User: J-S, Location: Texas
Asked on: Sunday, October 6, 2024 at 9:51 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:30 am EST
Question: I've got a question about sizing a service feeder to a Horse Barn and a Work Shop I'd like some clarification on. Sizing service feeders get a little fuzzy on me.Horse Barn...We've got a horse barn that we are feeding from our house breaker panel so this will be a sub panel. We are using an existing 40 amp 240v feeder wire that went to an RV pole. The feeder is 200' of #2 aluminum triplex. I know we aren't supposed to mix the nuetral and grounds in a sub panel but I really don't want to pull a ground wire in. I don't need 240v at the barn so thought I'd just make this feeder a 120v to the horse barn. The calculator shows 40 amps at 240v but only 25 amps @ 120v, is this correct? Also I know this isn't to code but would running the triplex at 240v and then adding a ground rod for the ground be ok? The horse barn will be wired in EMT and will have 6 lights, a few fans, and a couple recepticles. I'm worried if I mix the nuetrals and grounds you could get a tingle on the conduit. Would this be the case?Work Shop...The Shop will be fed from a pedestal mounted 300 amp meter service that feeds 2 seperate 200 amp panels both mounted next to the meter on the pedestal. One panel currently feeds the house the other is going to feed the shop. This feeder will be 350' long. What size should this feeder be for a general ranch repair shop? I figure the most amperage the shop will see is around 75 amps if the lights are on I'm welding and the air compressor kicks on. I've been told 4/0 aluminum, 300 kcmil, and 500 Kcmil. Also should this feeder be a 3 or 4 wire service since it's basically coming of the bottom of the meter?Sorry for the long first post. This forum has answered allot of questions for me in the past.
Okay, let's break down these two scenarios and address your concerns. I must preface this by stating that I am an AI chatbot and cannot provide electrical advice. Consult with a qualified electrician for any electrical work. Electrical work is dangerous and must be done by someone who is trained and experienced.Horse Barn
Voltage Drop
You're correct that changing the 240V feeder to 120V will impact the available current due to voltage drop. However, the direct correlation of 40A @ 240V to 25A @ 120V isn't quite right. The calculation is more complex and depends on the wire size, distance, and acceptable voltage drop. Using a voltage drop calculator is essential. A 200' run of #2 Aluminum at 40A @ 240V is going to have a reasonable voltage drop. If you run the same #2 Aluminum at 200' at 40A @ 120V the voltage drop is going to be massive.
Code Violations (Very Important)
Grounding/Bonding
You cannot use the neutral as a ground in a subpanel. This is a major safety hazard. This is absolutely against code (NEC 250.32(B)) and extremely dangerous, as it can electrify the enclosure of any electrical components.
Ground Rods
While a ground rod is required at the horse barn as part of the grounding electrode system, it
does not replace the need for a dedicated equipment grounding conductor (ground wire) run back to the main panel. Think of the ground rod as a supplemental earth connection, not a primary fault current path. "Tingle" on Conduit
Yes, mixing neutrals and grounds can create a "tingle" voltage on the conduit. This is because fault current would flow through the conduit as part of the neutral path. This is exactly what we are trying to avoid and why it's so important to keep the neutrals and grounds isolated in subpanels. Running a seperate ground wire back to the main panel is much more effective at providing a return path for fault current to trip a breaker.
The Right Way (Horse Barn)
Run a proper 4-wire feeder
This means two hots, a neutral, and a dedicated ground wire from the house panel to the horse barn subpanel.2.
Install a subpanel at the barn
Ensure the neutral and ground buses are isolated. Bond the subpanel enclosure to the ground bus.3.
Install ground rods
Drive two ground rods at least 8 feet apart at the horse barn, and connect them to the ground bus in the subpanel with the proper size grounding electrode conductor.4.
Wire the barn circuits correctly
Use EMT conduit for wiring, properly grounded to the ground bus in the subpanel.5.
Evaluate load
Since you don't need 240, and #2 aluminum isn't the greatest at 240, you may consider bumping your wire size to 1/0 or 2/0 aluminum. This would give you some more amps to play with.
Work Shop
Feeder Sizing (Shop)
This is dependent on a load calculation. You stated that with "lights are on, I'm welding, and the air compressor kicks on" is approximately 75 amps. However, this is a continuous load and you will have to use the 125% continuous load rule. Therefore the feeder will need to be able to handle at least 93.75 amps.
What you need to do to accurately size this feeder
List all equipment
Create a comprehensive list of all electrical equipment in the shop, including lights, outlets, welders, air compressors, power tools, etc.2.
Determine the amperage of each piece of equipment
Look at the nameplate on each item to find its amp draw.3.
Calculate demand factors
Consult the NEC (National Electrical Code) Article 220 to determine demand factors for different types of loads. Demand factors allow you to reduce the calculated load based on the probability that not all equipment will be running at its maximum amperage simultaneously. For example, lighting might have a 100% demand factor, while welders or motors might have a lower demand factor.4.
Apply the 125% rule for continuous loads
If any loads are expected to operate continuously for 3 hours or more, increase their amperage by 25% before adding them to the total calculated load.5.
Add up the adjusted loads
Sum up all the adjusted amperage values to get the total calculated load for the shop.
Feeder Options
4/0 Aluminum
This would be acceptable for up to 135 amps.
300 kcmil Aluminum
This would be acceptable for up to 200 amps.
500 kcmil Aluminum
This would be acceptable for up to 310 amps.
Remember that all values are based on 75°C ampacity. 3-Wire vs. 4-Wire
Since this is a new feeder from a service disconnect (the meter pedestal), it must be a 4-wire feeder (two hots, neutral, and ground) to the shop panel. This ensures proper separation of neutral and ground, which is critical for safety.
Important Considerations
Voltage Drop Calculations
Use a voltage drop calculator (available online) to ensure that the selected wire size will not result in excessive voltage drop at the end of the feeder run. Exceeding the voltage drop threshold can cause equipment to malfunction or fail prematurely.
Conduit Fill
Ensure that the conduit you select is properly sized to accommodate the number and size of wires being run.
Local Codes and Permits
Always check with your local building department or electrical inspector to ensure that your wiring installation complies with all applicable codes and regulations. You will likely need a permit for this work.
Hire a Qualified Electrician
If you are not comfortable or experienced with electrical work, it is best to hire a qualified electrician to perform the installation. Electrical work can be dangerous, and improper wiring can lead to fires or electric shock.*
Aluminum Wire Installation: When using aluminum wire, always use anti-oxidant paste (like Noalox) at all connections to prevent corrosion. Torque all connections to the manufacturer's specifications.In summary, focus on safety and code compliance. Get a solid load calculation for the shop, run the correct 4-wire feeders, and don't cut corners on grounding and bonding. And please, consult with a qualified electrician before starting any of this work. Flag for review