User: johnson151, Location: Idaho
Asked on: Thursday, October 3, 2024 at 3:53 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:22 am EST
Question: I have a 100 amp service that will be fed from the power company with 1/0 AL. The grounding electrode is a rebar coming out of the concrete. I installed a #6 solid copper wire between the service panel and the rebar as the grounding electrode conductor. The inspector cited 250.66(B) and says that a #4 must be installed. The last sentence of this paragraph says "shall not be required be larger than #4awg" To me this says #4 is the maximum size I would need, and that I should size the GEC off of table 250.66 until conditions surpass what would otherwise call for larger that #4. The only evidence I can see that would support his argument is if that final statement means "is required to be #4".He has asked a few other inspectors and they all say #4, but haven't been given a solid reference or piece of evidence to support it.Can anyone else point me to what they may be referring too? Or, if I'm correct, is there a better reference or resource I can give to prove my case?I found this video that seems pretty clear to me, but the only thing the inspector said was "is Mike Holt the AHJ?"https://fb.watch/u_HJO0XW-1/
You are correct in your interpretation of 250.66(B) and Table 250.
66.Here's a breakdown: 250.66(A)
States that for a service supplied by grounded conductors (like yours), the GEC size is based on the size of the largest service-entrance conductor or equivalent area for parallel conductors.
250.66(B)
Specifically applies when the grounding electrode is concrete-encased or a ground ring. This is where the key exception lies. It says the GEC shall not be required to be larger than #4 AWG copper. This means the maximum size needed is #4 copper, regardless of what Table 250.66 would otherwise dictate based on your 1/0 Aluminum service conductors. Table 250.66 dictates that the GEC is to be #6 copper for 1/0 Aluminum, as you stated.
Why the Confusion?
The wording in 250.66(B) can be misinterpreted if you don't read it carefully and consider its context. Some people incorrectly assume the "shall not be required to be larger than" means "shall be" or "must be."Your Argument
Refer to the exact wording of 250.66(B)
Emphasize that it says "shall not be required to be larger than." This is a ceiling, not a floor.2.
Table 250.66
Show how the table dictates a #6 copper GEC for your 1/0 Aluminum service conductors.3.
Explain the purpose of 250.66(B)
This exception was created because concrete-encased electrodes (like your rebar) and ground rings have a very large surface area in contact with the earth, providing a very low-resistance ground path. Increasing the GEC size beyond #4 AWG copper offers diminishing returns in terms of improved grounding effectiveness.4.
The Mike Holt video is valid
While the inspector's comment about Mike Holt not being the AHJ is technically correct, Mike Holt's interpretation of the code is generally very reliable and widely accepted. Point out that the video explains the specific section in question very clearly.
Additional Strategies
Ask for the inspector's specific justification
Politely ask the inspector to explain why he believes a #4 is required, referencing the specific code section he is using. This will force him to articulate his reasoning, which may reveal a misunderstanding.
Escalate to a higher authority
If you are unable to resolve the issue with the inspector, you can typically appeal to the chief electrical inspector or building official for a second opinion.
Get a written interpretation
Request a written interpretation of the code from the local electrical authority. This will provide a clear and official ruling on the matter.
In Conclusion:
You are on solid ground with your interpretation of 250.66(B). The #6 copper GEC you installed is code-compliant. Provide the inspector with a clear and logical explanation of your reasoning, backing it up with the code text and the information above. Good luck! Flag for review