Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Transfer switch(s) commercial

User: Moosifer, Location: Panama City Beach, FL

Asked on: Wednesday, October 2, 2024 at 3:53 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:18 am EST

Question: I have a customer with what I would call a 500a 240v single phase service. 2qty 200a disconnect and a 100a disconnect all directly fed from overhead power and the meter has CT's.They want to make sure they can connect generators if power is lost from the next hurricane. We are in Florida.I have done military setups that are similar but simpler or sometimes a lot more confusing, but plugging in a 100a cord is no big deal.Can I do three fused double throw switches with 100a plug inputs on them and provide cords for them to connect to whatever generator or generators they can acquire if power is lost for a few days? (I would assume 3x 100a would keep them going).We have done similar things for walk in coolers. I just don't know if there are rules about a maximum size temporary generator connection.If it were a 400a service I would tell them they need a single transfer switch and a permanent generator.This is for a disaster recovery operation so they have access to all sorts of generators and really don't want to buy one that will sit around and do nothing most of the time.Any help would be appreciated.

Okay, let's break down your situation and address the safest and code-compliant options for generator connection in your Florida customer's setup.

Key Considerations and Potential Issues



NEC (National Electrical Code) Compliance

Safety is paramount. Any generator connection must be done according to the NEC, local amendments, and any relevant utility regulations.


Load Balancing

With three separate disconnects, proper load balancing becomes critical. Uneven load distribution can damage generators and lead to voltage imbalances. This is often overlooked in these types of installations.

Neutral Bonding

You
must ensure that only one neutral-to-ground bond exists in the system when the generator(s) are running. Multiple neutral-to-ground bonds create parallel neutral paths, which can lead to circulating currents, overheating, and electrical noise. The safest way to ensure this is for the generator(s) to be non-separately derived (see below).

Generator Capacity and Cord Sizing

100A per cord is quite a bit of power. Make sure the generators that are connected, the cords, and the switches can all handle the required amperage safely.

Legality of Backfeeding
Be sure that your utility doesn't prohibit this type of setup, or require any additional equipment, such as relaying.

Your Proposed Solution: Three Fused Double-Throw Switches

While your approach
could work, it has significant potential pitfalls and may not be the best or safest approach. Here's a breakdown: Pros

Potentially cost-effective (compared to a large automatic transfer switch). Flexibility to use multiple smaller generators.

Cons



Load Balancing Nightmare

The biggest issue. Ensuring the load is perfectly balanced across the three circuits is difficult to impossible in a real-world outage scenario. You are highly reliant on the customer to manually manage the load.

Synchronization

If the generators are not synchronized, you can create damage to equipment.


Accidental Backfeed

It is far more likely a customer can accidentally backfeed onto the utility grid and injure or kill a lineman.

Neutral Bonding Issues

Must be carefully addressed to avoid parallel neutral paths.


Complexity for the Customer

Requires the customer to understand how to operate the switches, plug in the generators correctly, and manage the load distribution.

Code Compliance

It is difficult to see how this meets code without additional controls and interlocks.


Inspection Issues

Very likely to fail inspection by anyone familiar with generators.

Warranty Voiding

Your equipment warranty will likely be voided.

Recommended Solutions (Prioritized)
1. Single Automatic Transfer Switch (ATS) with Permanent Generator

This is the

safest, most reliable, and most code-compliant
solution. While the customer dislikes the idea of an unused generator, it provides peace of mind and ensures proper operation during an outage.
Size the generator and ATS appropriately for their critical loads. The ATS automatically switches the load between the utility and the generator. Neutral bonding is properly handled within the ATS. This approach minimizes the risk of human error and ensures proper operation.2. Single Manual Transfer Switch with a Larger Generator Input

A large manual transfer switch with generator input would be preferable to your 3x Double Throw approach.3.

Interlocked Breakers and a Generator Connection Box
A method of using interlocked breakers can be found in NEC 702.5 which addresses optional standby systems. If installed and used correctly these systems are code compliant. However you may have a hard time passing inspection.

Important Considerations



Load Calculation

Perform a thorough load calculation to determine the actual power requirements during an outage. Don't guess! 500A service does not mean they will use 500A with a generator.

Critical Loads

Identify the
essential loads that must be powered during an outage. Focus on those loads first.

Cord and Plug Ampacity

Make absolutely sure that the cords, plugs, receptacles, and transfer switch components are all rated for the maximum current they will carry.

Signage and Labeling

Clearly label all equipment, including the transfer switches, generator connection points, and any load panels. Provide clear instructions for the customer.


Testing

After installation, thoroughly test the system to ensure it operates correctly and that the load is properly balanced.

Training

Train the customer on the proper operation of the system and the importance of load management.

Disclaimer

You
must* consult with a qualified and licensed electrical engineer and electrician to design and install this system in accordance with all applicable codes and regulations. This information is for general guidance only. You also need to consult the Florida Building Code, and your AHJ for any specific requirements, and be prepared to stamp/seal any drawings required.

In Conclusion:


While your idea of three double-throw switches might seem like a quick fix, the complexities of load balancing and safety concerns make it a less desirable option compared to a properly sized automatic or manual transfer switch. I would strongly recommend explaining the risks and benefits to your customer and steering them towards a safer and more reliable solution. I would also suggest they contact their insurance company to make sure a non-permanent generator solution is acceptable to them. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question