Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: NEC 690.12 - RSID's for Solar Carport with Inverter AC Output Conductors Run Over a Building to Electrical Room - What Solution will Satisfy 690.12?

User: PV Designer, Location: California

Asked on: Friday, October 4, 2024 at 5:45 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:26 am EST

Question: Solar carports are generally considered ground mounts, and not subject to the rapid shutdown requirements of NEC 690.12.However, consider a carport with inverters mounted on its columns, the inverters are combined in a panel at the carport. The combined AC output conductors are then run underground to a nearby building, run up the exterior wall, over the rooftop, and down the opposite wall, to interconnect with the facility's main distribution panel in the the electrical room on the opposite side of the building from where the carport is located.The rapid shutdown requirements of 690.12 clearly apply to the inverter AC output conductors on the building. However, the question is whether the AHJ will accept the AC disconnect as a sufficient RSID, since only the AC conductors are in question here. My reading of 2020 NEC 690.12(C) and (D) suggests that the AC disconnect in the interior electrical room where the utility meter and disconnect are located is a sufficiently code compliant, safe and effective RSID for the conductors in question, satisfying both the intention and the letter of the code.My concern is that the AHJ may require RSID's on the DC side of the system, because these are specifically "listed" as RSID's.What are your thoughts on this? Do you have any experience with similar situations? Obviously, I will not quote you in any legal disputes, but I am curious to know if my thinking is off, or on target. What do you think?

You've presented a very common and tricky situation that highlights the tension between the letter of the NEC and its intent. Here's my take on it, based on my understanding of the code and experience with similar projects

Your Reasoning is Solid (and Often Correct in Practice):

Your argument that the AC disconnect in the electrical room, at the service entrance, can serve as the Rapid Shutdown Initiating Device (RSID) for the AC output conductors on the building is logically sound and often accepted by AHJs. Here's why: Focus on the Conductors in Question

690.12(C) and (D) specifically address the conductors that are "entering the building or passing over the building." Your proposed AC disconnect directly controls these conductors.


AC Disconnect Functionality

When the AC disconnect is opened, it de-energizes all AC conductors from the carport inverters that are present within/on the building. This is precisely the safety outcome 690.12 is trying to achieve: reducing voltage on those conductors to safe levels for firefighters.

No DC in the Building

Since the inverters are at the carport and only AC conductors run to the building, the
building itself doesn't contain any DC conductors that fall under 690.12's scope.

Intent of the Code

The primary intent of rapid shutdown is firefighter safety on the building. An AC disconnect that completely isolates the PV-generated AC power from the building effectively meets this intent.

Practical Considerations

Adding DC rapid shutdown devices at the carport adds cost and complexity, when, in this scenario, it doesn't necessarily improve safety on the building any more than the AC disconnect already does.

Why the AHJ Might Push Back (and How to Address It)

Despite the logic above, some AHJs might still insist on DC rapid shutdown due to the language in 690.12 mentioning listed devices or due to a rigid interpretation of the code. Here are the likely reasons and how to handle them:


"Listed" RSID Requirement Perception

Some AHJs fixate on the "listed" aspect of rapid shutdown devices and automatically assume it means DC. They might argue that AC disconnects are not explicitly listed as rapid shutdown devices. This is where you need to emphasize that the functionality and outcome of your proposed AC disconnect meets the intent of the code and, in this case, the AC disconnect is a listed component with a clear function.

Misunderstanding of System Architecture

The AHJ might not fully grasp that
no DC conductors are on the building. Clear and concise system diagrams are crucial.

General Hesitancy/Caution

Some AHJs are simply more conservative and prefer the perceived "safer" (and more common) solution of DC rapid shutdown.

How to Approach the AHJ


Early Communication is Key

Don't wait until the inspection to discuss this. Present your design to the AHJ during the permitting process.2.

Detailed System Diagram

Provide a clear, single-line diagram showing: Location of inverters. Routing of AC conductors (underground, on the building, etc.). Location of the AC disconnect. Point of interconnection with the utility. Voltages on the DC and AC side.3.

Clearly Articulate Your Rationale

In a written document (or verbally, then follow up in writing), explain why your proposed AC disconnect meets the intent of 690.12. Stress the safety benefit of isolating
all* PV-generated AC power from the building.4.

Cite Code Sections

Refer to specific sections of 690.12(C) and (D) to support your argument. Focus on the "conductors entering or passing over the building" language.
5.


Be Prepared to Compromise (Possibly)

While your reasoning is strong, be prepared for the AHJ to stand firm. If they insist on DC rapid shutdown, it might be more cost-effective to implement it rather than fight the issue. Consider asking for a compromise - perhaps only rapid shutdown on the arrays farthest from the disconnect.6.

Appeal (as a last resort)

If you truly believe your solution is code-compliant and the AHJ is being unreasonable, you can explore the appeals process outlined in your local jurisdiction.

Experience

I've seen similar situations play out both ways. I've had AHJs accept the AC disconnect as sufficient, especially when I've clearly articulated the design and its benefits. I've also had AHJs insist on DC rapid shutdown, even when it seemed redundant. The outcome often depends on the AHJ's specific interpretation, their familiarity with PV systems, and their willingness to consider alternative solutions.

In summary, your thinking is on target. However, success depends on clear communication, thorough documentation, and a willingness to work with the AHJ to find a solution that meets both their requirements and your project's needs.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question