User: nizak, Location: Humboldt
Asked on: Thursday, October 3, 2024 at 8:50 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:24 am EST
Question: I recently installed a 150CFM bath fan.It’s a .8 Sone noise level. I have successfully used this model for a few years with 0 issues.It requires a 6” duct.This time the HVAC contractor is someone I’ve never worked with and they did the venting. The fan is considerably noisy and seems to “cycke”as it runs.It will operate relatively quiet for about 30 seconds ( not as quiet as it should) but will then get louder.It appears to cycle this way.The soffit termination appears to be a 4” size.Could this be the problem?G.C. Is telling me that the fan is defective.I’m saying it’s the venting.
You are almost certainly correct: the 4" soffit termination is almost certainly the cause of the problem.
Here's a breakdown of why, and how to troubleshoot
Why a 4" Termination is the Likely Problem
Restricted Airflow
The 6" duct from the fan is designed to move 150 CFM of air efficiently. Forcing that same volume of air through a 4" opening dramatically restricts airflow. This creates back pressure and turbulence.
Noise
The turbulence caused by the restriction is what you're likely hearing. The fan motor is working harder to overcome the pressure, which generates more noise.
Cycling
The cycling noise you describe is indicative of the fan motor struggling to maintain its rated speed and airflow. As back pressure builds, the motor might slow down, then speed up again as the pressure fluctuates.
Potential Fan Damage
Over time, the restricted airflow can overheat and damage the fan motor.
Why the General Contractor's "Defective Fan" Claim is Unlikely You've used the same model before
You have a history of using this model successfully. It's highly unlikely that you'd suddenly receive a batch of defective fans, especially if the symptoms started immediately after the HVAC contractor's work.
Symptoms match venting issues
The specific symptoms you describe (noise, cycling) are classic indicators of venting problems.
Steps to Take & How to Explain It to the G.C.1. Document Everything
Photos/Videos
Take photos or videos of the 4" soffit termination. A short video demonstrating the cycling noise would be especially helpful.
Manufacturer Specs
Print out or have readily available the manufacturer's specifications for the fan, clearly stating the required 6" duct size and suggested termination size.
Local Codes
Check your local building codes regarding bath fan venting requirements. Most codes will specify the proper duct size based on CFM.2.
Politely But Firmly Explain the Issue to the G.C.
"I appreciate you considering the possibility of a defective fan, but based on my experience with this model, and the fact that the problem started immediately after the venting was installed, I strongly believe the 4" soffit termination is the cause." "The manufacturer's specifications require a 6" duct, and forcing 150 CFM of air through a 4" opening creates significant back pressure. This back pressure is what's causing the noise and cycling." "Restricting the airflow like this can also damage the fan motor over time." "I've checked local building codes, and they also specify the correct duct size for a fan with this CFM rating." (If applicable) "To properly troubleshoot this, we need to temporarily replace the 4" termination with a 6" termination. If the noise and cycling disappear, it will confirm that the venting is the problem."3.
Suggest a Test
The best way to prove your point (and potentially save everyone time and money) is to temporarily remove the 4" soffit termination entirely.
Be very careful doing this and ensure the area is safe and clear. Run the fan. If the noise and cycling disappear or drastically improve, that proves the termination is the issue. A less aggressive (but less conclusive) test is to partially remove the 4" termination so that you can see more of the duct opening inside the soffit. Does this reduce the noise?4. If the G.C. Still Insists on a "Defective Fan"
Offer a compromise: "Okay, let's assume for a moment it is the fan. Let's temporarily install a 6" termination to the existing ductwork while we wait for a replacement fan. If the new fan still makes the same noise with the correct venting, then we know it's a different issue. But if the new fan is quiet with the 6" vent, then we know that was the problem all along." This puts the onus on them to do the correct thing and prove their point.5.
Involve a Third Party (If Necessary)
If the G.C. remains resistant, you may need to involve a neutral third party, such as a building inspector or a different HVAC contractor, to provide an objective assessment.
What Needs to be Done
The HVAC contractor needs to replace the 4" soffit termination with a 6" termination (or larger, depending on local code requirements). The ideal solution would be a termination cap with a large opening and a backdraft damper. A larger, less restrictive termination will allow the fan to operate as intended, quietly and efficiently.By taking these steps, you can effectively communicate the problem to the G.C. and ensure that the venting is corrected, saving you from a noisy bathroom and potentially extending the life of your bath fan. Good luck! Flag for review