Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Sub-panel bonding

User: frofro19, Location: VA.

Asked on: Wednesday, October 2, 2024 at 8:21 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:19 am EST

Question: I ran into a situation while working at my church and I ran across a sub-panel wired with a 3 wire (#2 seu cable) and all the neutrals and grounds were connected together and bonded to the cabinet. I know a 4 wire should have been ran but was this an acceptable installation prior to 2008? I'm guessing it was done in the late 80's or 90's.

You're right to be concerned. What you describe was a common, and sometimes permissible, practice before the major revisions in the 2008 National Electrical Code (NEC). Let's break down the situation

Pre-2008 NEC (Late 80s/90s):
Acceptable Under Specific Circumstances

Yes, the NEC
allowed a 3-wire feed to a subpanel with the neutral and ground bonded at the subpanel cabinet under specific circumstances. The most common was when the subpanel was located in the

same building
as the main service panel. Key Requirement: Single Structure

The critical factor was that both panels were in the same building. The reasoning was that grounding through metal conduit (if used) and other metallic pathways was deemed sufficient to provide a low-impedance path for fault current back to the source.

SE Cable Considerations

The issue with your setup using #2 SE (Service Entrance) cable is two-fold:


SE Cable as a Ground

SE cable could be used in some cases to supply a subpanel in the same structure, BUT it was necessary to verify the cable was specifically listed for use as a grounding conductor. Usually, this meant it had a green stripe or other marking designating the bare conductor (the outer spiral wrap) as suitable for grounding. If the SE cable was not listed for grounding, this was a violation.

Ampacity of #2

You need to verify that the ampacity of #2 copper conductors were sufficient for the size of the overcurrent protection feeding the panel.


Why It Was Allowed (Historically)

The allowance stemmed from older electrical theory and accepted practices. Over time, experience revealed problems:

Neutral Current on Ground

With neutral and ground bonded at the subpanel, neutral current flowed on the grounding path. This created the potential for objectionable current and voltage on metallic equipment enclosures and could interfere with sensitive electronic equipment.


Safety Concerns

In the event of a neutral conductor failure, the grounding path became the only return path for current, which is dangerous.

Increased Electronic Sensitivity

Modern electronic equipment is much more susceptible to noise and voltage fluctuations on the grounding system.

Post-2008 NEC (And Current)



Four-Wire Feeds Required

The NEC now requires a separate equipment grounding conductor (EGC) to be run with the feeder conductors (two hots and a neutral) to any subpanel. This means a 4-wire feed. The neutral and ground must be kept separate at the subpanel.

No Bonding at Subpanel

The neutral bus in the subpanel must be isolated from the enclosure. The equipment grounding conductor (EGC) is connected to the enclosure and the ground bus.


Grounding Electrode Conductor (GEC)

The only point where the neutral and grounding systems are bonded together is at the main service disconnect.

What You Should Do (Recommendations)


Consult a Qualified Electrician

The best course of action is to have a licensed electrician evaluate the situation. They can: Verify the wire gauge and overcurrent protection size Determine if the SE cable used was rated for grounding purposes. Assess the overall condition of the installation. Advise on the best and safest way to bring the subpanel up to current code.2.

Correction is Highly Recommended

Even if the installation might have been compliant at the time it was done, it's strongly recommended to correct it to current code. This will improve safety and reduce the risk of problems.3.

Potential Corrective Actions



Run a New 4-Wire Feed

Ideally, replace the existing 3-wire SE cable with a 4-wire cable (or individual conductors in conduit) of appropriate size.


Separate Neutrals and Grounds

Isolate the neutral bus in the subpanel, connect the new grounding conductor to the enclosure and ground bus, and remove the bonding jumper that connects the neutral bus to the enclosure.

In Summary:


While the installation might have been permissible under older codes (assuming the SE was rated for grounding, ampacity was correct, and it was in the same building), it is a substandard and potentially unsafe configuration by today's standards. Correcting it to a 4-wire system with separated neutrals and grounds is the safest and most reliable approach. Don't hesitate to involve a qualified electrician to ensure the work is done properly. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question