Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Motion Sensor blows up

User: sparkmatic, Location: California

Asked on: Thursday, October 3, 2024 at 10:25 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:22 am EST

Question: So /we have motion sensors through out my site that power T5 fixtures single lamp, that are 240V to ground. The sensor is rated for 120/230 (single phase), 277,347. I do not see any issue with the voltage but for some reason from what I have found out that this is not the first time the sensor smoked on someone. For me it happened after I restored power, the lamps came on for about 10 seconds then the sensor let looseI then did some checks found nothing grounded but replaced the wiring and lamps (these are fixtures that come pre set up with cables that plug in either side of each fixture (encapsulated)not my choice just whats here.After the rewire the lights work and have worked for a few days now. Hope this makes sense.My main question is has anyone had this kind of issue? I don't want to put the manufacture out there as it may not be their issue just don't see an issue that should cause these smoke (violently)Thanks

Okay, this is a tricky one because you've covered the obvious stuff. Here's a breakdown of potential causes and things to investigate

Possible Causes (Based on the Info Provided):

1. Inrush Current

T5 lamps, especially when starting cold, can draw a significant inrush current. This is a very short burst of high amperage. While the sensor is rated for a certain amperage, the duration of the inrush could be stressing a sensitive component within the sensor, causing it to fail over time or suddenly. The fact that it happened on power restoration is a strong indicator.2.

Harmonics

T5 electronic ballasts (likely what you have, though you didn't explicitly state it) can generate harmonics on the power line. These harmonics can sometimes interfere with sensitive electronic circuits in the sensor. While most sensors are designed to tolerate some harmonics, the level of harmonics in your system could be unusually high.3.

Voltage Spikes/Surges

Even though you're at 240V, transient voltage spikes (from other equipment turning on/off, nearby lightning, utility switching, etc.) can damage the sensor's electronics. These spikes can be very short-lived (microseconds) and not easily detectable without specialized equipment.4.

Manufacturing Defect (Intermittent)

It's possible you're getting a bad batch of sensors. Manufacturing variations can lead to some units being more susceptible to stress than others.5.

Wiring/Connections (Subtle Problem)

Even though you replaced the wiring, there could be a subtle issue with the connections. Things to look for:

Loose connections

Even a slightly loose connection can create resistance, heat, and voltage drops, potentially stressing the sensor.


Improper crimps

If the plug-in connectors use crimped connections, ensure they are properly crimped. A bad crimp can lead to resistance and heat.

Shared Neutral (If Applicable)

In some electrical systems, multiple circuits share a neutral conductor. This can lead to neutral currents exceeding the wire's capacity and causing voltage fluctuations. While less likely with single-lamp fixtures, it's worth considering if the sensors and fixtures share a common neutral.6.

Sensor Compatibility

Even though the sensor's voltage rating seems compatible, double-check the
amperage or wattage rating of the sensor. It must be higher than the maximum amperage or wattage of the T5 fixture. If it is very close you could be causing stress.7.

Sensor Internal Relay Contact Damage

The sensor most likely uses a relay or solid-state switch to control power. Inrush current or voltage spikes could be damaging the contacts of the relay over time, leading to failure.

Troubleshooting Steps to Take


Inrush Current Mitigation



Consider using a sensor with a higher inrush current rating

If possible, find a sensor specifically designed for lighting loads with high inrush. The spec sheet might specifically mention inrush current handling.

Add an inrush current limiter

These devices are designed to reduce the inrush current to the lamp. This can be installed in series with the fixture. (Needs professional electrical installation).2.

Power Quality Monitoring



Hire an electrician or power quality specialist to perform a power quality analysis

They can use specialized equipment to measure voltage fluctuations, harmonics, and transient spikes. This will help determine if these are contributing to the sensor failures.3.

Check and Retorque Connections



Thoroughly inspect and retorque all connections

Make sure they are clean and tight. Use a torque screwdriver to ensure proper tightness, especially on terminal blocks. Pay close attention to the plug-in connectors.4.

Monitor Voltage



Use a multimeter to monitor the voltage at the sensor input

Check for voltage drops or fluctuations during the startup of the T5 lamps and while the lamps are running.5.

Contact the Sensor Manufacturer



Provide the manufacturer with detailed information about your system and the failures

Include the model number of the sensor, the type of T5 ballast, the voltage, and a description of the failure. Ask them if they have seen similar issues or have any recommendations.
Do this without publicly shaming the company. Be polite and cooperative.6.

Install Surge Protection



Consider installing surge protection at the electrical panel feeding the lighting circuit

This can help protect against voltage spikes from external sources.7.

Verify Wiring Diagram Compliance

Ensure the sensor and fixture wiring matches the diagrams provided by the sensor and fixture manufacturers. A small wiring error can cause unexpected behavior.8.

Test with a Different Sensor Type



If possible, try a different brand or model of sensor to see if the problem persists

This can help determine if the issue is specific to the original sensor.

Important Considerations



Safety First

Always work safely when dealing with electrical systems. De-energize the circuit before working on any wiring or components. If you're not comfortable working with electrical systems, hire a qualified electrician.


Documentation

Keep detailed records of all troubleshooting steps, measurements, and observations. This will be helpful for identifying patterns and communicating with the sensor manufacturer.

Warranty

Check the warranty of the sensors. If they are failing prematurely, you may be able to get them replaced under warranty.

Why Your Rewire
Seemingly Fixed it (Potentially Temporary)

The rewire might have temporarily fixed the problem by:


Improving a loose connection

You may have inadvertently fixed a loose connection that was causing a voltage drop or resistance, even if you didn't see it.*

Replacing a weakened sensor:
The original sensor might have been damaged and on the verge of failure. Replacing it with a new sensor gave you a temporary reprieve.However, if the underlying cause (e.g., inrush current, voltage spikes) is still present, the new sensor will likely fail eventually as well.By systematically investigating these potential causes and following the troubleshooting steps, you should be able to pinpoint the root cause of the sensor failures and implement a long-term solution. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question