User: Twiz, Location: Washington
Asked on: Friday, October 4, 2024 at 12:10 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:25 am EST
Question: I’m writing this in the matter of emergency lighting. The emergency lighting fixtures came with normal power wiring and emergency wiring in the same lighting whip. I installed these on the third level of an office building. I connected these whips to an emergency box and set a normal putter box next to it with a piece of m.c. in between. I made sure to label the normal power wires in the box connected to normal power wiring in the fixture whip that also has the labeled emergency wires in the whip as well. The emergency wires in the whip are red(connects to neutral) and blue(connects to hot) that run with the normal wires in the whip. My Forman said this is wrong and made us separate the wires and add another m.c. to the fixture which is taking way longer. We argued about it and I said if this is wrong what I have been doing why would the fixtures come made like this. Either way you go your going to have emergency and normal occupying the same space somewhere. I sighted 700.10b3. What would be the best move here. It’s almost the same as wiring am emergency lighting esrn.
Okay, this is a situation that needs careful consideration, referencing both code requirements and the manufacturer's instructions. Let's break it down
Understanding the Issue
Mixed Wiring
The core of the issue is having normal power conductors and emergency power conductors bundled together in the same flexible metal conduit (MC) whip feeding an emergency lighting fixture.
Separation of Systems
Electrical codes generally aim to separate normal and emergency systems to minimize the risk of a fault in the normal power system disabling the emergency lighting.
Article 700: Emergency Systems
This article of the NEC governs the installation of emergency systems. Your reference to 700.10(B)(3) is relevant and we'll examine it closely.
Manufacturer's Instructions
It is crucial to adhere to the manufacturer's instructions that come with the emergency lighting fixtures.
Analyzing NEC 700.10(B)(3)
Here's what NEC 700.10(B)(3) typically states (check your local code as it may have amendments):"Wiring for emergency circuits shall be kept entirely independent of all other wiring, equipment, and raceways and shall not enter the same raceway, cable, box, or cabinet with other wiring except:(1) Where common supply or return conductors are required.(2) In transfer switches.(3) In exit or emergency lighting fixtures supplied from two sources."
Key takeaway
The code generally prohibits mixing emergency and normal wiring.
Arguments for Your Installation1.
The Fixture Manufacturer's Design
The fact that the manufacturer provides the fixture with both normal and emergency wiring in a single whip is a strong argument. The manufacturer has already determined that this arrangement is acceptable for their fixture, and likely has testing and listings to back it up. They are responsible for the safety and compliance of their product.2.
700.10(B)(3) Exception (3)
You can argue that your installation falls under the exception 3, "...exit or emergency lighting fixtures supplied from two sources." The emergency lighting fixture is supplied from two sources: normal power and emergency power. The way the fixture is constructed with the two sets of wires in one whip supports this claim. The rationale behind this exception is that within the fixture, the normal and emergency wiring must come together to power the lamp or LED in an emergency. Therefore, allowing them to come together before the fixture, in the final whip run, is logical and doesn't introduce significant additional risk.3.
Equivalence to Emergency Lighting ESRN Setup
You are right about the similarity to an Emergency System Receptacle Network (ESRN). Typically these systems have normal and emergency power in the same cable that plugs into the light fixtures.
Arguments Against Your Installation (Your Foreman's Perspective)1.
Strict Interpretation of Separation
Your foreman may be taking a very strict interpretation of the separation requirement, arguing that any mixing of normal and emergency wiring before the physical fixture body is a violation.2.
Potential for Fault Propagation
Their concern may be that a fault (short circuit, ground fault) on the normal power conductors within the whip could potentially damage or compromise the emergency power conductors, defeating the purpose of the emergency system.3.
Local AHJ Interpretation
Ultimately, the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ - typically the electrical inspector) has the final say on what is code-compliant in your area. Their interpretation of 700.10(B)(3) is what matters.
Best Course of Action1.
Gather Documentation
Manufacturer's Instructions
Locate the exact installation instructions for the emergency lighting fixtures you're using. Emphasize any section that shows wiring diagrams or instructions for connecting the power feeds. If the manufacturer shows the bundled wiring as acceptable, this is powerful evidence.
Fixture Listing
Find the UL or other listing information for the fixture. The listing will specify the conditions under which the fixture is approved for use.
NEC Code Handbook
If you have access to the NEC Code Handbook, it often provides clarifying explanations and examples that can support your interpretation of 700.10(B)(3).
2.
Politely Discuss with Your Foreman (Again)
Present your documentation and reasoning clearly and respectfully. Explain how the fixture is designed, and how you believe the installation meets the intent of the code while adhering to the manufacturer's instructions.3.
Involve Your Supervisor/Project Manager
If you and your foreman still disagree, escalate the issue to your supervisor or project manager. They can help mediate and ensure that the installation is done correctly and in compliance.4.
Contact the Manufacturer's Technical Support
Call the emergency lighting fixture manufacturer's technical support line. Explain the situation and ask them to provide a written statement or clarification on whether the bundled wiring in the whip is acceptable for their fixture. This is strong evidence for your case.5.
Ask for an AHJ Ruling (If Necessary)
If all else fails, and especially if your foreman is adamant about changing the wiring, request a meeting with the local electrical inspector (AHJ). Present your documentation and arguments, and ask for their official interpretation of the code and whether your installation is acceptable. This is the most definitive way to resolve the issue. Be prepared to follow their decision.
Important Considerations
Documentation is Key
The more evidence you have to support your installation, the stronger your case will be.
Safety First
Regardless of the code interpretation, never compromise safety. If there's a legitimate concern about the integrity of the wiring, address it.
Maintain Professionalism
Keep the discussion respectful and focus on finding the correct and code-compliant solution.
Local Amendments
Check for any local amendments to the NEC in your jurisdiction, as these may affect the interpretation of the code.
In summary, your argument has merit because of the manufacturer-supplied wiring configuration and the exception in 700.10(B)(3). However, you need to present your case effectively with documentation and, if necessary, involve the AHJ. Good luck! Flag for review