breakers? Or does this girl need scrapped?? I really don't want to have to pull the box. I'm sure the Copper in it is good to go.There was some power moved around before I got in and appears they literally ran a dedicated EMT overhead just to avoid having to deal with this panel...lol This panel is fed under slab, so I like it. But has like 10 EMT takeoffs.
Okay, let's break down your situation with this panel. Providing a picture, or a few, would be super helpful.
Assumptions (Until I see pictures and more details)
The panel is a standard residential or light commercial panel. It's not water damaged or severely corroded beyond surface rust. The enclosure itself is structurally sound. The main breaker (if it has one) and individual breakers are the primary concern. You are qualified to do the work or working with a qualified electrician.
Here's a general approach and things to consider
1. Safety First!
Turn off the main breaker feeding this panel. Verify it's off with a non-contact voltage tester. Test multiple points in the panel. Treat everything inside as energized until proven otherwise.2. Initial Assessment (Before Doing Anything Inside)
Manufacturer and Model Number
Find this information on the panel label. This is crucial for looking up specifications and replacement parts.
Panel Amperage Rating
The label will state the maximum amperage the panel is designed for (e.g., 100A, 200A). This determines the size of the main breaker (if applicable) and overall capacity.
Number of Circuits
How many breaker spaces are there? Are there tandems/cheaters? Do you need more?
Physical Condition
Rust/Corrosion
Is it surface rust or deep corrosion? Surface rust can often be cleaned. Deep corrosion is a red flag.
Damage
Dents, cracks, holes in the enclosure?
Knockouts
Are all unused knockouts properly closed?
Wiring
Insulation
Cracked, brittle, or melted insulation on wires inside the panel?
Connections
Loose connections on breakers or the neutral/ground bars? Signs of arcing (burn marks)?
Overfilled
Is the panel overcrowded with wires, making it difficult to work?
Breakers
Type
Are the breakers the correct type for the panel (based on the manufacturer and model number)?
Condition
Are they physically damaged? Do they feel loose or sticky when you try to flip them?
Tripping
Do breakers trip frequently for no apparent reason? (This could indicate a problem with the breaker or the circuit it protects.)
Incoming Feed
Wire Size
Is the wire gauge appropriate for the amperage of the main breaker feeding the panel? (A qualified electrician should verify this.)
Condition
Is the insulation on the incoming wires in good condition?
EMT Connections
Assess the condition of the EMT takeoffs. Are they properly secured? Are there any signs of water entry?
3. Is a Full Replacement Necessary?
Based on the above, here's a decision-making process: Definitely Replace
Significant Corrosion
Extensive corrosion weakens the panel and can cause electrical problems.
Physical Damage
Cracks, dents, or holes compromise the enclosure's safety.
Mismatched Components
Breakers that aren't the correct type for the panel are a major safety hazard.
Overfilled/Overloaded
If the panel is too small to accommodate the circuits you need (or is already crammed with wires), replacement is necessary.
Evidence of Arcing/Burning
This indicates serious electrical problems that could lead to a fire.
Potentially Salvageable (Requires More Evaluation)
Surface Rust
Can be cleaned and treated.
Older Breakers
If they are the correct type and in good working order (not tripping unnecessarily), they might be okay, but replacing them for peace of mind is often a good idea.
Loose Connections
Can be tightened (but investigate why they were loose).
Most Likely Salvageable The bus bars are in good condition. Correct breakers available.4. If Considering Keeping the Panel (Assuming it's deemed safe)
Breaker Replacement
Replace all breakers
This is often the best approach, especially if the panel is old. New breakers provide better protection and reliability. Use the correct type for the panel.
Consider AFCI/GFCI breakers
Code requirements often dictate the use of Arc Fault Circuit Interrupter (AFCI) and Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter (GFCI) breakers for certain circuits (e.g., bedrooms, bathrooms, kitchens).
Cleaning and Repair
Clean Rust
Use a wire brush and rust converter/inhibitor.
Tighten Connections
Carefully tighten all screw terminals (breakers, neutral/ground bars). Use a torque screwdriver to ensure proper tightness.
Label Circuits
Clearly label each breaker with the circuit it controls. This is essential for troubleshooting and safety.
Wiring
Re-Terminate
If any wires are damaged or have poor connections, re-terminate them.
Secure Wiring
Ensure all wiring is properly secured within the panel.
5. New Panel Considerations (If You Decide to Replace)
Size
Choose a panel with enough spaces for your current and future needs.
Amperage
Ensure the panel's amperage rating is adequate for your shop's electrical load.
Location
Replacing the panel in the same location is easiest, but consider if a different location would be more convenient.
Professional Installation
Replacing a panel is a complex and potentially dangerous job. It's highly recommended to have a qualified electrician do the work.
Addressing Your Specific Concerns
EMT Takeoffs
Evaluate the condition of the EMT runs. Are they properly supported? Are there any signs of water entering the conduits? If you're rerouting circuits, you may need to remove or cap off some of these.
Under Slab Feed
This can be an advantage, but it also means that any problems with the feed wire are more difficult to access. Have an electrician inspect the wire for any signs of damage or deterioration.
Avoiding the Panel
The fact that the previous occupants ran a new EMT run instead* of dealing with the existing panel is a red flag. It suggests they may have encountered problems with the panel itself.
In Summary
Before making any decisions, perform a thorough inspection of the panel. If you're not comfortable doing this yourself, hire a qualified electrician. If the panel is in poor condition, replacement is the safest and most reliable option. If it's potentially salvageable, carefully evaluate each component and consider replacing the breakers for peace of mind.
Next Steps
Post Pictures
Upload clear photos of the panel (inside and out) so I can give you more specific advice.2.
Gather Information
Get the manufacturer, model number, and amperage rating of the panel.3.
Consult an Electrician: Get a professional opinion on the condition of the panel and the best course of action.Good luck with your shop remodeling! Safety first! Flag for review