Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Portable Generators?

User: jmellc, Location: Durham, NC

Asked on: Sunday, October 6, 2024 at 2:33 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:29 am EST

Question: I’m sure at this moment, one would have to take whatever generator the store has. But what’s the recent status of brands? I know Generac had issues awhile back. I had a Subaru that didn’t last long. Had a small Harbor Freight one that didn’t last either. Our plant has DeWalt that have been there a few years. They seemed ok the little I used them.

You're right, availability can be a big factor when you need a generator right now. But if you have a little time to research, here's a rundown of the recent generator brand landscape, taking into account common issues and general reputation

Things to Consider Beyond Brand:
Engine Type

This is HUGE.


Inverter Generators

These produce cleaner power, making them safe for sensitive electronics. They're also generally quieter and more fuel-efficient. Honda and Yamaha are kings here, but there are other good options.

Conventional Generators

Typically less expensive and more powerful for their size, but noisier and produce "dirtier" power.


Wattage Needs

Be realistic about what you need to power. Add up the running wattage of everything you want to use simultaneously, then add a surge wattage buffer (especially for appliances with motors).

Fuel Type

Gasoline, propane, natural gas, or dual-fuel (gasoline/propane). Each has pros and cons in terms of availability, storage, and cost.


Features

Electric start, remote start, CO sensors (a MUST), portability kits (wheels and handles), automatic voltage regulation (AVR).

Maintenance

Regular maintenance (oil changes, air filter cleaning, spark plug replacement) is crucial for any generator's lifespan.

Brand Breakdown



Honda



Pros

Top-tier reliability, quiet operation, excellent fuel efficiency (especially their inverter models), long lifespan, good resale value. Industry standard.


Cons

Expensive, can be a target for theft.

Best For

Home backup (inverter models), RVs, sensitive electronics, construction sites where noise is a concern.


Yamaha



Pros

Very similar to Honda in terms of quality, reliability, and quietness. Excellent inverter generators.


Cons

Expensive.

Best For

Similar applications as Honda.


Generac



Pros

Widely available, good range of sizes and features, automatic standby generators are popular.


Cons



The biggest concern with Generac is perceived quality control issues in recent years.
There have been reports of engine problems, electrical issues, and shorter lifespans than in the past. This is NOT to say all Generac units are bad, but do your research, read reviews, and consider extended warranties if you go this route. They've had recalls and class action lawsuits related to safety. Best For

Whole-house standby (with careful research), portable generators for general use.


Champion Power Equipment



Pros

Good value for the price, decent reliability for the cost, wide range of models. Their dual-fuel models are popular.


Cons

Not as refined as Honda or Yamaha, may not last as long, can be noisier.

Best For

Budget-conscious buyers, general-purpose use, occasional power outages.


DeWalt



Pros

Often powered by reliable engines (like Honda or Briggs & Stratton), good build quality.


Cons

Can be more expensive than some other brands in their class, not as wide a selection as some others.

Best For

Construction sites, professional use, users who want a durable and reliable generator.

The fact your plant has had good experience with them is a strong indicator.
Briggs & Stratton



Pros

Well-established brand, good range of models, decent value.


Cons

Reliability can vary depending on the model. Some models can be quite noisy.

Best For

General-purpose use, home backup, users who want a recognizable brand.


Westinghouse



Pros

Competitive pricing, decent feature set, some models have good reviews.


Cons

Not as well-established as some other brands, long-term reliability is still being evaluated.

Best For

Budget-conscious buyers, users who want a feature-rich generator at a lower price point.


Harbor Freight (Predator)



Pros

Very inexpensive.


Cons

Quality control is a major concern, reliability is questionable, short lifespan is common.

Generally, not recommended for anything critical.
Best For

Very occasional use, situations where you need a generator but can't afford anything else. Think of it as disposable.


Subaru (Robin Subaru)



Pros

Historically known for durable engines. They still make engines, but the generator market presence is more limited now.

Cons

May be harder to find parts and service. The quality may not be what it once was.

Key Takeaways and Recommendations


Prioritize Engine Quality

A reliable engine is the heart of a good generator. Brands like Honda and Yamaha are consistently top-rated. If you can afford it, they're worth the investment. Briggs and Stratton is a common engine and has good reputation.2.

Read Reviews

Before buying ANY generator, research specific models. Read reviews from multiple sources (Amazon, Home Depot, Lowe's, independent review sites). Pay attention to recurring issues and long-term reliability reports.3.

Consider Your Needs

Don't overbuy. Choose a generator that meets your wattage requirements without being unnecessarily large and expensive.4.

Maintenance is Key

No matter which brand you choose, regular maintenance is essential for a long lifespan. Follow the manufacturer's recommendations for oil changes, air filter cleaning, spark plug replacement, etc.5.

CO Sensor is a MUST

Carbon monoxide poisoning is a serious risk with generators. Ensure your generator has a functioning CO sensor with automatic shutoff.6.

Extended Warranties

If you're concerned about reliability (especially with brands like Generac), consider purchasing an extended warranty for added peace of mind.

In your specific situation



The positive experience your plant has had with DeWalt generators is significant.
That suggests they might be a good option for you, especially if they use a quality engine like Honda or Briggs & Stratton. Look into the specific DeWalt models your plant uses and read reviews. Avoid Harbor Freight unless you're truly in a pinch and understand the risks.

Good luck finding the right generator! Let me know if you have any more specific questions. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question