User: infinity, Location: New Jersey
Asked on: Thursday, October 3, 2024 at 4:48 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:22 am EST
Question: My wife is bugging me about the lousy city water we have and wants a whole house filter system installed. I've seen them with a pre-filter, two stages of filtering and conditioning, and then an output filter. My brother had a Rhino system by Aquasana that he liked. Any opinions? I'm not looking for reverse osmosis.
Okay, sounds like you're on the right track investigating whole house filtration. Your wife's concerns are valid – city water can have a host of issues, even when it meets regulatory standards. Let's break down the options, the Aquasana Rhino, and what to consider.
Why Whole House Filtration? Improved Water Quality
Reduces chlorine, chloramine, sediment, rust, herbicides, pesticides, VOCs (volatile organic compounds), and other contaminants that can affect taste, odor, and health.
Protection for Appliances
Reduces scale buildup in water heaters, dishwashers, washing machines, and other appliances, extending their lifespan and efficiency.
Better Skin and Hair
Reduced chlorine and other chemicals can lead to softer skin and less dry, brittle hair.
Peace of Mind
Knowing you're providing cleaner, safer water for your family.
Common Stages in Whole House Filtration Systems (like you described)
Pre-Filter (Sediment Filter)
Purpose
Removes larger particles like sand, silt, rust, and sediment.
Benefits
Protects the downstream filters from clogging prematurely, extending their lifespan and effectiveness. Typically, a 5-micron filter is a good starting point.2.
Stage 1 Filter (Often Carbon)
Purpose
Reduces chlorine, chloramine, herbicides, pesticides, VOCs, and other organic chemicals that affect taste and odor.
Types
Granular Activated Carbon (GAC), Catalytic Carbon (for chloramine), Carbon Block.
Benefits
Improves taste and odor, removes harmful chemicals.3.
Stage 2 Filter (Conditioning/Specialized)
Purpose
This stage varies widely depending on the specific system and water needs. Could be:
Scale Inhibitor
Adds a chemical (like polyphosphate) or uses a template assisted crystallization (TAC) media to prevent scale buildup.
KDF Media
Kills bacteria and reduces heavy metals.
pH Neutralizer
Raises the pH of acidic water to prevent corrosion of pipes.
Specific Contaminant Removal
Designed to target specific contaminants prevalent in your water (e.g., lead, arsenic). Requires water testing.
Benefits
Addresses specific water quality issues.4.
Post-Filter (Fine Filtration)
Purpose
Removes any remaining fine particles that may have passed through the earlier filters.
Benefits
Polishes the water for clarity and further contaminant removal.
Aquasana Rhino Systems (Like Your Brother Had)
Pros
Reputable Brand
Aquasana is a well-known and respected brand in water filtration.
Long Filter Life
Rhino systems often boast long filter lifespans (e.g., 6 months to 10 years, depending on model and usage), which can be more convenient.
Generally Good Performance
Users often report improved water taste, odor, and clarity.
Easy Installation
Relatively straightforward DIY installation (but professional installation is always recommended if you're not comfortable).
Specific Models
They have different Rhino models that address varying needs (e.g., whole house filter with salt-free softener).
Cons
Cost
Can be more expensive upfront than some other whole house filter systems.
Filter Replacement Costs
While the filters last a long time, replacement filters can be pricey.
Flow Rate
Some users have reported a slight decrease in water pressure, especially with older plumbing. Check the flow rate (gallons per minute - GPM) of the system and compare it to your household's needs.
Specific Needs
Standard Rhino systems might not address specific contaminants that are prevalent in your water. You might need to add a specialized pre- or post-filter.
Salt-Free Softening
If you get the Rhino with a salt-free softener, understand that it's not true "softening." It conditions the water to reduce scale, but it doesn't remove the calcium and magnesium that cause hardness.
Here's a step-by-step guide to help you make your decision
Water Testing is Crucial
Get your water tested by a certified lab. Don't rely solely on city water reports (although review them). Testing will identify the specific contaminants you need to target (e.g., lead, arsenic, bacteria, high levels of chlorine/chloramine, sediment, hardness). Contact your local water municipality for a water quality report.2. Determine Your Needs
Flow Rate
How many gallons per minute (GPM) do you need? Consider the number of people in your household and the number of appliances that use water simultaneously (showers, washing machine, dishwasher). Err on the side of a higher GPM rating to avoid pressure drops.
Contaminants of Concern
Based on your water test results, identify the specific contaminants you want to remove.
Budget
How much are you willing to spend on the system and replacement filters?3.
Research and Compare Systems
Aquasana Rhino
A good starting point, but consider if it addresses all your specific needs.
Other Brands
Look at brands like Springwell, iSpring, Pentair, Filtersmart and others. Read reviews, compare features, and check filter replacement costs.
Customizable Systems
Some companies allow you to build a custom system with specific filters to target your water issues.4.
Consider Installation
DIY vs. Professional
Are you comfortable with plumbing and basic tools? If not, hire a licensed plumber for installation. Improper installation can lead to leaks and other problems.5.
Read Reviews and Warranties
Customer Reviews
Pay attention to both positive and negative reviews. Look for patterns in the feedback.
Warranty
Check the warranty coverage for the system and its components.
Specific Questions to Ask Yourself
What is the primary reason for wanting a whole house filter? Taste/odor? Scale buildup? Specific health concerns? What is your water pressure like currently? A whole house filter can reduce pressure, so make sure the system you choose has a sufficient flow rate. Are you on a well or city water? Since you mentioned "city water," I'm assuming you're on a municipal system. What is your budget for the initial system and for ongoing filter replacements?In summary, getting your water tested is the most important first step. This will guide you to the right system and ensure you're not just throwing money at a generic solution. The Aquasana Rhino is a good option to consider, but compare it to other systems and make sure it addresses the specific needs revealed by your water test. Flag for review