User: g-and-h_electric, Location: northern illinois
Asked on: Sunday, October 6, 2024 at 11:19 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:30 am EST
Question: Hey guys, I am running into an issue that makes no sense to me. I am hoping maybe someone here has an answer.I am the supervising electrician for an HVAC+ Electric shop, so all electrical problem (and their solutions) fall on me.I have been running into an issue where the customer wants a heat pump system to replace a conventional gas furnace and central ac system. The estimator and sales staff are going "size for size. By that I mean the furnace ( which is still gas) has the same BTU output, and the A/C has the same tonnage. The problem that I am running into is that the outdoor unit (on a 3 ton system) is now wanting a 42 Amp circuit, 45 Amp breaker. We agree that this needs #8 wire.My question is why with the outdoor unit being more efficient and having variable speed and inverter drives, am I needing a larger circuit???? I would have expected the exact opposite. I am confused.Howard
Howard, you're right to be confused! It does seem counterintuitive. Here's a breakdown of why you're likely seeing this discrepancy, even with more efficient systems
1. Locked Rotor Amps (LRA) and Minimum Circuit Ampacity (MCA)
LRA is Key
While running amperage might be lower on inverter-driven systems, the Locked Rotor Amps (LRA) for the compressor can still be significantly high. LRA is the inrush current when the compressor starts. Even with soft starting, the LRA has to be accounted for in the breaker sizing.
MCA Dictates Wire Size
The Minimum Circuit Ampacity (MCA) is the minimum amperage your circuit conductors must be rated for. It's calculated based on the nameplate information, including the compressor's rated load amps (RLA), fan motor amps, and any auxiliary heating elements.
Overcurrent Protection (Breaker Size)
The breaker size is calculated based on MCA but can be higher than the running amps due to LRA. The NEC allows for specific overcurrent protection rules based on the motor type and equipment specifications.
Here's why new systems might have higher LRA/MCA despite being more efficient overall
High-Efficiency Compressors
Ironically, some high-efficiency compressors, while consuming less energy during normal operation, might have higher LRA values because of their design (e.g., optimized for specific operating conditions).
Added Features/Components
The new heat pump likely has additional components that draw power, even if they are efficient. These could include:
Inverter Board
The inverter board itself consumes some power.
Supplemental Resistance Heat
Some heat pumps include supplemental resistance heating (electric heat strips) for emergency heat or when the heat pump can't keep up. These are often hidden within the specs and contribute significantly to the required circuit size. This is the most likely culprit if you are seeing a large jump.
Defrost Cycle Heaters
Heat pumps need to defrost the outdoor coil in the winter. This often involves electric resistance heaters that are separate from the supplemental heat strips.
More Sophisticated Controls
Advanced controls and sensors consume a small amount of power.
Nameplate Discrepancies
Manufacturers may have changed their testing procedures or safety margins, leading to higher nameplate values. It's always safest to adhere to the nameplate ratings.
What to Check to Solve the Mystery
Review the Nameplate Carefully
This is the most critical step.
Pay close attention to the following values: MCA (Minimum Circuit Ampacity)
This must be used to determine your wire gauge.
MOCP (Maximum Overcurrent Protection)
This is the maximum breaker size allowed.
RLA (Rated Load Amps)
LRA (Locked Rotor Amps)
Supplemental Heater Amps
Look for any mention of auxiliary or supplemental heat strips and their wattage/amperage.2.
Consult the Manufacturer's Specifications
Download the installation manual for the exact outdoor unit model number. The manual will often have a detailed electrical section with sizing recommendations and wiring diagrams.3.
Verify the Existing Wiring
Confirm the existing wiring is actually what you think it is. It's possible the original system was undersized, or the wiring has been changed over time.4.
Consider Diversity
The NEC allows for diversity factors in some situations, but generally not for residential HVAC equipment. It's best to avoid applying diversity unless you have a very clear and justifiable reason to do so.5.
Double-Check Your Calculations
Ensure you're using the correct NEC tables for conductor ampacity and overcurrent protection. Use a voltage drop calculator to confirm your wire size is adequate for the run length.6.
Communicate with the Sales Team
Make sure the sales team is using the nameplate values from the exact model being installed, and they are not making assumptions based on tonnage.7.
Call the Manufacturer's Technical Support
If you're still unsure, call the manufacturer's tech support line. They can provide clarification on the unit's electrical requirements and help you troubleshoot.
In summary: While efficiency has improved, the MCA and breaker size are driven by the worst-case scenario (LRA and supplemental heat), which may be higher on modern systems due to compressor design, added features, and/or updated testing standards. Always use the nameplate values and manufacturer specifications to determine the correct wiring and overcurrent protection.Let me know the model number, and I can try to help you look up the specs myself. Good luck! Flag for review