User: goldstar, Location: New Jersey
Asked on: Thursday, October 3, 2024 at 7:19 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:21 am EST
Question: It's been a while since I was here but, I know there is a wealth of info being passed along in this forum so, I'm backAnyway, I live in a lake community and was asked by the lake association if I would test and inspect the electrical connections for those lake-front houses that are using water movers to keep the algae, leaves, etc. from accumulating at their docks and water fronts. The first one I inspected was done by a homeowner, but you would think it was done by an experienced electrical contractor. All wiring was done in PVC, proper connections, proper JB's, proper in-use covers and the GFCI protection worked perfectly. The next two I inspected were not so great. In both cases the GFCI protection worked perfectly but the homeowners buried 16-gauge extension cords below their lawns (and I'm sure it was not more that 6" down). One house had the extension cord buried up to one side of the lawn where he had festooned lights plugged in, split it from there and then ran extension cords on the lawn's surface down to the dock area.So, here are my questions (aside from Code compliance)Should I be concerned about electrifying the water in the water mover area as long as the GFCI's are functioning properly?The lake association claims that they have no concern with Code compliance on the homeowner's property as long as the GFCI's work. Should I be concerned and/or would I have a liability in the event of an electrification?I want to add that in most cases there would not be anyone swimming in these areas - but we don't know that for sure. The lake is about 1/2-mile long and about 1000' wide. The closest swimming area is about 800' away.Thanks in advance for your responses.
Okay, this is a situation with multiple layers of concern. Let's break it down
1. Ground Fault Circuit Interrupters (GFCIs) and Electrical Safety in Water:
GFCI Function
GFCIs are designed to quickly interrupt power when they detect a difference in current flowing between the hot and neutral wires (indicating current leakage to ground). They are absolutely crucial in environments near water.
GFCI Limitations
While GFCIs significantly reduce the risk of electric shock drowning (ESD) and other electrical hazards, they are not foolproof. They are designed to protect against dangerous currents, but:
Small Leakage Currents
They may not detect very small leakage currents. These small currents, while not enough to trip the GFCI, can still be present in the water and could potentially cause discomfort or, in very rare circumstances, contribute to an unsafe situation, especially for someone with underlying health conditions.
Malfunction
GFCIs, like any electrical device, can fail. Periodic testing is essential, but even then, there's no guarantee against sudden failure.
Reaction Time
GFCIs have a reaction time (typically milliseconds). While fast, there's still a brief moment where a fault current could flow.
Stray Voltage
The presence of "stray voltage" (low-level electrical potential differences in the water or ground) is often a complex issue with multiple potential sources. Even with functioning GFCIs, there can be stray voltage.
Should you be concerned about electrifying the water, even with working GFCIs? Yes, you should still be concerned, but the risk is significantly reduced by properly functioning GFCIs. The buried extension cords are a HUGE red flag because their insulation will eventually degrade and leakage current is much more likely.2. Code Compliance vs. Lake Association Policy
Code Compliance is the Baseline for Safety
Electrical codes (like the NEC in the US) are minimum safety standards. They are designed to protect people and property from electrical hazards.
Lake Association's Position
The lake association's stance of ignoring code compliance as long as GFCIs work is
extremely risky and, in my opinion, shows a significant lack of understanding about electrical safety. It is prioritizing convenience and cost over safety. Specific Code Violations
Buried Extension Cords
This is a major code violation. Extension cords are not designed for direct burial. They lack the necessary insulation and protection against moisture, physical damage, and rodent activity. Buried cords are practically guaranteed to fail over time, creating shock hazards and potential fire risks. The NEC requires direct burial cable to be rated for direct burial and installed at a specific depth.
Inadequate Wiring Methods
Running extension cords across lawns is also a code violation and a trip hazard. Proper wiring methods (like UF cable in conduit) should be used for permanent outdoor wiring.
Wet Locations
Electrical equipment near water (docks, etc.) requires specific ratings for wet locations (e.g., weatherproof enclosures, GFCI protection, appropriate wiring methods).
3. Your Liability
This is the most crucial part for you personally.
Good Samaritan Laws
These laws typically offer some protection from liability to individuals who voluntarily render aid in emergency situations. However, they generally don't apply when you are providing a service or acting in a professional capacity. Your position with the lake association likely puts you in a grey area.
Negligence
If you identify a clear and present danger (like the buried extension cords), and you don't take reasonable steps to address it (e.g., reporting it, recommending corrective action, documenting your concerns), you could be held liable if someone is injured or killed as a result.
Documentation is Key
You must document everything you find, the recommendations you make, and the lake association's response. Get everything in writing. If the lake association refuses to address dangerous conditions, seriously consider resigning from the position to protect yourself.
Consult Legal Counsel
Given the potential liability, it is strongly advised that you consult with an attorney who specializes in liability and negligence law in your state. Explain your situation, show them your documentation, and get their advice on how to protect yourself.
Inform the Lake Association in Writing
You need to clearly and unequivocally inform the lake association in writing that their policy of ignoring code violations is dangerous and could expose them (and you) to significant liability. State that you are strongly recommending that all electrical installations comply with the National Electrical Code (NEC) or local electrical codes, and that unqualified people should not be performing electrical work.
Refuse to Inspect Without Addressing Concerns
If the lake association is unwilling to do anything about the violations you are seeing, you should refuse to continue inspecting. Your involvement could imply that you are condoning the unsafe practices.
4. Recommendations
Prioritize Safety
Make it clear that the safety of residents and visitors is the top priority.
Enforce Code Compliance
Advocate strongly for full compliance with the National Electrical Code (NEC) or the local electrical codes.
Qualified Electricians Only
Recommend that all electrical work be performed by licensed and insured electricians.
Correct the Violations Immediately
The buried extension cords and other unsafe wiring practices should be corrected immediately.
Regular Inspections
Implement a program of regular electrical inspections by a qualified electrician.
Education
Educate homeowners about the dangers of electricity near water and the importance of safe wiring practices. Provide them with information on proper wiring methods, GFCI protection, and the dangers of using extension cords improperly.
Signage
Consider posting signs in the lake area warning about the dangers of electricity in the water and the importance of avoiding contact with electrical equipment.*
Consider an Electrician's Perspective
The best approach would be to encourage the lake association to have a licensed electrician perform the testing and inspections. You are more likely to be seen as liable if you are not properly licensed to perform this type of inspection.
In summary
You are in a precarious situation. The lake association's stance is dangerous and irresponsible. To protect yourself, you need to:1.
Document everything.2. Inform the lake association of the risks in writing and recommend corrective action (Code compliant installations).3. If they refuse to act, consider resigning and consult with an attorney to understand your legal obligations.4. Stop inspecting.
Safety needs to be the priority. If you have to choose between being liked by the lake association and protecting yourself and others from potential harm, choose safety every time. Flag for review