Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: New Service to Feed the EV charges

User: Electriman, Location: TX

Asked on: Saturday, October 5, 2024 at 12:28 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:27 am EST

Question: Hello every one,A customer is adding a hand full of Fast EV chargers. Due to the amount of power that is required to feed the chargers, he either needs to get a new service or upgrade the existing service. But new service would be in conflict of NEC 230.3 (one service for each building). Therefore, he only can upgrade the existing service. Is there any exception applicable to this case to explain two services are permitted for this commercial customer?Thank you in advance

You're right, NEC 230.3 generally limits a building to a single service. However, there are several exceptions you should explore that could permit a second service for the EV chargers.

Relevant NEC Exceptions to 230.3



230.2(D) Special Occupancy

Where additional services are permitted for special occupancies. This isn't directly related to EV chargers but may apply depending on the building's main use.


230.2(A)(1) Capacity Requirements

“Where the capacity requirements exceed 2000 amps at a supply voltage of 1000 volts or less.” This is a common exception when the existing service simply cannot handle the additional EV charger load. Perform a load calculation following Article 220, taking into account all existing loads plus the new EV chargers. Demonstrate with calculations that the existing service would be overloaded according to NEC requirements.

230.2(A)(2) Different Characteristics

“Where the different voltages, frequencies, or phases are required.” Less likely in this scenario for EV chargers, but still worth checking.

230.2(B)(3) Load Management

"For load management purposes, where all of the following conditions are met: (1) The building is under single management. (2) The total connected load is not less than 2000 kVA. (3) The additional service(s) is/are used only for the purposes of load reduction in response to a signal from the utility company or other authorized entity." If the customer has a large enough load, and the utility supports load shedding, this might be applicable.

Key Considerations & Steps


Load Calculation is Crucial

You must perform a detailed load calculation for the entire building, according to NEC Article 220, to determine the existing load and the added load of the EV chargers. Don't forget demand factors! If the calculation proves the existing service will be overloaded (or approaching overload) with the new EV chargers, you can justify using 230.2(A)(1). Include not only the calculated loads for the EV chargers, but also include any required safety factors (e.g., for continuous loads). Ensure the calculation is clear, detailed, and easy for the inspector to follow.
2.


Demand Factors for EV Chargers

Carefully apply demand factors to the EV charger loads according to NEC Article 625 (Electric Vehicle Charging System). Consider factors like: Number of chargers Likely simultaneous usage Smart charging capabilities (if applicable, to reduce demand)3.

Communication with the Utility

Talk to the local utility company. They may have specific requirements or limitations regarding service upgrades and the connection of EV chargers. They may also offer incentives for load management solutions. The utility's perspective on whether the existing service can handle the load is important.4.

Documentation is Key

Keep meticulous records of your load calculations, communication with the utility, and the rationale for choosing the solution you recommend.5.

Code Official Consultation

Before committing to a specific approach, consult with the local electrical inspector or authority having jurisdiction (AHJ). Explain the situation, present your load calculations, and ask for their interpretation of the code and their preferred solution. Getting their buy-in upfront will save you headaches later.

Why Upgrading Might Still Be Preferable (Even with an Exception)



Cost

While a second service might seem appealing, the long-term costs (separate metering, service charges) could be higher than upgrading the existing service.

Simplicity

One larger service is generally easier to manage and maintain than two separate services.


Future Capacity

Upgrading the existing service provides more capacity for future expansion.

In summary, start with a thorough load calculation. If that calculation demonstrates the existing service cannot handle the load, Exception 230.2(A)(1) becomes your strongest argument. Document everything and consult with the AHJ.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question