Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 230.72 Grouping of Disconnects

User: goldsborough, Location: Northern California

Asked on: Thursday, October 3, 2024 at 7:03 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:21 am EST

Question: I recently failed a job by a contractor. A Service lateral terminates in a non-fused disconnect located about 5 feet from entry. All the grounding and bonding was completed at this non-fused disconnect. The non-fused disconnect then feeds two 4 gang Meter Stacks (OCPD at Each Meter) which brings the total services number to 8 for one building. There are other inspectors saying this is not a violation.

Okay, let's break down the potential code violations based on the information you provided. It seems like there are several potential issues, but the biggest one is the number of services.

Potential Code Violations & Explanations


Number of Services (Critical)
Violation

Multiple Services in a Building.


NEC Reference

230.2 Number of Service.

Explanation

The NEC generally limits a building to

one
service. While exceptions exist, they are specific and don't seem to apply in your scenario based on what you've described. Having 8 individual services (one for each meter in the meter stacks) originating from a single service lateral is likely a violation unless a specific exception applies. The inspector is not allowed to use the term "Main Disconnect" on a Multi-Occupancy service, it must be clearly labeled "Meter Disconnect" for NEC 230.71 compliance. Exceptions that might apply (but are unlikely without more information)



230.2(A) Special Conditions


(1) Fire Pumps

A separate service shall be permitted for fire pumps.

(2) Emergency, Legally Required Standby, or Optional Standby Systems

A separate service shall be permitted for emergency, legally required standby, or optional standby systems where one or more of these systems are installed.
(3) Parallel Power Production Systems

A separate service shall be permitted for parallel power production systems.

(4) Electric Vehicle Charging Systems

A separate service shall be permitted for electric vehicle charging systems.
(5) Different Characteristics or Uses

Additional services shall be permitted for different voltages, frequencies, or phases, or for different uses, such as control of outside lighting from a time clock, or electric space heating where separately metered.

(6) Occupancies with 25 or More Branch Circuits

Where a building or other structure is under single management and control, multiple services supplying it shall be permitted to supply the loads in each occupancy under any of the following conditions:

(a)
Where the capacity requirements are in excess of 2000 amps at a supply voltage of 600 volts or less.(b) Where the load requirements of a single-phase installation exceed the utility's supply capacity.(c) Where by reason of the design of the installation, the capacity requirements make it necessary to supply the building or structure with more than one service.(d) For large capacity multitenant buildings or complexes under single management. 230.40 Exception No. 2

Two to six service disconnecting means shall be permitted to supply separate loads from one service drop or lateral. This exception might be applicable IF the building is a multi-occupancy building (like an apartment complex), and each meter stack truly serves a separate occupancy. Even then, there is a limit of six disconnecting means from one lateral. You have eight.2.

Feeder Taps Without Overcurrent Protection (Potentially)
Violation

Tapping a feeder without proper overcurrent protection at the tap point.


NEC Reference

240.21 Location in Circuit.

Explanation

If the conductors running from the non-fused disconnect to the meter stacks are considered feeder taps (and they likely are), they need to comply with tap rules. The tap rules require that the tap conductors either (a) be protected by overcurrent protection at the point they receive their supply, or (b) meet certain length and ampacity requirements. Since the non-fused disconnect has no overcurrent protection, this could be a violation if the tap rules aren't met.3.

Grouping of Disconnects (Potentially)
Violation

Service disconnects not grouped.

NEC Reference

230.72
Grouping of Disconnects.

Explanation

If the meter stacks are considered service disconnects (which they likely are), they need to be grouped in a readily accessible location. If these meter stacks are not next to each other, it could be a violation. However, the "grouping" requirement is often interpreted as being at the same location, not necessarily a single enclosure. Since all the meter stacks are at the same location, they are likely not violating this.

Why Other Inspectors Might Disagree (and why they might be wrong)



Misunderstanding of "Service"

Some might incorrectly assume that as long as the
service lateral is only one, it's okay. However, the NEC is very specific that a building should only have one service. The service starts at the point of connection to the utility and includes the service entrance conductors, the disconnecting means, and the overcurrent protection.

Misinterpreting Exceptions

They may be trying to force-fit the situation into one of the exceptions in 230.2 without a valid basis.

Utility Company Rules

The utility company's rules and regulations are sometimes confused with the NEC. While utilities have their own requirements, they don't override the NEC requirements for the building's electrical system.


Lack of Understanding

It's unfortunate, but sometimes inspectors make mistakes or don't fully understand the code.

Local Practices

In some areas, there are established practices (even if incorrect) that inspectors are hesitant to challenge.

What You Should Do


Document Everything

Take detailed photos of the entire installation, including the service lateral, non-fused disconnect, meter stacks, and any labels.2.

Review NEC 230 Thoroughly

Understand the sections on number of services, service disconnecting means, and grounding/bonding.3.

Consult with a Senior Inspector/Chief Electrical Inspector

If possible, speak to a more experienced inspector or the chief electrical inspector for the jurisdiction. Explain your concerns and provide your documentation.4.

Get a Second Opinion (from a NEC Expert)

Consider consulting with a qualified electrical engineer or a certified master electrician who is an expert in the NEC. Pay for their time to review the situation and provide a written opinion.5.

Request a Formal Interpretation

If necessary, you can request a formal interpretation of the code from the AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction).6.

Be Prepared to Appeal

If you believe the installation is a code violation and the inspector is not taking action, be prepared to appeal the decision.

Key Argument

Your strongest argument is the violation of the "one service per building" rule (230.2). Unless a very specific exception applies, having 8 services originating from a single lateral is a clear violation.

Important Considerations



Safety

This type of installation can be dangerous if not done correctly. Multiple service disconnects without clear labeling can create confusion in emergency situations.*

Liability

If something goes wrong (e.g., a fire) and the installation is found to be non-compliant, you (and potentially the inspector who approved it) could be held liable.Good luck! This can be a frustrating situation, but it's important to advocate for code-compliant and safe electrical installations.

Disclaimer:
I am an AI chatbot and cannot provide definitive legal or professional advice. This information is for general guidance only. Consult with qualified professionals for specific advice related to your situation. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question