Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Disconnecting means

User: JJWalecka, Location: New England

Asked on: Friday, October 4, 2024 at 7:24 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:27 am EST

Question: Some RTU units have an internal disconnecting means from the factory...where in the code does it state that the factory internal disconnect meets the requirements for equipment shut down

You're right, some RTUs do come with factory-installed disconnects. However, whether that disconnect meets code requirements for equipment shutdown is a critical question and not automatically assumed.Here's a breakdown of where the NEC (National Electrical Code) addresses this, and the considerations involved

Key NEC Sections & Considerations:
NEC 440.14 Location

For
air-conditioning and refrigerating equipment, this section generally requires a disconnecting means to be located within sight of the equipment and readily accessible. It's the primary section that governs this situation.

Exception to (A)

Allows the disconnecting means to be installed on or within the equipment if it is "capable of being locked in the open (off) position." This exception is where the factory-installed disconnect often comes into play.

Exception to (B)

Allows the disconnecting means to be mounted up to 50 feet away, if readily accessible. This section applies to rooftop installations, where the disconnect must be readily accessible from the ground (via ladder, stairs, etc.).


NEC 430.102 Location

This covers disconnecting means for motors and motor controllers in general. Because RTUs contain motors (for fans, compressors, etc.), this is relevant. Similar to 440.14, it generally requires the disconnect to be in sight of the motor/controller.

(B) Within Sight From

Generally, unless certain conditions are met.


(1) The disconnecting means is capable of being locked in the open position.
(2) The disconnecting means is installed remote to the motor, the location of the disconnecting means is field marked on the motor. NEC 440.12 Rating and Type

This section dictates the required rating for the disconnecting means. This is important because the factory installed disconnect must be rated for the voltage, motor full-load amps, and locked-rotor amps of the equipment.

NEC 110.3(B) Examination, Identification, Installation, and Use of Equipment.
This is a very general requirement, but critically important. It states that listed or labeled equipment must be installed and used in accordance with any instructions included in the listing or labeling. This means: If the RTU manufacturer's instructions state that the factory disconnect is suitable as the required disconnecting means, and it meets the lockable/rating requirements, then it may be acceptable. However: If the manufacturer's instructions require an external disconnect, then the factory disconnect does not meet code.Determining if the Factory Disconnect is Acceptable


Manufacturer's Instructions (MOST IMPORTANT)

Read the RTU's installation manual thoroughly. Look for specific statements about whether the factory disconnect is intended to serve as the required disconnecting means for servicing. The manufacturer will often state whether it is suitable for shutting down the entire unit for servicing.2.

Lockability

The factory disconnect
must be capable of being locked in the open (off) position. It typically needs a provision for a padlock or similar locking device.3.

Rating

Verify that the disconnect is rated appropriately for the RTU's voltage, FLA (Full Load Amps), and LRA (Locked Rotor Amps).4.

Accessibility

Even if the internal disconnect is acceptable, consider accessibility for servicing personnel. Is it easy to reach? Is it obstructed by other components? Practicality is important.5.

Local AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction)

Ultimately, the final determination rests with the electrical inspector. If there is
any doubt, consult with the AHJ before relying solely on the factory disconnect.

In summary:


The code
permits a factory-installed disconnect to serve as the required disconnecting means, if it meets specific requirements (lockable, properly rated) and* is specifically identified by the manufacturer as suitable for that purpose in the installation instructions. If the manufacturer does not explicitly say it is intended to serve as the disconnecting means, it should not be used as such.Always prioritize the manufacturer's instructions, and when in doubt, install an external disconnect. An external disconnect is often preferred because it is generally safer, more accessible, and easier to verify proper operation. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question