Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Separation of class 2 and 120 volt

User: JJWalecka, Location: New England

Asked on: Friday, October 4, 2024 at 12:05 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:25 am EST

Question: Is plastic carflex listed for use as a "barrier" to separate class 2 and power conductors? Or does it have to be a metal raceway

The NEC (National Electrical Code) doesn't explicitly use the term "barrier" when separating Class 2 and power conductors. However, the intent of the code is to ensure adequate physical separation and insulation to prevent hazardous voltage from contacting low-voltage circuits.Here's a breakdown of the relevant factors and why plastic carflex is generally not considered sufficient as the sole separation barrier in most typical scenarios: NEC 725.136 (Physical Separation)

This section is key. It covers the required separation between Class 2 and Class 3 circuits and power circuits.


725.136(D) Separation by Barriers

A barrier is acceptable but needs to be identified as suitable for the purpose.

Why carflex typically fails as a barrier



Not a Rigid Barrier

Flexible nonmetallic conduit (carflex) is, well, flexible. It's easily crushed, punctured, or displaced. This makes it an unreliable barrier against the mechanical stresses and potential insulation failure of higher-voltage power conductors. A barrier needs to be robust.

Listing and Identification

Carflex is typically listed as a
raceway, not a barrier. For a barrier to be accepted, it must be identified for that purpose. Carflex isn't.

Insulation Properties

While carflex is non-conductive, it's not designed or tested as a primary insulation barrier against sustained contact with damaged power conductors.

Metal Raceway (e.g., EMT, Rigid Conduit)

A properly grounded metal raceway offers significantly better protection:


Mechanical Protection

It's far more resistant to crushing, penetration, and displacement.

Grounding

If a power conductor's insulation fails and contacts the metal raceway, the resulting fault current will trip the circuit breaker, de-energizing the circuit and preventing a prolonged hazard.


Enclosure

Fully enclosed and grounded metal provides a very high degree of separation

Alternatives to Metal Raceway



Listed Barriers

The NEC allows "barriers" that are specifically listed and identified for the purpose of separating circuits of different voltages. These exist, but carflex isn't one of them.

Additional Insulation/Separation

In
some limited cases, additional insulation around the power conductors (e.g., using conductors rated for higher voltage than required) might be considered adequate in combination with some form of physical separation. This would require very careful evaluation and approval by the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ). It's rare and usually not practical.

Distance

A sufficient distance between the power and low-voltage circuits can satisfy the requirement. The NEC doesn't specify a precise distance, leaving it to the AHJ to determine what's adequate based on the specific circumstances.

In Conclusion

Plastic carflex is

unlikely to be accepted as the sole "barrier"
to separate Class 2 and power conductors in most situations. Metal raceway is a far more common and generally accepted solution. If using an alternative method, you must have it approved by the AHJ. Provide them with documentation that demonstrates it meets the intent of the code for safety and separation. This will include the physical description of the separation, material listings, voltage testing data, and expected fault tolerance. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question