Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 220.61 FEEDER / SERVICE NEUTRAL LOAD CALCULATION

User: Cybatrex, Location: Florida

Asked on: Thursday, October 3, 2024 at 6:24 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:21 am EST

Question: Help. I'm practicing for my exam and I believe on my practice test the answer is wrong here.Feeder/Service Neutral Calculated Load:What is the feeder/service neutral calculated load for the following service:200 amp Line to Line loads200 amp Line to Neutral Nonlinear Loads200 amp Line to Neutral Linear Loads

You're right to question the answer! Here's a breakdown of how to calculate the neutral load and why the typical answers are often incomplete

Understanding the Concepts
Line-to-Line Loads (240V in a typical split-phase system)

These loads do NOT contribute to the neutral current. The current flows from one hot leg to the other. Examples include electric ranges, water heaters, and window A/C units.


Line-to-Neutral Linear Loads (120V)

These loads DO contribute to the neutral current. For a perfectly balanced system, the neutral current would be the difference between the currents on the two hot legs. Examples are incandescent lights, some older electronics, and resistive heating elements.

Line-to-Neutral Nonlinear Loads (120V)

These are the tricky ones. They can significantly increase neutral current
beyond what a simple addition of the linear load current would suggest. Examples include:

Electronic devices with switching power supplies

Computers, LED lighting, TVs, and many modern appliances. These devices draw current in short, sharp pulses, creating harmonic currents.

Harmonic Currents

These are currents with frequencies that are multiples of the fundamental frequency (60 Hz in North America). Odd-order harmonics (3rd, 5th, 7th, etc.) are particularly problematic. The 3rd harmonic is a
triplen harmonic, meaning it is a multiple of 3. Triplen harmonics are additive in the neutral conductor in a 3-phase, 4-wire system (and often problematic even in split-phase systems).

The Calculation (with considerations for Non-linear loads)
1. Linear Load Contribution

Assume the 200A of linear load is divided equally across the two hot legs. In a
perfectly balanced system, the neutral current could theoretically be zero. However, in a real-world scenario, there is always some imbalance, and a portion of this load's current will return on the neutral. Without more information on the specific circuiting of the 200A linear load, it's difficult to determine the exact neutral current contribution. We will assume, though, that the fundamental frequency current contribution to the neutral conductor is

200 amps
.2. Nonlinear Load Contribution

This is where things get complex. Because triplen harmonics are additive in the neutral conductor, it is common for the neutral current from nonlinear loads to exceed the current in either of the hot legs feeding those loads. 200A of non-linear loads means 200 Amps of harmonic current are flowing through the neutral.3.

Total Neutral Load (Simplified)

Linear Load: 200 amps Non-Linear Load: 200 amps Total: 400 amps

Important Considerations and Potential Code Requirements (NEC)
NEC 220.61 (Services)

This section covers optional methods for calculating neutral loads for services. It allows you to take a demand factor on the portion of the neutral load that serves electric ranges, dryers, and similar appliances.
However, it explicitly states that there is no reduction allowed for that portion of the load consisting of nonlinear loads.

NEC 220.20 (Feeders)

Similar rules apply to feeders.

Oversizing the Neutral

Due to the potential for high harmonic currents, it's often necessary to
oversize the neutral conductor, especially in commercial buildings with a high density of electronic equipment. Some specifications might call for a neutral conductor to be sized at 150% or even 200% of the ampacity of the phase conductors to handle harmonic currents.

Why the Practice Test Answer Might Be Wrong


Many older resources or simplified practice tests
incorrectly assume that the neutral load is simply the difference between the current on the two hot legs, or they neglect the impact of nonlinear loads altogether. This can lead to significantly underestimating the required neutral conductor size.

In summary:

For the given scenario, if the 200A of nonlinear load is present, the minimum neutral load should be
at least 400A, and may even need to be larger.To provide a precise answer for your exam, look for clues in the question: Does the question mention anything about diversity or demand factors? If so, there might be a permitted reduction for the linear load portion, but never for the nonlinear portion. Is the question specifically asking about the minimum neutral conductor size according to the NEC? Are there specific code sections referenced in the question?Good luck with your exam! Understanding these concepts will put you in a strong position. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question