User: Ken_S, Location: NJ
Asked on: Sunday, October 6, 2024 at 1:50 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:29 am EST
Question: I have an installation I was looking at on a farm. There are two services, one for the home and one for the farm buildings. A PV system is to be installed on a barn, that barn has already has a feeder. The barn PV system will be broken into two arrays, one will supply power back to service 1, the other to service 2. I feel this installation may create some issues with section 225.30.Any thoughts?
You're right to be concerned about 225.30 with this setup. Let's break down why and what the potential problems are.
Understanding 225.30: Maximum Number of Disconnects
NEC 225.30 generally limits the number of disconnects for each building or structure supplied by a feeder or branch circuit to a maximum of six. There are exceptions, but they are narrowly defined.
The Problem with Your Proposed Setup
Here's why your plan likely violates 225.30, and where the issue lies:1. Two Services, Two Buildings
You have two separate services. One supplies power to the house (let's call it Building A), and the other supplies the farm buildings, including the barn (Building B). The barn has a feeder from the farm service (Service 2).2.
PV as an Additional Power Source to Each Service
You are proposing to supply power
back to both Service 1 (house) and Service 2 (farm buildings) from the barn's PV system. This means the barn now has three sources of power: The original feeder from Service 2. The PV array feeding Service 1 (effectively a feeder back to Service 1). The PV array feeding Service 2 (effectively a feeder back to Service 2).3. Disconnect Counts
Because of this, the Barn will have at least 3 disconnects: One disconnect for the original feeder from Service 2. One disconnect for the PV system feeding Service 1. One disconnect for the PV system feeding Service 2.
Why This is a Problem
The NEC aims to limit the number of disconnects to make it easier for emergency responders (firefighters, etc.) or service personnel to safely de-energize a building. Multiple disconnects complicate this process and increase the risk of someone accidentally leaving a circuit energized.
Possible Solutions and Considerations
Here are a few ways to approach this situation to comply with the NEC, along with their pros and cons: Option 1: Single Point of Interconnection Description
Interconnect all PV output to
one service. Typically, this would be to Service 2 (the farm service, already feeding the barn). Then, if needed, power can be distributed from that service to the house. Pros
Simple to implement, complies with 225.30 (assuming you can keep the disconnects at the barn to 6 or less).
Cons
May require upgrades to Service 2 to handle the total PV output and load. May not achieve the desired goal of directly offsetting the house's energy consumption with solar power. Also would require another feeder from the Farm Service back to the Home, which may create other 225.30 concerns.
Option 2: Load-Side Interconnection with Careful Circuit Design Description
Interconnect the PV to the load side of the main breaker of each service, but without creating a backfeed situation. This is
highly complex and requires very careful circuit design, monitoring, and control to ensure that power is never unintentionally fed back to the utility grid. Pros
Can achieve the goal of offsetting energy consumption at both the house and the farm.
Cons
Complex design and control system. Requires significant monitoring to ensure proper operation and prevent unintentional grid feed. Requires AHJ approval of the specific design.
Option 3: Two Separate PV Systems Description
Install two completely separate PV systems. One on the barn feeding Service 2, and another smaller system (possibly ground-mounted) dedicated to the house feeding Service 1.
Pros
Simplifies the electrical design. Easier to comply with 225.30 at each location.
Cons
May be more expensive due to needing two sets of equipment. May require more physical space.
Option 4: Consider the Feeder to the Barn as a Branch Circuit Description
If the barn feeder comes directly from the service equipment, and there are no overcurrent protective devices along the feeder path, the barn can be considered part of the same building as the source. If that is the case, you can have up to 6 disconnects at the barn location.
Pros
Easy to implement if applicable
Cons
May not apply. Feeder is typically required in barns, since barns do not have dwellings.
Important Considerations
Utility Interconnection Agreement
You must work closely with the utility company to ensure that your PV system meets their interconnection requirements. They will likely have specific rules about how and where you can interconnect, and they may not allow backfeeding to multiple services in this manner.
Rapid Shutdown
Pay close attention to NEC 690.12 regarding rapid shutdown requirements for PV systems. This will affect the placement and type of disconnects you need.
Engineering Review
This situation definitely requires a qualified electrical engineer to review the design, perform calculations, and ensure code compliance. Don't attempt to implement this yourself without professional expertise.
Local AHJ
Discuss your plans with the local Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) early in the process. They may have local interpretations or requirements that differ from the NEC.
In Summary:
Your initial assessment is correct: splitting the PV output to feed back to two separate services connected to different buildings is likely to create violations of NEC 225.30 and utility interconnection requirements. Explore the alternative solutions described above, and definitely involve a qualified electrical engineer and the local AHJ in the design and permitting process. Flag for review