Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: back to back box installation in the concrete wall in the light of IBC

User: Jin Kim, Location: USA

Asked on: Wednesday, October 2, 2024 at 5:44 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:18 am EST

Question: Hello, fellows.I have been dwelling on this matter, but still haven't got any documented guidelines.the notorious "back to back box in the wall, that is considered as membrance penetrant per IBC".Well... for the through penetration, IBC has a paragraph saying concrete wall as an exemption (714.4.1 of IBC 2021).However, IBC is silence about membrance(back to back) in the concrete wall.Of course, I can just seprate the boxes more than 2 feet, but it is so off putting and it won't work at the security doors where many of accessories are mounted on both sides of the wall.My guts say having not less than the depth of concrete wall thickness between boxes should work, but... does any one have a good ground that illustrate what is should be like?Any advice would be appreciated.

You're right, the IBC is silent on back-to-back boxes within concrete walls when considering them as "membrane penetrations." This ambiguity is a common point of confusion. Here's a breakdown of the issue, potential solutions, and supporting arguments

Understanding the Problem

The concern with back-to-back boxes is that they create a weakness in a fire-rated assembly. A direct pathway is formed for flames and hot gases to bypass the integrity of the barrier, potentially leading to faster fire spread. While concrete itself is highly fire-resistant, the penetration created by the boxes and wiring introduces a vulnerability.

Why IBC 714.4.1 (Concrete Exemption) Doesn't Directly Apply

IBC 714.4.1 provides an exemption for through penetrations in concrete walls. This means that if a single conduit or cable passes completely through a concrete wall, it may not require the same level of firestopping as a penetration in a fire-rated gypsum wall assembly. The assumption is that the concrete itself provides adequate fire resistance.However, your back-to-back scenario is different. It's not a single, straightforward through-penetration. It effectively creates two penetrations close together, potentially compromising the integrity of the concrete between them. That compromised section of concrete becomes a potential weak point.

Possible Solutions and Justifications

Here are some approaches to address the situation, along with their rationale:1. Firestopping

This is the most conservative and generally accepted approach.

Action

Treat each box as a separate penetration, even if they're back-to-back. Use listed firestopping materials (putty pads, sealants, etc.) appropriate for the specific box type, wall construction, and fire-resistance rating. This is likely required if your AHJ is concerned with fire-stopping integrity.


Justification

This complies explicitly with the intent of the code to maintain the fire-resistance rating of the assembly. It provides a tested and documented solution.2.

Concrete Thickness/Spacing Justification (Your "Guts" Feeling)

This is a more nuanced and potentially controversial approach.

Action

Argue that a sufficient thickness of concrete between the boxes provides adequate fire resistance. You could propose a minimum distance based on factors like the wall's fire-resistance rating and the box size. You might say, the depth of the box to be an acceptable seperation.


Justification



Concrete's inherent fire resistance

Concrete is inherently fire-resistant. A substantial layer of concrete will act as a thermal barrier.


Limited box size

Electrical boxes are generally small. The area of the concrete compromised is also small.

Potential for charring/self-sealing

In a fire, the wiring and box materials might char, potentially creating a degree of self-sealing within the penetration. (This is a weaker argument and not something to rely on heavily.)


Engineering Judgement

This is not something you can do without an engineering judgement.3.

Consider Non-Combustible Box Materials and Design



Action

Utilize metal electrical boxes. Recess them to prevent protruding.


Justification

Non-combustible materials provide a resistance to spreading fire that combustible materials don't. If you are already using non-combustible materials that have been installed correctly, there is less risk of fire damage.

Important Considerations and Best Practices



Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)

The most important factor is the AHJ's interpretation. Contact your local building department and discuss the situation. They will ultimately decide what's acceptable. Document their response.

Documentation

Regardless of the approach, document everything: Drawings showing the box locations and wall construction. Specifications for the boxes and any firestopping materials. Written confirmation from the AHJ.

Engineering Judgement Letter

If pursuing the concrete thickness justification, consider obtaining an engineering judgment letter from a licensed fire protection engineer. This letter would provide a professional opinion based on relevant fire science and engineering principles, supporting your claim that the concrete thickness is sufficient.

Testing and Listing

If possible, look for electrical boxes that have been tested and listed for use in fire-rated concrete walls without firestopping (although this is uncommon).


Security Systems and Low-Voltage

If the boxes primarily contain low-voltage wiring (security systems, data, etc.), the fire risk is generally lower than if they contain high-voltage power circuits. You might be able to make a stronger case for the concrete thickness justification in low-voltage applications, but you still need AHJ approval.

In summary, while the IBC doesn't explicitly address back-to-back boxes in concrete walls as membrane penetrations, the prudent and generally accepted approach is to provide firestopping. If you want to pursue an alternative, such as relying on concrete thickness, you need to discuss it with the AHJ and potentially obtain an engineering judgment letter.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question