User: RobbieNelson, Location: WV
Asked on: Wednesday, October 2, 2024 at 1:43 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:18 am EST
Question: NFPA 497 Fig 5.10.16I noticed this in the 2017 edition. It's in the 2024 edition the same way.1. Shouldn't this diagram list "Division 2" instead of "Zone 2"? 5.10 is for Divisions; 5.11 is for Zones. Is it a typo?2. Assuming the section on the left is a view from above, the left shows a 15ft ground level radius, but the right side shows a 10ft radius. Am I looking at it wrong?
You've spotted two potential inconsistencies in NFPA 497 Figure 5.10.
16. Let's break them down
1. Zone vs. Division Labeling:
Yes, you are likely correct. Figure 5.10.16 is located in a section of NFPA 497 dealing with Divisions. Given this context, the label "Zone 2" is most likely a typographical error and should read "Division 2". Why it matters
This distinction is crucial because the requirements for equipment and installation in Division 2 locations are different than those for Zone 2 locations. Using the wrong classification can lead to non-compliance and potential safety hazards.
Recommendation
While NFPA standards are generally very carefully reviewed, errors can and do happen. It's best practice to: Consult with a qualified expert in hazardous location classification to confirm the correct classification based on your specific process and materials. Consider submitting a formal interpretation request to NFPA asking for clarification of the figure. This will get the issue officially on their radar and potentially lead to a correction in future editions.
2. Radius Discrepancy (15ft vs. 10ft)
You are also likely correct to see a discrepancy. It appears you're interpreting the diagram correctly: the left "plan" view shows a 15ft radius, while the right "elevation" view shows a 10ft radius from the tank vent/source. Possible Explanations (but not justification)
Intended Difference (Less Likely)
Very rarely there might be a reason to specify different radii in plan and elevation based on dispersion patterns, but this is highly unlikely for a standard figure like this. If that were the case, it should be clearly labeled as such.
Graphical Error (Most Likely)
It's much more probable that this is a graphical error in the drafting of the figure.
Recommendation
Again, treat this with caution:
Clarification Needed
Don't assume the smaller radius is correct without justification.
Conservative Approach
Use the larger of the two radii (15 ft) when determining the extent of the classified area. It's better to be overly cautious than to underestimate the hazard.
Expert Consultation
As with the Zone/Division issue, discuss this with a qualified expert who can evaluate the dispersion characteristics of the specific flammable material being handled. They can use modeling software or their experience to accurately determine the proper extent of the classified area.
NFPA Request
Include this discrepancy in your interpretation request to NFPA.
In summary: You've identified two potential errors in the diagram. It's crucial not to rely solely on the figure without further investigation and expert consultation. Prioritize safety and compliance by seeking clarification and using the most conservative approach until a definitive answer is obtained. It is very important to have a qualified expert determine the proper extent of the classified area. Flag for review