User: Ozzy2054, Location: Nevada
Asked on: Saturday, October 5, 2024 at 1:54 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:27 am EST
Question: Lets say I have both primary and secondary protection, any location. When sizing the transformer secondary OCPD, my understanding is that if the circuit breaker is 80% rated, I must multiply the transformer secondary FLA by a maximum of 125%. However, if I specify a 100% rated circuit breaker, then I do not have to multiply the transformer secondary FLA at all.For example:-2500KVA Transformer 12.47kV to 480/277V 3Ph 4W D-Y feeds a switchboard-Secondary FLA = 3007A-For simplicity, ignore kva rating at 65/75 deg C temperature winding riseIf my switchboard has 80% rated main breaker, then it should be sized as 4000A (next size up rule)If my switchboard has 100% rated main breaker (LV Power Circuit Breaker or 100% Rated Molded Case Circuit Breaker) then it should be sized as 3000A.This has always been my understanding, as with lot of the engineers I talk to. However, I was recently told this is incorrect and that 100% rated only applies to continuous loads (i.e not transformer ocpd sizing) and that I need to multiply by 125% whether or not the breaker is 80% rated or 100% Rated.What's everyone's thoughts on this?
You've articulated a common and understandable interpretation of the NEC rules, and you're right to question the conflicting advice. Let's break down the relevant sections of the NEC and clarify the proper application.
Key NEC Sections & Concepts Article 450: Transformers
This is the primary article governing transformer protection.
450.3(B): Secondary Protection
This section specifically addresses the overcurrent protection requirements on the secondary side of transformers.
240.6: Standard Ampere Ratings
This section outlines the standard sizes of overcurrent devices.
Article 100: Definition of Continuous Load
A load where the maximum current is expected to continue for 3 hours or more.
210.20(A): Overcurrent Protection
Overcurrent protection shall be rated for not less than 125% of the continuous load plus the noncontinuous load.
Analyzing the Situation
Your initial understanding is based on the principle that 100% rated breakers, by their design and listing, are capable of carrying 100% of their rated current continuously, without tripping. Therefore, the "125% rule" (which is primarily aimed at addressing the limitations of 80% rated breakers and continuous loads) would seemingly not apply.
However, the NEC primarily applies the 125% rule for transformer secondary overcurrent protection regardless of the breaker being 80% or 100% rated.The 125% Rule for Transformers (NEC 450.3(B))
NEC 450.3(B) requires the overcurrent protection on the secondary side of a transformer to be sized to protect the transformer itself. While the primary side has more flexibility, the secondary side overcurrent protection is typically governed by the 125% rule.
Why?
The intent is to protect the transformer from overloads and faults, regardless of the nature of the downstream load (continuous or non-continuous). Even if all the downstream loads are non-continuous, the transformer can still be subjected to an overload that could damage its windings if not protected.
Addressing the 100% Rated Breaker Argument
While 100% rated breakers can carry their full rated current continuously, the NEC requirements for transformer protection supersede that capability. The code mandates the 125% factor to ensure the transformer is adequately protected against sustained overloads, regardless of the breaker's continuous-current carrying capacity.
Therefore, the person who told you that you need to multiply by 125% whether or not the breaker is 80% rated or 100% rated for transformer secondary OCPD sizing is CORRECT!Your Example Revisited 2500 kVA Transformer
Secondary FLA = 3007A
80% Rated Breaker
3007A 1.25 = 3758.75A. You'd need to use the next standard size up which is 4000A.
100% Rated Breaker
3007A 1.25 = 3758.75A. You'd still need to use the next standard size up which is 4000A.
Key Takeaways1. Transformer Protection Priority
The primary goal of transformer secondary OCPD is to protect the transformer itself.2.
NEC 450.3(B) Rules
The NEC rules in 450.3(B) generally dictate the OCPD size on the secondary side.
3.
125% Rule Applies
You must apply the 125% factor to the transformer's secondary FLA when sizing the OCPD, regardless of whether it's an 80% rated or 100% rated breaker.4.
100% Rated Breakers and Continuous Loads
The benefit of a 100% rated breaker is realized when you have known downstream continuous loads that need to be supplied. However, that's a separate issue from the transformer protection itself.5.
Coordination
Remember to perform a proper short-circuit and coordination study to ensure your OCPD settings are appropriately coordinated and provide the necessary protection.
In summary, the 125% rule is still required even if you're using a 100% rated circuit breaker. Flag for review