User: fastline, Location: midwest usa
Asked on: Thursday, October 3, 2024 at 4:50 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:23 am EST
Question: As I work up a proposal for a building remodel, I would like to incorporate dimming on the OH lighting system. I am curious what dimmer controls you guys are reaching for? I am always surprised how many shops don't care to have dimming, but I am trying to work some numbers in the proposal to determine KWH savings when max lighting is not needed.I have also been in shops that have motion activated lighting. I just want to offer some optional strategies.
Okay, let's break down dimmer control options and motion-activated lighting for your remodel proposal, with an eye on energy savings and different shop needs.
Dimming Control Options: Considerations and Recommendations
Here's a breakdown of dimmer control types, along with pros and cons for shop environments, and popular brands: Phase-Cut Dimmers (Leading-Edge/Triac and Trailing-Edge/Reverse Phase) How They Work
These dimmers chop off a portion of the AC sine wave to reduce the power delivered to the lights.
Leading-Edge (Triac)
Older, cheaper technology. Can cause flickering and buzzing with some LED fixtures, especially at low dimming levels. More common in residential applications.
Trailing-Edge (Reverse Phase)
More modern, smoother dimming, generally better compatibility with LEDs. Considered the "premium" phase-cut option.
Pros
Relatively inexpensive (especially leading-edge). Widely available. Simple to install (often direct replacements for standard switches).
Cons
Can be noisy (buzzing/humming). Compatibility issues with some LED fixtures (flickering, limited dimming range). Requires careful selection of dimmers and dimmable LED drivers. Leading-edge is less efficient and can introduce more harmonic distortion into the electrical system.
Best For
Shops with a tight budget if you've thoroughly tested compatibility with the chosen LED fixtures. Trailing-edge is almost always preferable if the budget allows.
Brands
Lutron (Diva, Skylark), Leviton (SureSlide), Legrand (radiant), Eaton
0-10V Dimmers How They Work
A low-voltage DC signal (0-10V) is sent from the dimmer to the LED driver, controlling the light output. 0V = off or minimum light, 10V = maximum light. Requires LED drivers that specifically support 0-10V dimming.
Pros
Smooth, flicker-free dimming. Good compatibility with a wide range of LED fixtures (as long as they have 0-10V drivers). Can be used to control multiple fixtures simultaneously. Relatively energy efficient.
Cons
Requires 0-10V dimming compatible LED drivers. This can increase the initial cost of the fixtures. Requires running low-voltage control wiring in addition to the power wiring.
Best For
New installations or remodels where you are specifying the LED fixtures and can choose models with 0-10V dimming. Ideal for larger spaces with multiple fixtures.
Brands
Lutron (Grafik Eye QS), Leviton, Philips Advance, Fulham
DALI (Digital Addressable Lighting Interface) How They Work
A digital communication protocol that allows for individual control and monitoring of each lighting fixture.
Pros
Highly flexible and scalable. Precise control over each fixture. Advanced features like scene setting, scheduling, and energy monitoring. Good for building-wide lighting management systems.
Cons
More complex to install and program. Higher initial cost. Requires DALI-compatible LED drivers and a DALI controller.
Best For
Large shops, commercial buildings, or projects with complex lighting requirements and a desire for advanced control and monitoring. Not generally needed for smaller shops.
Brands
Tridonic, Osram, Philips, Helvar
Wireless Dimmers (Bluetooth, Zigbee, Wi-Fi) How They Work
Use wireless communication to control smart bulbs or fixtures.
Pros
Easy to install (no new wiring required in many cases). Convenient control via smartphone apps, voice assistants, or dedicated remotes. Can be integrated with other smart home/building systems. Offer flexibility for adding control without running new wires.
Cons
Can be more expensive than wired options. Reliance on a stable wireless network. Potential security vulnerabilities (especially with Wi-Fi). Compatibility issues between different brands/ecosystems.
Best For
Retrofit projects where running new wiring is difficult or expensive. Shops that want a modern, app-based control system. Careful consideration of security is important.
Brands
Philips Hue, Lutron Caseta, Sengled, Cree Lighting, LIFX
Key Considerations When Choosing Dimmer Controls for Shops
Compatibility
The most important factor. Ensure the dimmer is compatible with the LED fixtures (specifically the LED drivers). Check the dimmer manufacturer's compatibility list or test a sample fixture before committing to a large purchase.
Dimming Range
How low can the lights dim? Some dimmers have a limited dimming range, especially with LEDs. You want a smooth dimming curve down to a low level.
Flicker
Avoid dimmers that cause flickering, especially at low dimming levels. This can be distracting and even cause headaches.
Noise
Some dimmers (especially leading-edge) can produce audible buzzing or humming.
Ease of Use
The dimmer should be easy for employees to use and understand.
Installation
Consider the complexity of installation. Some dimmers require new wiring, while others are direct replacements for existing switches.
Energy Efficiency
Some dimming technologies are more energy-efficient than others. Trailing-edge and 0-10V are generally more efficient than leading-edge.
Cost
Balance the cost of the dimmer with its features and performance.
Future-Proofing
Consider whether the dimming system can be integrated with other building automation systems in the future.
Load Requirements
Check the total wattage that the dimming system can provide. Make sure you are under the load requirements.
Motion-Activated Lighting (Occupancy Sensors) How They Work
Sensors detect movement in a space and automatically turn the lights on. When no movement is detected for a set period of time, the lights turn off.
Types of Sensors
Passive Infrared (PIR)
Detects changes in infrared radiation (heat). Good for detecting movement in a direct line of sight.
Ultrasonic
Emits high-frequency sound waves and detects changes in the reflected waves caused by movement. Good for detecting movement around obstacles.
Dual Technology
Uses both PIR and ultrasonic technology to reduce false triggers.
Pros
Significant energy savings in areas that are not constantly occupied (e.g., storage rooms, restrooms, hallways). Convenience (hands-free operation). Increased safety (lights turn on automatically in dark areas).
Cons
Can be annoying if the lights turn off too quickly. May not be suitable for areas where constant lighting is required (e.g., assembly lines, machine shops). Can be prone to false triggers (e.g., from pets, drafts, or vibrations). Initial cost of the sensors and installation.
Best For
Storage areas, restrooms, offices, hallways, break rooms, and other areas where occupancy is intermittent.
Brands
Lutron, Leviton, Wattstopper, Hubbell Lighting Control Solutions
Calculating Potential Energy Savings
This is where you can add some real value to your proposal. Here's a simplified approach to estimate energy savings from dimming and motion-activated lighting
1. Dimming Savings:
Determine Baseline Usage
Calculate the total wattage of the existing or proposed lighting system. Multiply by the hours of operation per day and the number of days per year to get the annual energy consumption in kilowatt-hours (kWh). `Total Wattage (kW) Hours/Day Days/Year = Annual kWh Consumption`
Estimate Dimming Levels
Estimate how often the lights will be dimmed and to what level. For example: 2 hours per day at 100% brightness 4 hours per day at 75% brightness 2 hours per day at 50% brightness
Calculate Reduced Consumption
For each dimming level, calculate the reduced wattage. Multiply by the hours of operation to get the reduced energy consumption. `Wattage Dimming Level Hours/Day Days/Year = Annual kWh Consumption for each Level`
Calculate Savings
Subtract the reduced energy consumption from the baseline energy consumption to get the annual energy savings. Example: 100 LED lights at 20 watts each, 8 hours a day, 365 days a year = 5840 kWh. If you dim those lights to 50% power for 4 hours a day, you save 1460 kWh a year.
Monetary Savings
Multiply the annual energy savings by the cost per kWh to get the annual monetary savings.
2. Motion-Activated Lighting Savings
Determine Baseline Usage
As above, calculate the annual energy consumption of the lighting system in the area where you plan to install motion sensors.
Estimate Occupancy Rate
Estimate the percentage of time the area is actually occupied. For example, a storage room might only be occupied 20% of the time.
Calculate Reduced Consumption
Multiply the baseline energy consumption by the occupancy rate to get the reduced energy consumption.
Calculate Savings
Subtract the reduced energy consumption from the baseline energy consumption to get the annual energy savings.
Monetary Savings
Multiply the annual energy savings by the cost per kWh to get the annual monetary savings.
Important Notes
Accuracy
These are just estimates. Actual savings will vary depending on the specific usage patterns and the effectiveness of the dimming and motion-activated lighting systems.
Cost per kWh
Get an accurate cost per kWh from the local utility company.
Incentives
Check for rebates or incentives from the utility company or government agencies for installing energy-efficient lighting controls.
Lifecycle Cost
Consider the total cost of ownership, including the initial cost of the equipment, installation, and ongoing maintenance.
Proposal Structure
Here's how to incorporate this into your proposal:1.
Executive Summary
Highlight the potential energy savings and benefits of dimming and motion-activated lighting.2.
Existing Lighting Assessment
Describe the existing lighting system and its energy consumption.3.
Proposed Lighting System
Describe the proposed lighting system, including the types of fixtures, dimming controls, and motion sensors.4.
Energy Savings Analysis
Present the calculations for potential energy savings, including the assumptions used.5.
Cost Analysis
Compare the cost of the proposed lighting system to the cost of the existing system, including the cost of installation and any rebates or incentives.6.
Return on Investment (ROI)
Calculate the payback period for the investment in the new lighting system.7.
Options
Present different options for dimming controls and motion sensors, with varying levels of cost and performance.8.
Conclusion
Summarize the benefits of the proposed lighting system and recommend a course of action.
Example Proposal Snippet (Dimming Savings):"We propose incorporating 0-10V dimming controls for the overhead LED lighting in the workshop area. Based on our analysis, we estimate that the lights will be dimmed to an average of 75% brightness for 4 hours per day. This will result in an estimated annual energy savings of 2,500 kWh, with a cost savings of $375 per year (assuming a cost of $0.15 per kWh). The initial cost of the dimming controls is $500, resulting in a payback period of approximately 1.3 years."By providing a clear and compelling analysis of the potential energy savings, you can help your client make an informed decision and justify the investment in energy-efficient lighting controls. Good luck! Flag for review